Re:AI Is Throwing a Roadside Picnic
by ndriscoll on Saturday October 10, 2026 @01:54PM
(#50035378)
What does apparently here mean? Is there an account of an expert sharing their attempts to get a model to explain the results and key ideas to them (for a topic they're familiar with) in an interactive session, and having it fail?
For somebody deeply familiar with a topic and all the nuance around the problem and approaches that didn't work, I'd be quite surprised if they couldn't cajole it into explaining what finally did work in terms they understand. Unless it turned out that these proofs were just well beyond anything humans were anywhere near being able to figure out, in which case, no great loss that the AI figured it out because we were nowhere near it.
For somebody deeply familiar with a topic and all the nuance around the problem and approaches that didn't work, I'd be quite surprised if they couldn't cajole it into explaining what finally did work in terms they understand. Unless it turned out that these proofs were just well beyond anything humans were anywhere near being able to figure out, in which case, no great loss that the AI figured it out because we were nowhere near it.