Re:Tech Needs Humanists More
by hardbass on Friday September 25, 2026 @06:29AM
(#49842576)
Do we have any examples of societies or governments ran by humanities people? I at least don't know any country ran by tech execs. If we can find examples of both, then we can compare and see.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Tech exec's don't always veer STEM, eg. Musk is a Business Grad who took "Physics for Business Grad" bridging courses, Paul Graham is a Philosophy grad.
China is said to be top heavy in actual STEM graduates at the party committee five year plan level.
A number of countries are top heavy in politico's with a formal Law degree, eg. Australia.
Mark Zuckerberg famously studied Latin in high school and remains a Classics enthusiast.
China inherited the dictatorship from communists. I am not sure if we can blame the dictatorial rule to the STEM people. But still, China seems quite good otherwise.
I think Law could be a example in favor of humanities, as eg many of the founders of the American government were from a background in law.
Re:Tech Needs Humanists More
by chris_swart on Friday September 25, 2026 @06:40AM
(#49842643)
Law is a branch of humanities, so most governments are ran by humanities people
I was about to add if Law is considered part of humanities. Many of the better governments have been founded by law background people, so I'd say that is at least a data point.
The UK government ministers have a lot of Oxford PPE graduates – the first P is Philosophy,
The current PM has an English degree.
The last one to have a scientific background was Thatcher.
That's just the Prime Minister. One person being from tech background doesn't make it a system ran by techs if the rest are of some other viewpoint or profession. So we would need examples of both governments ran by a group of humanities people having the "real power" and compare it to a government ran by a group of technical/engineering people.
You said the current UK government is mostly Philosophy background people. So how would you rate its performance?
I do not know about majority PPE.
This applies to many of the UK governments since WWII.
I suspect most ministers have been humanities graduates. STEM is a very small minority.