News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Painful Truth: The RAM Crisis Is Only Just the Beginning by josephg on Thursday September 17, 2026 @12:18AM (#49736339)
> OAI's deal with Samsung & SK Hynix is also colossal - locking up roughly 900,000 DRAM wafers per month, roughly 40% of world output (Stargate project).

I wonder if they'll, at some point, have enough RAM? Or is this is the new normal? Will models keep scaling with the amount of ram chips openai and anthropic own?

Re:The Painful Truth: The RAM Crisis Is Only Just the Beginning by bionhoward on Thursday September 17, 2026 @12:30AM (#49736432)
Even with efficiency breakthroughs, it would just afford packing more agents per unit of memory. Scaling compute and data keeps paying off, leading to smarter models, and smarter models have more demand even at higher prices because they can accomplish more work at higher quality. Sovereign AI hasn’t even really taken off yet to anywhere near the level it could. That’s going to dramatically increase the number of massive-scale users of AI agents. So no, IMHO they will “never” have “enough.”
Re:The Painful Truth: The RAM Crisis Is Only Just the Beginning by epicureanideal on Thursday September 17, 2026 @12:52AM (#49736543)
At some point though, won't someone be able to extrapolate the demand growth curve, and invest some colossal amount of money into making and selling more RAM chips?
Re:The Painful Truth: The RAM Crisis Is Only Just the Beginning by fragmede on Thursday September 17, 2026 @01:04AM (#49736619)
Yes. China's done just that. Expect those factories to come online within 2-3 years.
Re:The Painful Truth: The RAM Crisis Is Only Just the Beginning by cyanydeez on Thursday September 17, 2026 @08:35AM (#49739849)
Weve hit the sigmoid. Whats scalling is ancillary to the model. The cry for a slowdown is because the open weight models demonstrate the cost of parameter pacling is not work neither inference nor training.

The assumption about the singularity simply is a delusion with LLMs.

However, the models do provide a means to improve the harness universe, so that residual will continue to improve perception. Parameter cpunt will stagnate and training wont be justifiable from every angle.

Re:The Painful Truth: The RAM Crisis Is Only Just the Beginning by ohyes on Thursday September 17, 2026 @12:34AM (#49736456)
Hard to know, does each GB of ram give some marginal increase in profit or potential profit?

I’d guess no. Past a certain point the model has all the capabilities it can possibly usefully offer and honestly we may already be past that. The next gen model just doesn’t seem like as clear a step up as it once was.

Re:The Painful Truth: The RAM Crisis Is Only Just the Beginning by Leonard_of_Q on Thursday September 17, 2026 @04:17AM (#49737874)
That point is said to lie somewhere around 640 KB if I recall correctly.

https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/2863/did-bill-g...

Re:The Painful Truth: The RAM Crisis Is Only Just the Beginning by josephg on Thursday September 17, 2026 @06:44AM (#49738873)
LLMs still seem pretty bad at writing large scale software like web browsers. Though it’s probably a problem of managing large context windows more than anything. Not sure if larger models will magically overcome that.
Re:The Painful Truth: The RAM Crisis Is Only Just the Beginning by cyanydeez on Thursday September 17, 2026 @09:51AM (#49740742)
The LLM by itself will never create software of any nontrivial (training) complexity.

The harness though will improve while parameter count stagnates. The Qwen3.8 models are strong enough when given proper context.

Re:The Painful Truth: The RAM Crisis Is Only Just the Beginning by josephg on Thursday September 17, 2026 @11:04AM (#49741889)
> The LLM by itself will never create software of any nontrivial (training) complexity.

Huh? I'm not sure what the word "training" does in that sentence. But "never" my arse. Frontier models can make nontrivial software already.

For example, the other day I asked fable to reverse engineer the satisfactory blueprint file format. Then write a program to read the logistic flow graph in a blueprint. Then make an auditing tool that can analyse the graph to find problems.

Well, it totally knocked it out of the park:

https://seph.au/blueprints/#bp=0%3Aalumina.sbp

This is a relatively small program, but it's not trivial. I'd consider a trivial program to be something I could code up in 20 minutes. It would have taken me a couple weeks to make this blueprint auditing tool, including reverse engineering the file format, writing the analysis code, making the website, scraping all the in-game data on available recipes and icons and so on.

I've got a lot of mixed feelings about LLMs. But it seems very silly to lie about what they're capable of.

Re:The Painful Truth: The RAM Crisis Is Only Just the Beginning by cyanydeez on Thursday September 17, 2026 @12:38PM (#49743269)
training is in there because it's "trained" to do trivial apps like TODO lists, etc.

I'm well aware it can build apps. But if you arn't tracking what's going on, they're basically creating deterministic gates and tools to get it to do anything.

There's no lie here, it's simply about what you think is _LLM_ and what is the rest of the software that's making it go. I use opencode consistently to build non-trivial apps with it, but it's not doing it with zero guidance, and it's routinely wrong about it's assumptions, and the rest. The thing keeping it on track is opencode, not the LLM's training.

Re:The Painful Truth: The RAM Crisis Is Only Just the Beginning by josephg on Thursday September 17, 2026 @09:59PM (#49749359)
> But if you arn't tracking what's going on, they're basically creating deterministic gates and tools to get it to do anything.

So, the same as skilled humans then?

Re:The Painful Truth: The RAM Crisis Is Only Just the Beginning by ohyes on Friday September 18, 2026 @12:11PM (#49756490)
That’s definitely how I like to ensure my code isn’t garbage. But now I use the tools I would have made to make the LLM & harness more useful and I might make more with the LLM because it costs me slightly less mentally.