This is not surprising: a surplus means that the government is removing more money from the economy than it's adding, something which is rarely warranted absent a large current account surplus and/or an economy operating at full capacity.
You need to understand the sector financial balances.
About your examples, the first sentence of the Wikipedia article for Zimbabwe is: [1]
"Hyperinflation in Zimbabwe began shortly after destruction of productive capacity in Zimbabwe's civil war and confiscation of private farms."
While in Weimar Germany the French occupation of the Ruhr valley, the at that time most important industrial region of Germany, directly preceded the hyperinflation. ( And arguably the Beer Hall Putsch [2], Hitlers first attempt to seize power, was the more important event in '23.)
That's why my original comment is about: Assuming that a nation is like a household--i.e., that at some point it obviously should earn more than it spends, because that's how a household operates--leads to conclusions that aren't always supported by history.
Weimar Germany's situation partly mirrors the one today. To deal with hyperinflation and a collapsing economy, in '31 Chancellor Brüning cut spending by 30%. It eventually led to a budget surplus but at the cost of 30% unemployment. Those events helped set the stage for what followed in WW2. Obviously the comparison is tangential, but it's interesting to think about nonetheless.
See: http://www.guardian.co.uk/global/2011/nov/24/debt-crisis-ger... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperinflation_in_the_Weimar_Re...
You may be right, but it seems there is more than just our current situation to consider. There are long-term ramifications of that debt. At some point, we can't just keep borrowing. It might be working for us today, but like the sprinting marathon runner, eventually it will catch up to us.
And yes, America is currently the most powerful economy in the world's history, and that's why it has an AAA credit rating despite its fairly disastrous finances. But barring total implosion, China'll be the top dog within a decade or so, and what happens then?
If in a hypothetical alternate universe the US had a civil war tomorrow, it could have a massive budget surplus and yet it'd probably find that nobody would be willing to lend to it regardless, because the climate of repayment would be so uncertain.
In today's real world, the US has the power to print its own money. In very real terms it can define the very term "debt" as whatever it pleases. That, combined with its status as a massive buyer of foreign goods, history of entrepreneurship and growth, history of corrective action by the Fed, insanely powerful military, and so on, means that it could owe 100x times as much as it does today, and nations would probably still happily lend.
A nation is not a household. It doesn't reach some magic number "lending ceiling" where everyone else says, "you owe 100 trillion and 1 dollars, we're not gonna lend any more" like might happen to a regular person with a credit card. A "AAA" rating is just some label that some private company makes up.
So the issue isn't some dollar amount drawn out of an economist's hat, but rather the real trust inferred from a nation's geopolitical position.
Any real students of economics please do correct me, as I have no doubt my reasoning is flawed somewhere. But this is how I currently understand it.
http://whereistheoutrage.net/domestic-issues/budget/budget-d...
And sure, unlike households, nations have the option of printing more money to pay off their debts. Unfortunately that doesn't generally work too well (see also: Zimbabwe, Weimar Germany).