News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI Is Throwing a Roadside Picnic by ricardobeat on Saturday October 10, 2026 @01:44PM (#50035275)
Why wouldn’t the AI be able to answer questions about the proofs or organize a talk? Those are pretty much the things it excels at, exploring and summarizing previous knowledge. The problem is the volume of questions and data a human needs to step through to arrive at the same understanding.
Re:AI Is Throwing a Roadside Picnic by kurthr on Saturday October 10, 2026 @01:47PM (#50035308)
Apparently, the knowledge isn't in the data set, and the explanations are gobbledygook. They certainly summarize well, but it seems that if the "understanding" isn't already baked in, then expanding the source description doesn't really clarify it. Maybe in the future?
Re:AI Is Throwing a Roadside Picnic by ndriscoll on Saturday October 10, 2026 @01:54PM (#50035378)
What does apparently here mean? Is there an account of an expert sharing their attempts to get a model to explain the results and key ideas to them (for a topic they're familiar with) in an interactive session, and having it fail?

For somebody deeply familiar with a topic and all the nuance around the problem and approaches that didn't work, I'd be quite surprised if they couldn't cajole it into explaining what finally did work in terms they understand. Unless it turned out that these proofs were just well beyond anything humans were anywhere near being able to figure out, in which case, no great loss that the AI figured it out because we were nowhere near it.

Re:AI Is Throwing a Roadside Picnic by scotty79 on Saturday October 10, 2026 @05:17PM (#50037285)
> explanations are gobbledygook

To humans? To check if the explanations actually make sense we would have to pause the new AI in while it's rediscovering the result and steer it with the explanation to see if it arrives at the result faster or slower/same.

It very well may be that explnations need to be further explained until they don't sound like gobbledygook to humans. If that's harder than arriving at the result then it's a sign of how far ahead AI actually is.

Re:AI Is Throwing a Roadside Picnic by figure8 on Sunday October 11, 2026 @12:00PM (#50044680)
Yes. These explanations are possible and will improve. For example: https://youtu.be/mtU4op2kMWI?is=Tr-d91BvFEsVNmiL
Re:AI Is Throwing a Roadside Picnic by ASalazarMX on Tuesday October 13, 2026 @05:41PM (#50079264)
Why isn't it doing that right now?