News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by akoboldfrying on Monday October 05, 2026 @04:45PM (#49970444)
I'm coming to saulpw's house tomorrow at noon with a gun, and I'm gonna make them pay.

If a policeman notices the sentence above on my phone screen during a routine traffic stop, the response you want him to take is... nothing?

Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by soerxpso on Monday October 05, 2026 @05:04PM (#49970716)
For the record, under current US law, it is not illegal to have a sentence in your locally-stored notes on your phone outlining a plan to commit a crime. There has to be an overt act. The police in that instance could inform the intended victim, surveil you, etc, but they would not be able to successfully charge you with attempted murder. It's not illegal to be considering committing a crime, even if you have a tendency to write down your thoughts.

The law in this particular case, which seems to be intended for threats that you actually send to someone, is being interpreted broadly to apply to any "threat" that you transmit to a server. So in your hypothetical, the legality would depend on whether your notes are backed up to icloud or not.

Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by wolfy1993 on Monday October 05, 2026 @05:21PM (#49970966)
>the legality would depend on whether your notes are backed up to icloud or not

I agree, and it's nuts.

This feels like less of an issue with anthropic per say as it is a broad reading/misuse of the law's original intent.

Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by openasocket on Monday October 05, 2026 @06:13PM (#49971602)
This is true for the general criminal conspiracy law, but be aware that an “overt act” doesn’t have to be an illegal act, just some action in furtherance of that crime. That can be purchasing a weapon, or scouting out a location. There may also be other laws in play depending on the specifics
Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by Arodex on Monday October 05, 2026 @06:36PM (#49971771)
Just having saulpw's physical address is already furtherance of that possible crime.

The commenters here are cute little HNers who think they have found a loophole in the law. They are not the first ones innover their head.

Spoiler: the law is written in words, and those words aren't strictly executed like in a computer program, they are interpreted by actual humans who can see what you are trying to do and will stamp it out.

Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by ls612 on Monday October 05, 2026 @10:20PM (#49973422)
Yup. HNers (and so many normies) believe that there are well defined rules they can follow and be safe. Spoiler, there is one law in the real world and that is might makes right, and you have no might, so therefore you will never be right. China for its many flaws at least is honest about this.
Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by akoboldfrying on Monday October 05, 2026 @05:21PM (#49970954)
You're absolutely right, at least according to my own quick check on Gemini. I find this state of affairs amazing.

In my country, no "overt act" is required, but both here and in the US a "conspiracy to commit" charge requires an agreement with a second party. This is indeed consistent with a very broad interpretation of "no thought crimes".

Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by devin on Monday October 05, 2026 @04:57PM (#49970619)
Correct. Nevermind how ridiculously contrived the scenario you've just concocted is.
Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by ruszki on Monday October 05, 2026 @05:27PM (#49971047)
Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by autoexec on Monday October 05, 2026 @06:45PM (#49971834)
FYI this links to "Key & Peele - Rap Album Confessions"
Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by ndjdndndnd on Monday October 05, 2026 @06:08PM (#49971557)
its not contrived just because you recognize how silly the argument its arguing against is
Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by jrflowers on Monday October 05, 2026 @06:18PM (#49971624)
> If a policeman notices the sentence above on my phone screen during a routine traffic stop, the response you want him to take is... nothing?

Anybody showing a cop their hacker news comments at a traffic stop should be arrested, for harassing the police

Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by autoexec on Monday October 05, 2026 @06:55PM (#49971925)
You joke, but part of the issue here is we're supposed to have laws that keep cops from reading over everything we type and using it to turn us all into crime suspects. There's a whole constitutional amendment about that, but our personal "papers and effects" that should be protected against unreasonable searches are increasingly really "owned" by others who are all too happy to snitch.

Part of me says that the solution is stop entering any personal data into any device and service you don't own, but I'm not sure if that's really what we want considering that there are zero private cell phones. Even desktops and laptops aren't 100% owned by you these days. The only thing you can really do is keep them offline 100% of the time so they can't spy on you, but that seems like a lot to demand.

Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by salawat on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @12:56AM (#49988396)
They want the network state secured and operating by their rules so they can leverage it's power, while ensuring the proles are kept from doing the same via surveillance.

It's been very obvious for at least the last decade that was the direction things were going.

Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by naasking on Monday October 05, 2026 @04:51PM (#49970522)
Do you really think reading a snippet like that completely out of context should qualify as probable cause?
Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by akoboldfrying on Monday October 05, 2026 @05:24PM (#49971017)
Yes!

When you read something describing in detail a person's intent to do something very bad, in a place where they write things that they intend to do, and which in the past they have in fact consistently done, you don't attach any significance to that at all?

Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by anigbrowl on Monday October 05, 2026 @06:37PM (#49971772)
I certainly think a police officer that stumbled across such a thing would be justified in asking follow-up questions like 'hey, what's this about you going to shoot someone?' and then maybe making an arrest based on your replies/demeanor.

'Probable cause' should involve a degree of certainty, because 'possible cause' would be altogether too loose of a standard. It's possible that you're intending to shootme and you just mentioned saulpw to throw other HN users off the scent. Possibilities are only limited by the assessor's imagination.

Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by rolosa on Monday October 05, 2026 @05:39PM (#49971209)
How can you prove that it's not just me writing a dark and morbid story?
Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by akoboldfrying on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @08:40PM (#49986341)
Suppose you go further: You write the "story", and "agree" with a friend to carry it out. Then you go to a gun store and buy a gun ("overt act").

How can I prove that all this is not just a dark and morbid roleplay?

And yet US federal law will convict you for conspiracy to commit murder on this evidence, as I understand it.

If you think the "dark and morbid story" defence is reason enough not to make writing the threat down a crime, why do you think the "dark and morbid roleplay" defence is unsound?

Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by jrflowers on Monday October 05, 2026 @06:25PM (#49971677)
How does the cop at the traffic stop know that your username is akoboldfrying? Did you tell them? If so, why, at a traffic stop, did you do that?

Are you posting threats on hacker news while you are driving? And the cop was close enough to see your username and what you wrote? Is that why you were pulled over?

Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by akoboldfrying on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @08:45PM (#49986388)
I don't see how any of these questions are relevant to the point I'm making.

Do you dispute that people sometimes discover things about other people? Do you dispute that things a person discovers about another person can change the first person's assessment of what the second person might do next?

Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by jrflowers on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @01:28AM (#49988618)
> Do you dispute that people…

> Do you dispute that things…

I don’t see how any of these questions are relevant to the point I’m making.

Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by akoboldfrying on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @05:04AM (#49990123)
What is the point you're making?

Because it seems to me that you are merely picking apart concrete details of an example situation that are not relevant to the general issue that the example is clearly trying to demonstrate.

I was reaching for a scenario that concisely demonstrated the core aspects of the general issue; maybe the example I chose wasn't very good. The core aspects are what are important, though. They are:

1. Someone in authority can discover recorded information, one interpretation of which is that that someone else is plotting a crime

2. The information might not have been subject to any agreement with (or even seen by) a second person

3. Should that discovery be taken seriously enough to warrant arresting the person?

My claim is that yes it should, unless there are other clearly overriding factors.

Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by jrflowers on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @05:32AM (#49990334)
Are you saying that your example is so bad that it is the reader’s job to come up with one for you? Everything after

> maybe the example I chose wasn't very good

is just you saying that police should have evidence when they arrest somebody

Re:Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces fel... by akoboldfrying on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @08:06AM (#49991607)
Engage with my argument, if you feel so inclined.