News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PipePipe: NewPipe hard fork implementing SponsorBlock by MisterMunchkin on Saturday September 26, 2026 @04:42PM (#49860349)
The problem with P2P video is that it's expensive to host and most of the people using it are going to use it for child abuse. It makes it not realistic.
Re:PipePipe: NewPipe hard fork implementing SponsorBlock by kitchi on Saturday September 26, 2026 @04:49PM (#49860404)
> most of the people using it are going to use it for child abuse.

This is deeply unsubstantiated and does not help contribute to a constructive debate. Please consider thinking more carefully.

Re:PipePipe: NewPipe hard fork implementing SponsorBlock by api on Saturday September 26, 2026 @04:52PM (#49860435)
“Most” is hyperbolic but it’s a real problem in any system designed for peer to peer hosting or sharing.

If the system is truly distributed it means you might not be able to participate without hosting or transmitting CSAM.

It’s also been used as a deliberate attack, which is known as “pissing in the pool.” Flood the system with CSAM and copyright infringement.

Re:PipePipe: NewPipe hard fork implementing SponsorBlock by choo-t on Saturday September 26, 2026 @05:10PM (#49860582)
Most P2P video system make you seed only the video you started watching, thus making the point about transmitting csam moot.
Re:PipePipe: NewPipe hard fork implementing SponsorBlock by dotancohen on Saturday September 26, 2026 @06:41PM (#49861281)
If I search for The Best of Both Worlds but open the video to find it's csam and not st:tng then I've unwittingly started watching, and thus potentially seeding, the csam.
Re:PipePipe: NewPipe hard fork implementing SponsorBlock by kitchi on Saturday September 26, 2026 @10:41PM (#49862819)
But even simple checks like the number of seeders on a torrent will defeat a vast majority of this problem. I would not expect a torrent with 1k seeders to be csam for e.g.

I understand the worry, and it is a difficult problem worth thought but the alarmist virtue signalling helps absolutely no one, victims included.

Re:PipePipe: NewPipe hard fork implementing SponsorBlock by dotancohen on Sunday September 27, 2026 @08:32AM (#49866132)
That might work for popular culture. It's probably a good strategy if you want to watch the latest superhero movie.

I listen to the Butthole Surfers and Amboog-a-Lard - I'm willing to bet a good portion of their material has less seeders than much illegal content do.

Re:PipePipe: NewPipe hard fork implementing SponsorBlock by monkeywork on Sunday September 27, 2026 @01:32PM (#49868840)
Are you not describing perfect as the enemy of good?

A product doesn't need to serve EVERY human on earths needs, just enough of them that it can become large enough that established legacy solutions need to adapt.

I get why you might think this wouldn't be a fit for YOU but rather than argue against it from a niche viewpoint instead maybe look at how if it did exist it could be good for many.

Re:PipePipe: NewPipe hard fork implementing SponsorBlock by Dylan16807 on Sunday September 27, 2026 @12:48AM (#49863452)
That's pretty unlikely. P2P can have moderation systems. Also that can be solved by only seeding videos you kept watching.
Re:PipePipe: NewPipe hard fork implementing SponsorBlock by dotancohen on Sunday September 27, 2026 @08:29AM (#49866104)
Is that actually done in practice?
Re:PipePipe: NewPipe hard fork implementing SponsorBlock by Dylan16807 on Sunday September 27, 2026 @10:58AM (#49867188)
There's no popular peer to peer video system in the first place so uh not yet?

Peertube has moderation.

Re:PipePipe: NewPipe hard fork implementing SponsorBlock by thisislife2 on Sunday September 27, 2026 @02:25AM (#49863906)
> If the system is truly distributed it means you might not be able to participate without hosting or transmitting CSAM.

Depends on the P2P architecture. With something like bittorrent / webtorrent you will be distributing CSAM only if you download it yourself first. Otherwise there is no way for any CSAM content to appear on your device. The fear that an algorithm may spread CSAM on the network by making you view one accidentally is a legitimate concern though.

Re:PipePipe: NewPipe hard fork implementing SponsorBlock by palata on Sunday September 27, 2026 @07:12AM (#49865623)
In that case, a real problem if you sell hammers is that you might not be able to prevent people from hitting their wife with them.

Not sure it is a reason for making hammers illegal?

Re:PipePipe: NewPipe hard fork implementing SponsorBlock by api on Sunday September 27, 2026 @10:14AM (#49866822)
I’m not in favor of making it illegal. I was speaking for those who write, maintain, or run such systems.