News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I didn't sign the Fields medallists' letter by pdonis on Thursday September 17, 2026 @07:44PM (#49748337)
> this is also a stunning example of survivorship bias.

No, it's an example of why you have to allow people to pursue what at the time look like "curiosities", even though most of them don't go anywhere--because the very small portion that do go somewhere, end up changing the world, and we don't know in advance which ones those are going to be.

It's quite true that the funds we have for this are a finite resource. But that doesn't mean that "foreseeable practical applications" is a useful filter for how to deploy that resource.

Re:I didn't sign the Fields medallists' letter by oliculipolicula on Thursday September 17, 2026 @10:10PM (#49749437)
You know how drunken debates with friends over trivia became pointless with the advent of Google and Wikipedia. The debates didn't get better. But they could. They did. Today we have HN mods and HN citations and upvotes

>useful filter

There's also "useful friction" as _almost_ imagined by Tao here

https://youtu.be/svl_1upFpQo?t=25m11s

We can't know in advance, but something like the "weird cadence" that arises when 2 skilled humans try to do a threesome with an AI..

could be reified into a local measure (eutripsis) of how likely advances (conceptual or otherwise) are in the midterm

Re:I didn't sign the Fields medallists' letter by Dylan16807 on Thursday September 17, 2026 @11:13PM (#49749820)
Yes you have to allow people to pursue these things. That's not a compelling argument for funding, especially when nobody was funding the people that did invent calculus.
Re:I didn't sign the Fields medallists' letter by stymaar on Friday September 18, 2026 @12:51AM (#49750312)
> nobody was funding the people that did invent calculus.

Of course someone was. Newton and Leibniz weren't living in autarky an some island. They had an income stream that was taken away from somewhere else and given to them so that they could afford working on their pet projects.

The fact that it's not publicly funded doesn't change the fact that there's still resource allocation happening.

Re:I didn't sign the Fields medallists' letter by Dylan16807 on Friday September 18, 2026 @01:38AM (#49750528)
I think by that definition every mathematician in the current day is funded, mission accomplished.
Re:I didn't sign the Fields medallists' letter by stymaar on Friday September 18, 2026 @06:51AM (#49752540)
> every mathematician in the current day is funded,

This is tautological, “mathematician” being defined in the modern world as someone paid to do mathematics…

Notice that the modern world is able able to sustain significantly more mathematicians than when “mathematicians” used to mean “someone well-off enough to work on mathematics in their ample amount of free time without worrying about their subsistence”.

Re:I didn't sign the Fields medallists' letter by Dylan16807 on Friday September 18, 2026 @04:20PM (#49759713)
> This is tautological, “mathematician” being defined in the modern world as someone paid to do mathematics…

Note that I'm including all the ones that a normal definition would not call paid, but your definition does.

But yes when a definition declares that everyone doing a thing is "funded", it does get pretty tautological and get in the way of arguments for actual funding.

Re:I didn't sign the Fields medallists' letter by what on Friday September 18, 2026 @01:39AM (#49750531)
They worked other jobs, no? No one paid them specifically to invent calculus or anything of the sort.
Re:I didn't sign the Fields medallists' letter by stymaar on Friday September 18, 2026 @04:57AM (#49751782)
> They worked other jobs, no?

This is an anachronism, you're projecting modern social organization to an era that worked very differently.

Re:I didn't sign the Fields medallists' letter by pdonis on Friday September 18, 2026 @11:55AM (#49756231)
During the years when Newton made his great discoveries, of calculus and universal gravitation, he had a scholarship from the University of Cambridge. (Note that it was not until a couple of decades later that Newton published this work.) After he got his MA he became a Fellow of Trinity College. So society was basically subsidizing him.
Re:I didn't sign the Fields medallists' letter by rdbl27 on Saturday September 19, 2026 @01:08PM (#49768293)
Newton was able to attend Cambridge at all only because his parents were prosperous yeoman farmers who owned substantial agricultural estates and held private incomes.

Nearly all schools at the time were not subsidized by society and required substantial tuition payments. Most children had to get jobs. School was rare.

Newton's parents, while not extremely wealthy, could afford to send him to expensive private schools, instead of requiring him to get a job at age 8. This was a prerequisite for entering Cambridge.

His early career was subsidized by his upper middle class parents and inherited capital, not by society at large. He became a professor at age 26, and was paid a salary in exchange for work after that.

Re:I didn't sign the Fields medallists' letter by rdbl27 on Saturday September 19, 2026 @12:58PM (#49768184)
Newton and Leibniz both inherited substantial estates from their upper middle class parents.

Neither was fabulously wealthy, but they were both able to bootstrap their academic careers with inherited money until they became famous enough to receive patronage.

"Individuals choosing voluntarily to spend their own money researching mathematical puzzles and curiosities and pure knowledge" is a very different ethical proposition than modern academia, which depends heavily on compulsory tax payments levied on everyone.

Re:I didn't sign the Fields medallists' letter by fmbb on Friday September 18, 2026 @02:04AM (#49750658)
Correction: you don’t _have_ to, but technological advancement is faster if you do.
Re:I didn't sign the Fields medallists' letter by eru on Friday September 18, 2026 @03:14AM (#49751090)
That's an empirical question. And you also need to justify why your country in particular should finance that.

For the kind of research where benefits accrue to the inventor (or her employer) and others can be excluded so that the benefits don't 'spill over', then private companies can fund it.

For the kind of research that spills over, you can just let the tax payers of that other country foot the bill. Eg the US can free-ride on Chinese research, and if having mathematicians in the population is good, the US can offer green cards to whatever has a math degree from a good enough university.

There might be some intermediate research that has just enough spill over that a company won't do it, but a country might, should be a rare creature. And differently sized countries should have different sweet spots: some companies are bigger than some countries after all. But I don't think we see different countries select the research (mathematical or otherwise) with an eye towards exactly tailoring spill over.