News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by jorgeleo on Thursday January 03, 2013 @09:12AM (#5002390)
In other news, people are still looking for the inventor of the hammer to charge him with multiple accounts of manslaughter, consequence of every death in which his invention was used. People with sore thumbs are waiting for a verdict before presenting their griefs.

Faraday commented: "I am not guilty of the use of electricity in Guantanamo"

Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by suby on Thursday January 03, 2013 @09:29AM (#5002449)
This is not a fair comparison. A hammer has multiple purposes. In general, it is not an instrument intended to cause harm. Even a gun can be used for a purpose other than causing harm to others -- it can be argued that it serves as a deterrent to violence.

What other purpose could gambling software be used for? It's irrelevant whether it was sold to overseas countries since, given the nature of the internet, New Yorkers would have access to those sites.

I'm not saying that I think what is happening is right, I just think your comparison is unfair.

Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by betterunix on Thursday January 03, 2013 @10:34AM (#5002752)
"What other purpose could gambling software be used for?"

Not all gambling is illegal. New York State itself has a gambling operation, it is called the lottery and it serves as a way to extract money from poor people. There are casinos in New York State, on reservations.

"It's irrelevant whether it was sold to overseas countries since, given the nature of the internet, New Yorkers would have access to those sites."

That is a slippery slope. Hacker News does not censor its comments; that would make HN illegal in China. Do you really want to say that one jurisdiction's laws should apply elsewhere, just because of the Internet?

The Internet is a communication system. If New Yorkers cannot gamble in a country where it is legal by communicating their bets over the Internet, New York is engaged in censorship; arresting someone who wrote software that was used by New Yorkers who ignored that censorship is something I would have expected from China or Iran.

Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by hef19898 on Friday January 04, 2013 @04:00AM (#5006849)
Comletely agree. Following this logic, the internet and all web services could be regulated using the most most severe laws on this planet due to the global nature of the internet.

What this shows is, at least for me, frightening trend to ignore the souverenity of foreign states when you consider them less powerfull than yourself. Germany is doing it with Switzerland for example too.

Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by rprasad on Thursday January 03, 2013 @04:47PM (#5004892)
Basic misunderstanding of international law on your part.

A "service", website, or software program is considered to take place where the user is located, not where the website is located. This standard was set decades ago (in relation to services) and extends quite well to websites.

Thus, the gambling in your example would be treated by international law as occuring in NY. Moreover, by choosing to do business with NY residents (unless such business is minor or incidental), the gambling websites would be subjecting themselves to the jurisdiction of NY for criminal law purposes).

Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by jeremyjh on Thursday January 03, 2013 @10:01AM (#5002591)
>What other purpose could gambling software be used for?

It could be lawfully used for gambling in OTHER countries. But actually this question is absurd. Writing gambling software is not illegal in New York. The burden of establishing a lawful motive is not on the defendant; instead the prosecution must prove that the activity he conducted was directly in support of illegal activity. That is a big difference.

Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by jonknee on Thursday January 03, 2013 @09:55AM (#5002571)
> What other purpose could gambling software be used for? It's irrelevant whether it was sold to overseas countries since, given the nature of the internet, New Yorkers would have access to those sites.

That's absolutely relevant. There are US companies that make slot machines. Most places in the country their products are illegal, just like the activities that this gambling software allows for. If an underground casino gets busted and is found to have slot machines, it's not the maker of the slot machines that is in trouble (unless there is evidence they were sold illegally).

Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by Mvandenbergh on Thursday January 03, 2013 @10:16AM (#5002668)
Jack Daniels is famously distilled in a dry county where its sale would be illegal.
Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by jlgreco on Thursday January 03, 2013 @11:51AM (#5003196)
And you can bet there are a hell of a lot of people in that county that will buy jack in an adjacent county and drive back home to drink it.
Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by icambron on Thursday January 03, 2013 @03:17PM (#5004395)
Which is legal in that county.
Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by jlgreco on Thursday January 03, 2013 @08:23PM (#5005759)
The legality or lack of it really is irrelevant to Jack Daniels. If someone brings the jack back into the county, then sells it, that is not Jack Daniels problem.
Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by nicholassmith on Thursday January 03, 2013 @10:25AM (#5002712)
You raise an interesting point about boundaries in the internet age. The comparison is unfair, but I do think it's perfectly relevant that it went overseas as it's not up to the software developer to also make sure that the sites are prohibiting American users, he's simply making a tool that's been using for the purpose it wasn't sold for.
Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by jorgeleo on Thursday January 03, 2013 @11:04AM (#5002908)
I believe that the comparison is fair because "he's simply making a tool that's been using for the purpose it wasn't sold for".

All the tools in the comparison are used in a manner that was not intended by the creator. The point is that it is unfair to charge the creator for the misuse of the tool. The problem is that in our society some "legal-oriented" people think of themselves as very smart because they believe to have attacked the root of the problem; this is under the rationale of "if we eliminate the source, we eliminate all its misuse" (as a side bar, the same rationale is used by the entertainment industry). The problem with this rational is that it destroy the good uses of the tool. And it has a double domino effect, one of chilling some creators (in this case some developers), and one of the thrill of the power on legally hurting someone (I got him! how smart and powerful I am).

In reality it hurts the very thing that they claim to defend: the land of the free.

Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by rorrr on Thursday January 03, 2013 @09:33AM (#5002470)
> What other purpose could gambling software be used for?

Educational.

Recreational (no money involved).

Research (like to collect gambling data).

To learn how to code and/or how games/strategies work.

Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by eriksank on Thursday January 03, 2013 @10:00AM (#5002588)
Well, it may not even matter. As you can see they are very heavy-handed. That means they do not fear any reprisals for this. That is obviously where the problem is. Ultimately, respect is always based on the fear for reprisals.
Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by danielweber on Thursday January 03, 2013 @09:31AM (#5002461)
While there are things to be concerned about with this case, this is pretty silly.

He sold gambling software while living in a state where gambling was illegal.

I'm all ears for arguments that gambling shouldn't be illegal or that prosecutors abuse their authority or many other arguments.

Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by fr0sty on Thursday January 03, 2013 @11:02AM (#5002894)
>He sold gambling software while living in a state where gambling was illegal.

Jack Daniels Whiskey is made and sold by a distillery in a county where selling liquor is illegal.

Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by rprasad on Thursday January 03, 2013 @04:50PM (#5004902)
Where selling liquor to consumers is illegal. It's perfectly legal in Moore County to sell liquor to retailers and wholesalers.
Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by obstacle1 on Thursday January 03, 2013 @09:33PM (#5005963)
The programmer in question wasn't selling gambling services to consumers, he was selling gambling software to "retailers and wholesalers" who in turn served gambling consumers.
Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by dfxm12 on Thursday January 03, 2013 @11:00AM (#5002882)
Is selling gambling software illegal in the state though?

It might seem like a pedantic question, but laws can be very narrow in scope or vague in meaning. "Gambling" and "Selling gambling software" are legally two different things.

Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by danielweber on Thursday January 03, 2013 @11:49AM (#5003183)
Oh, that is a very very good question. And it borders on extremely stupid to be making something that is illegal to use in your jurisdiction without first consulting a very good lawyer.

Maybe his actions were, indeed, perfectly legal, and this is entirely a prosecutor abusing his power. But we have to be able to see a distinction between him selling something like a hammer, which isn't illegal to use in his jurisdiction, and gambling software, which probably is illegal to use in his jurisdiction.

Covering your eyes and not figuring out if your actions are legal or not is a pretty crappy defense.

Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by pyre on Thursday January 03, 2013 @12:19PM (#5003361)

  > extremely stupid to be making something that is
  > illegal to use in your jurisdiction
He was making it in the jurisdiction, but selling out outside of the jurisdiction. He was making gambling software and selling it to businesses in locales where gambling is legal.

If he was making slot machines and selling them to legal casinos (e.g. in Las Vegas), do you think that he would have been busted like this? Highly doubtful.

This happened because his customers were crossing the line with the product, but -- to carry the analogy -- I doubt a slot machine maker would be held accountable if Caesar's Palace decided to open up an illegal gambling operation with the slot machines. The issue here is that the main offenders (foreign casinos) are outside of the state's jurisdiction, so they are going after the only person that they do have in their jurisdiction.

Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by danielweber on Thursday January 03, 2013 @12:52PM (#5003523)
I suspect people who manufacture slot machines have retained legal counsel that tell them what they need to do to follow the local law.

If he were growing marijuana and selling it to people where marijuana is legal, no one would have trouble understanding this concept: hire a lawyer very early on. He only got a lawyer after the cops descended on him, and then only crappy ones he found on the Internet.

I don't know the specifics of the law, and you don't either.

(I shouldn't have to say this, again, but I'm not saying there wasn't prosecutorial abuse here. Neither does this guy, because he hoped he could ignore the question.)

Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by pyre on Thursday January 03, 2013 @01:53PM (#5003886)
Drugs are a bad analogy as production and mere possession are illegal.

A better analogy:

  - Drugs are legal to possess, but the act of buying them is illegal
    (in the US).
  - This guy makes an e-commerce software package designed specifically
    for selling drugs.
  - This guy only sells the software to companies in Amsterdam.
  - He's arrested because one of the companies in Amsterdam is selling
    illegally to US citizens.
  - The government puts a gun to his head and tells him to hack into
    his customers' websites in a scene straight out of Operation
    Swordfish
I doubt that a lawyer would have helped him with this though. Unless I read the article wrong, he was being prosecuted/threatened in New York state, but was operating in the state of Arizona. He may be in accordance with all local (Arizona) laws, but was arrested and shipped off to New York state for some reason.
Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by danielweber on Thursday January 03, 2013 @02:18PM (#5004042)
Gambling, like drugs, is heavily regulated. Maybe it shouldn't be, but it is, and this is well known by every American. You also wouldn't start a firearm company or a brewery or a boutique cigar manufacturing without hiring a lawyer.

I don't know the law, and neither do you, and neither did this guy. If he had spent a few thousand of that $2.3 million on a lawyer he would be better informed and had someone on retainer.

Maybe he would have found out some simple way to comply.

Maybe he would have found out there was no way to comply.

Maybe he would have found out that he was already completely complying and this is just your "Operation Swordfish" scenario.

But, since Operation Swordfish has been brought up, I'm out.

Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by pyre on Thursday January 03, 2013 @07:11PM (#5005541)
I do agree that this guy should have had a lawyer, even just as a go-to person for stuff relating to the law. He was running a business, and not consulting a lawyer from time to time is probably a bad idea. For example, if he was ever sued, he would want to have a lawyer on speed-dial, rather than flipping through the Yellowpages trying to find a lawyer while under stress.

My general thought is that it's quite possible that his lawyer would not have foreseen this turn of events. His lawyer probably would have referenced local, state, and Federal law on this, but could have easily not seen that another state would try to prosecute him for his clients offering online gambling to residents of that state.

(I think it goes without saying that a lawyer probably would not have foreseen the government offering him a plea bargain to commit a Federal -- and international -- crime in order to plead guilty to a lesser charge)

Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by tossacct on Thursday January 03, 2013 @02:43PM (#5004182)
"Marijuana" is not illegal.

It is illegal to do certain things with marijuana. Possession is one of those things. Growing, distributing, selling, processing, all fall under the category of possession.

It is not illegal to write about marijuana, sing songs about it, paint pictures of it, talk about it, or trade photographs of it.

"Gambling" is not illegal.

It is illegal to gamble in certain ways. One of those ways is when a gambling participant wins anything of tangible value greater than what they paid to play the game. This is why some children's arcades that give tickets for games of luck are legal, and some carnival games are legal. Your winnings are required by law be worth less than what you paid to play.

Playing poker is not illegal, playing bingo is not illegal, playing slots is not illegal, playing blackjack is not illegal, guessing who will win the presidential election is not illegal, and guessing how much rain will fall next Tuesday is not illegal. Just don't gamble for tangible value while you do these things!

Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by hef19898 on Friday January 04, 2013 @04:04AM (#5006857)
Probably the NY AG was after someone elses ass and just decided that he could get all the information need way more easily from the programmer than using his own means? And when he realised that his strongarming didn't work, it was decided to actually put th programmer to trial. Just my theory...
Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by carbocation on Thursday January 03, 2013 @09:39AM (#5002495)
> He sold gambling software while living in a state where gambling was illegal.

"He sold a Bugatti Veyron in a state where driving over 75mph was illegal."

Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by DoggettCK on Thursday January 03, 2013 @10:05AM (#5002613)
"He sold fireworks in a county where it's illegal to set off fireworks."
Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by carbocation on Thursday January 03, 2013 @12:03PM (#5003279)
Unless (a) the sale of fireworks is prohibited, (b) fireworks are wrong in and of themselves and therefore can have no moral or lawful use, or (c) the owner is not just selling fireworks but advocating their unlawful use, I see no issue with selling fireworks in a county where setting them off is prohibited.
Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by andrewcooke on Thursday January 03, 2013 @10:10AM (#5002633)
but he sold them to people outside the country, where using fireworks is legal, right? it was those people that sold them back to where it is illegal... (if i understand correctly).
Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by PeterisP on Thursday January 03, 2013 @12:22PM (#5003371)
It would and should be perfectly ok to manufacture fireworks and run a wholesale fireworks export operation in such counties.
Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by laurent123456 on Thursday January 03, 2013 @10:04AM (#5002610)
> "He sold a Bugatti Veyron in a state where driving over 75mph was illegal."

With gambling software, the only thing you can do is illegal gambling. With a Bugatti Veyron, well as long as its speed is not locked at 75mph+, you can drive it all your life without doing anything illegal.

Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by pavel_lishin on Thursday January 03, 2013 @10:12AM (#5002647)
> With gambling software, the only thing you can do is illegal gambling.

You can also do legal gambling.

Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by chc on Thursday January 03, 2013 @01:35PM (#5003776)
Not in a context where gambling is illegal, you can't.
Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by Goronmon on Thursday January 03, 2013 @03:08PM (#5004339)
"Gambling is illegal where it is illegal" is a bit of a tautology don't you think? Unless you are saying gambling is never legal anywhere, in which case you are wrong.
Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by chc on Thursday January 03, 2013 @03:24PM (#5004439)
> "Gambling is illegal where it is illegal" is a bit of a tautology don't you think?

Absolutely. And that appears to be the context in which Laurent was using it. carbocation compared selling a sports car in a jurisdiction with a low speed limit to selling gambling software in a jurisdiction where gambling is illegal. Laurent replied that drivers of the sports car could still obey the law, while users of the gambling software would always be disobeying that jurisdiction's laws.

I'm not sure I find the argument all that compelling, but it seems to me that people are arguing with a premise that is tautologically true.

Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by carbocation on Thursday January 03, 2013 @04:22PM (#5004742)
> while users of the gambling software would always be disobeying that jurisdiction's laws

(1) Only if they are gambling with the gambling software. They could be using it for non-illegal gaming purposes (such as free online poker where no money is involved), for research, for education, etc. Gambling is illegal in this hypothetical jurisdiction, not software that allows one to gamble.

(2) Just as the Veyron can be produced in one jurisdiction and used elsewhere, gambling software can be produced in one jurisdiction and sold to people who then use it elsewhere. From the article, this is, indeed, what the software author claims to have done.

In other words, software that can be used for behavior that is illegal in one jurisdiction can quite possibly be used for legal purposes in that same jurisdiction (1) or for the same purpose in a jurisdiction where such behavior is legal (2).

Saying that you can't gamble in a place where gambling is illegal doesn't advance the discussion because nobody has yet disagreed with that explicitly or tacitly, as far as I can tell.

Re:Write Gambling Software, Go to Prison by carbocation on Thursday January 03, 2013 @10:10AM (#5002636)
> With a Bugatti Veyron, well as long as its speed is not locked at 75mph+, you can drive it all your life without doing anything illegal.

That's a good part of my point.

> With gambling software, the only thing you can do is illegal gambling.

That's untrue.