Re:Things that apparently cause cancer
by thereisnospork on Friday October 02, 2026 @11:06PM
(#49941047)
>Without correlation, what are we left with?
Mechanism. Testable causality. X causes cancer by doing y.
Re:Things that apparently cause cancer
by vlovich123 on Friday October 02, 2026 @11:09PM
(#49941060)
Get out of here with your crazy talk. The only tool we have is statistics
Re:Things that apparently cause cancer
by tjwebbnorfolk on Saturday October 03, 2026 @07:37PM
(#49948882)
Problem is, doing Y only "causes" cancer after doing it nonstop for like 40 years.
What can you do today that would cause cancer tomorrow or next week? Even next year? Nothing. Yet, just about every environmental thing causes cancer over long periods of time.
Which leads to the absurd: being alive causes cancer.
>is a kind of slippery slope..
Yea..
A deer in a forest who heard the foot steps of a lion and thought "hey Correlation is not causation" would soon be a goner...
Re:Things that apparently cause cancer
by tjwebbnorfolk on Saturday October 03, 2026 @07:38PM
(#49948898)
I see the reverse: the deer doesn't KNOW what those footsteps are. But can correlate it vaguely with danger and act accordingly.
Isn't that what I said?
My retort is always:
Saying 'Correlation isn't causation' doesn't disprove causation.
Meh, while obviously true, it's on the one claiming a causation to prove it, not on the others to disprove it.
Establishing a correlation is only a starting point. After that there is an entire field of statistics called causal inference that is devoted to establishing causality using a variety of tools.
The strength of correlation is NOT the only useful metric and should not be mistaken for more rigorous statistical analysis regarding causality.
I'm starting to think that "Correlation is not causation" is a kind of slippery slope toward a world where nobody can ever prove the cause of anything. At the same time, just about everything is at least a mild carcinogen including food, the sun, air particulates, etc. But knowing that everything causes cancer isn't useful information. Knowing the strength of the correlations of each of these things is actually useful.
Without correlation, what are we left with?