That's a tantalizingly simple and intuitive comparison that everyone can understand and relate to. Unfortunately a nation's economy is so utterly unlike a household economy that the comparison is downright dangerous, because it leads to harmful false assumptions like "national debt is always a bad thing", "a nation must always 'earn' more than it spends at all times", and "an economy can never grow in a nation with debt".
I'm no economic wizard but it really surprised me that how everyone in Europe and many in the States are prescribing austerity, when basic history from this very century frequently demonstrates that austerity can lead to economic damage. Yes you can always find programs that can and should be cut back in any developed society, but considering debt to be the central and only problem in a situation where the debtor defines the very money it "owes" seems a little shortsighted to me.
So the default action is austerity, the IMF signed off on it because they feared that the euro's breakup would be catastrophically worse than almost any amount of austerity in europe.
Making something that is not politically viable is a politician’s job – and they refuse to do it.
Additionally, a 3rd option worth consideration: letting individual countries default.
Then Greece would be OK, and the German banks about to fall like dominoes. Then the Germans might have become more reasonable about a bailout.
After all, they would really be bailing out not the Greek people, but German banks that shouldn't have bought bonds from crooked Greek politicians and Goldman Sachs.
I don't see how any of that is the Greek people's fault, and in the mythical "free market" said German banks would have been allowed to go bust years ago.
http://whereistheoutrage.net/domestic-issues/budget/budget-d...
And sure, unlike households, nations have the option of printing more money to pay off their debts. Unfortunately that doesn't generally work too well (see also: Zimbabwe, Weimar Germany).
This is not surprising: a surplus means that the government is removing more money from the economy than it's adding, something which is rarely warranted absent a large current account surplus and/or an economy operating at full capacity.
You need to understand the sector financial balances.
About your examples, the first sentence of the Wikipedia article for Zimbabwe is: [1]
"Hyperinflation in Zimbabwe began shortly after destruction of productive capacity in Zimbabwe's civil war and confiscation of private farms."
While in Weimar Germany the French occupation of the Ruhr valley, the at that time most important industrial region of Germany, directly preceded the hyperinflation. ( And arguably the Beer Hall Putsch [2], Hitlers first attempt to seize power, was the more important event in '23.)
That's why my original comment is about: Assuming that a nation is like a household--i.e., that at some point it obviously should earn more than it spends, because that's how a household operates--leads to conclusions that aren't always supported by history.
Weimar Germany's situation partly mirrors the one today. To deal with hyperinflation and a collapsing economy, in '31 Chancellor Brüning cut spending by 30%. It eventually led to a budget surplus but at the cost of 30% unemployment. Those events helped set the stage for what followed in WW2. Obviously the comparison is tangential, but it's interesting to think about nonetheless.
See: http://www.guardian.co.uk/global/2011/nov/24/debt-crisis-ger... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperinflation_in_the_Weimar_Re...
You may be right, but it seems there is more than just our current situation to consider. There are long-term ramifications of that debt. At some point, we can't just keep borrowing. It might be working for us today, but like the sprinting marathon runner, eventually it will catch up to us.
And yes, America is currently the most powerful economy in the world's history, and that's why it has an AAA credit rating despite its fairly disastrous finances. But barring total implosion, China'll be the top dog within a decade or so, and what happens then?
If in a hypothetical alternate universe the US had a civil war tomorrow, it could have a massive budget surplus and yet it'd probably find that nobody would be willing to lend to it regardless, because the climate of repayment would be so uncertain.
In today's real world, the US has the power to print its own money. In very real terms it can define the very term "debt" as whatever it pleases. That, combined with its status as a massive buyer of foreign goods, history of entrepreneurship and growth, history of corrective action by the Fed, insanely powerful military, and so on, means that it could owe 100x times as much as it does today, and nations would probably still happily lend.
A nation is not a household. It doesn't reach some magic number "lending ceiling" where everyone else says, "you owe 100 trillion and 1 dollars, we're not gonna lend any more" like might happen to a regular person with a credit card. A "AAA" rating is just some label that some private company makes up.
So the issue isn't some dollar amount drawn out of an economist's hat, but rather the real trust inferred from a nation's geopolitical position.
Any real students of economics please do correct me, as I have no doubt my reasoning is flawed somewhere. But this is how I currently understand it.
I don't think Keynes' model is perfect. I'm excited to see what new kinds of models emerge after this depression -- we have a lot more data to play with. However, at this stage, it makes a lot more sense to stick with models that have kind of worked sometimes rather than to just operate off of pure, baseless speculation.
The problem is ignoring the reality that at some point the government cannot issue more debt. The US government has been in structural deficit for all but a few of the past 40 years. If we look at the funny money of state and local pension assumptions there's even more stimulus. OF COURSE when that's withdrawn the economy slows.
It doesn't matter if the fiscal multiplier is 0.5 or 1.5 when the government simply can't issue more debt. Multipliers matter when a government has decisions to make, when it can't issue more debt there are no decisions to be made.
It's instructive to remember that we match our deficit spending with debt issuance by legal fiat and not for any real operational reason. We could just as well deficit spend freely with no debt issuance (and no, it would not be more inflationary.
Of course, treasuries are a risk free savings vehicle for the private sector and world at large, and they play an important role in managing the payments system (though not one that couldn't be replace), so I'm not suggesting that we stop issuing debt. But it's important to understand how the system works so we can stop with the silly notion that we are just scraping by on the good graces of Treasury buyers.
And, "constant growth" depends on a structurally sound economy. Well, if the economy has been shaped to meet demand from a necessarily contracting customer -- the government -- its structure gets distorted. Add in the distortions from crazy federal credit policy (Fannie / Freddie). Now we have an economy that must reallocate productive resources to meet real demand -- but no one has a clue where that demand actually will be because we're so distant from the environment supporting it.
tldr; 40 years of government stimulus, in various dimensions, has fundamentally detoriated the economy's ability to deliver "constant positive growth." We've gone past the point where we can outgrow the debt growth needed to fuel this government stimulus growth model.
The only thing that would probably help Greece is massive debt foregiveness (bankruptcy if applied to individuals or companies) which isn't a "stimulus" so much as a gift. Again if it worked like a regular bankruptcy they'd agree to pay off part of their debt on a plan, but be forgiven a bunch of it, and their credit would suck for many years to follow.
Really? Than tell me what other non-austerity policy is being proposed. We're not talking about what is being pursued. The discussion is about the merits of the alternatives to austerity. Massive debt forgiveness is one although at this point it's a complete fantasy. What else have you got?
Intl macro isn't really my field, so there may be errors in that description.
i.e. stimulus, in Keynesian terms.
(Thinking about economics in terms of common sense and morality is generally unhelpful.)
So you need less and less effective stimuli programs, the higher the dept to GDP ratio is. ( And I do not know if anyone does claim that dept-financed stimulus is the cure for any economic ill. But if not enough money is the problem, one can simply print that stuff.)
You're correct about inflation but unfortunately their in the Euro so they either have to leave it or suffer a very long and painful internal deflation.
[Greek/US dual citizen here]
Having lived in Greece for upwards of a decade, during the particularly transitional time from ~1988-2004, this is not in line with my experience. Hear me out before writing me off as an apologist :)
Greece has a large problem with collecting the taxes they claim citizens owe but not a large problem with collecting a large fraction of GDP. According to the World Bank, they are right in line with Sweden and France (http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/GC.TAX.TOTL.GD.ZS). These numbers are corroborated by the OECD (PDF warning http://www.oecd.org/newsroom/41498733.pdf). [Edit: I wrote Sweden and France when I meant to write Spain and France; I apologize for the error but I have left it lest someone think I am trying to whitewash :-)]
Greece has collected plenty of money; we overspent, and we spent stupidly i.e. in ways that obtained either votes or kickbacks, and not in ways that improved the economy or the life of the common person. As just one example, look at the paltry investment of the Greek government in its only competitive advantage, the tourism business. The cast and crew of "Mamma Mia" did a better job promoting tourism in Greece than any Ministry of Tourism effort. Spain, Italy, and Turkey are eating our lunch.
We also got used to almost five decades of "free" foreign money through the Marshall plan, post-communist hysteria leading to US military aid and military bases, EEC/EU growth funds, and having our debt priced as if it were of German quality.
In my opinion, the tax evasion is a serious social justice problem, but it is not a serious budgetary problem. The bulk of Greece's public budget is supplied by ordinary people making ordinary incomes, and it is a travesty that the wealthiest manage to dodge contributing proportionately. But that does not mean the government does not have enough money to do a good job.
I would love to believe that the government has failed due to being starved of resources; at least then a solution like taking on more debt would be plausible. With the situation as it stands, I can only respond with our poet laureate Seferis' exasperated lament, "Everywhere I go, Greece wounds me".
Part of my problem with the statistics you link is that the measure is limited because it's known that US revenues are in the 16-19% range but they are listed here at 9%. Loathe as I am to cite the Heritage Foundation they are the most complete figures on wikipedia and show Greece heavily lagging France and Spain.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_tax_revenu...
Next, the black market in Greece is estimated at 25% of GDP which inflates official collection percentages even more.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_evasion_and_corruption_in_G...
Finally, it really doesn't matter that they collect some nebulous "large share of gdp". What matters is that the scale of evasion is far greater than Greece's immediate problems.
But Nikos Lekkas, the head of the Greek tax inspectorate, the SDOE ... insisted that Greece could easily pay off its debts if taxes due for payment were paid into the Greek state's coffers.
”Tax evasion in Greece has reached 12 to 15 per cent of the gross national product... That is €40 to €45bn per year. If we could recover even half of that, Greece would have solved the problem.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/financialcrisis/9319799/G...
You raise an interesting question, to which I don't have a conclusive immediate response. I'll have to dig deeper to really know. The numbers on the US do seem out of line with well-known facts. However, here's another ~30% estimate from Eurostat (http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/statistics_explained/index....). Given the conflicting reports, I can only say that it's theoretically possible that Heritage is right and OECD/Worldbank/Eurostat are jointly wrong. If I had to weigh Heritage's ideology and their likely expertise on European economic statistics, as compared to lined-up answers from OECD/WorldBank/Eurostat I know where I'd bet. Still, the 9% reported for the US does seem troubling. I have a research project for the evening.
As for the scale of tax evasion and whether it could plug the hole: it's really, really hard to have an objective opinion here. My inner Greek is saying of course SDOE claims that tax evasion is the main problem. I can't prove that they're wrong, and I don't want to pollute the discussion with personal anecdotes. I'll only add that the SDOE claims don't link to any examinable research.
Thank you for an interesting counterpoint :)
[Edit: the Eurostat data shows Greece parallel to Spain but way behind France... so at this point I'm going to tentatively retract the comparison to France pending further research, but I think I am still persuaded that Greece has a tax base that commands a significant-enough fraction of GDP for them to manage responsibly]
This is not to say that there wasn't gross economic mismanagement on the part of the Greek government, but focusing on that distracts from the real solution.
UPDATE: I'm in complete agreement with everyone pointing out that the problems aren't identical. Perhaps the question is whether, if you were to summarize the causes Euro crisis in broad terms, you ought to mention Greece's economic mismanagement first or the overall crash of the financial markets as the more important factor. My assertion is the latter, mostly echoing Stglitz's analysis here:
Spain is closer to Ireland in terms of housing market effects on economic downturn, but ultimately each economy functions on a different system, so it's not entirely wrong to attribute economic problems to separate causes. There is some overlap, of course, but it's definitely not identical.
Just to be clear, my answer is: Each country's problems are rooted in the collapse of the US housing market and the resulting financial crunch. The country-to-country variations are there and they're significant, but secondary.
I find it funny when Keynesians talk about bubbles. What do you think happens when you set interest rates absurdly low? You could make the argument it stimulates the economy, sure, but at what cost?
Schiff's misfire is especially relevant to this discussion, because it demonstrates the Austrian school's grossly flawed understanding of public finance and our monetary system (despite having valuable things to say at times).
Actually for me from the point of view of Mises and his praxeology everyone who uses his methodology to advise a policy is just guessing and expecting that his views are coherent with reality.[1]
Austrian school is very deep, and not a monolithic bloc like mises.org loves to say, there were Austrian economists who were not Mises and disagreed with his methodology, including Machlup and Wieser who were Mises student and teacher respectively.
[1]: More of that in here: http://mises.org/mofase/ch4.asp It's just my interpretation of his view.
http://gregmankiw.blogspot.com/2012/12/a-krugman-puzzler.htm...
I'm definitely pro-Krugman.
If you're interested, there are some particular blog posts about the history of the austerity movement and why it's ridiculous:
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/02/opinion/02krugman.html -- is a good place to start.
But I'm not in the mood to argue about it, so have a pleasant day.
For instance, the Debt Ceiling crisis of 2011 [1] is a perfect example of how these kind of psuedoscientific ideas can cause real harm to a country. Especially given how readily certain groups (coughrepublicanscough) are willing to accept these ideas with virtually zero backing or acceptance from established economists.
See also: Everything Paul Krugman has ever written.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_debt-ceiling_cris...
[2] http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/