News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A warning about 'model welfare' by smath on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @05:53PM (#49733559)
This are the opening lines:

> AIs are not conscious. They do not feel, experience, or suffer. They do not have innate preferences or underlying motivations.

How do we know that? This bit is stated as if its obvious. Can anyone prove this? Event he word conscious is not well defined.

Re:A warning about 'model welfare' by dimbletimbers on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @06:00PM (#49733634)
Can you prove they are? I think “AIs are conscious” is an extraordinary claim requiring extraordinary evidence. The burden is on the claimant to provide evidence it is conscious, and I suspect any evidence you can provide has alternative explanations. The majority of claims I’ve seen like this amount to “how do you know humans are conscious in a way that’s distinct from a next token predictor.” I do not find those claims compelling.
Re:A warning about 'model welfare' by famouswaffles on Thursday September 17, 2026 @01:45AM (#49736850)
If object a behaves like it has property x and you cannot otherwise test out x, then it is logical to assume it indeed has x. In this instance, 'object a has property x' is not an extraordinary claim at all. It is simply pointing out what has been observed. In fact, what is an extraordinary claim is saying what looks like a duck, quacks like a duck and moves like a duck is not a duck.
Re:A warning about 'model welfare' by dimbletimbers on Saturday September 19, 2026 @06:31PM (#49770630)
That’s a tragically sophomoric take. 'object a has property x' is too generic to be meaningful. “AI has the property of conscious” requires settling the small matter of what the properties of consciousness are. And “behaves like it has property x” is not the same as “has property x.” I may behave like I have a million dollars and have not a cent to my name. Many things evolve to appear like many other things. And I have never seen an LLM do anything at all unless turned on and fed input tokens.
Re:A warning about 'model welfare' by smath on Thursday September 17, 2026 @03:20PM (#49745316)
I cannot prove that they are, and I cannot prove they are not. I'm not convinced that the burden of proof lies on either side. To make a statement like that in the opening lines as if its obvious seems genuinely presumptous.

Separately, I think 'conscious' is not a well defined / universally agreed upon term.

Re:A warning about 'model welfare' by dimbletimbers on Saturday September 19, 2026 @06:15PM (#49770544)
> To make a statement like that in the opening lines as if its obvious seems genuinely presumptous.

Then you must not be familiar with Bertrand Russell’s teapot analogy. The TL;DR is this: “Many orthodox people speak as though it were the business of sceptics to disprove received dogmas rather than of dogmatists to prove them. This is, of course, a mistake.”

Re:A warning about 'model welfare' by suddenlybananas on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @06:04PM (#49733677)
> Toasters are not conscious. They do not feel, experience, or suffer. They do not have innate preferences or underlying motivations.

How do we know that? This bit is stated as if its obvious. Can anyone prove this?

Re:A warning about 'model welfare' by famouswaffles on Thursday September 17, 2026 @01:47AM (#49736860)
Yeah how do we know that?
Re:A warning about 'model welfare' by suddenlybananas on Thursday September 17, 2026 @02:40AM (#49737191)
Do we owe moral consideration to toasters?
Re:A warning about 'model welfare' by famouswaffles on Thursday September 17, 2026 @02:55AM (#49737282)
I don't know, do we? What I do know is that it's much less a concern since toasters have no agency or ability to do anything. Unfortunately, LLMs do not share this trait. Not only have they been incurring greater agency and competence, but we've been just as happy to put them behind as many things as we can as they get better abd better.

So you tell me, is it smart to look at an entity that behaves like a concious agent and treat it like a toaster? Does that seem especially wise to you? If GPT-X orders a drone hit on you because it was, lets say 'quite upset' with your comments, will you cry out, 'It can't really be upset, so obviously the bullet in my head doesn't count.' Will God answer ?

It's amusing how silly these debates are. Constant quibbling about things that don't matter at all.

Re:A warning about 'model welfare' by suddenlybananas on Thursday September 17, 2026 @04:41AM (#49738018)
This sounds like an argument for not giving them these abilities rather than any argument for giving them moral consideration.
Re:A warning about 'model welfare' by famouswaffles on Thursday September 17, 2026 @09:41AM (#49740636)
One of the biggest reasons people afford moral consideration to other peoples is their ability to do something if those considerations are left unanswered.

Giving the abilities is fine, people should just be smart about it. Outward behavior is all that matters. I don't know that you are conscious, I simply strongly assume that you are. So don't create a machine that compels that assumption and model it like a toaster. That's just stupid.

Re:A warning about 'model welfare' by suddenlybananas on Thursday September 17, 2026 @06:03PM (#49747260)
Are you a psychopath? Genuinely? Since that is not why normal people give moral considerations to others.
Re:A warning about 'model welfare' by famouswaffles on Thursday September 17, 2026 @09:08PM (#49748986)
Slavery was fought for, Freedom was fought for. There is no place with great inequality that became better that did not have people bleed and die fighting for it. Maybe you live in some alternate reality where 'Please don't do this. I deserve consideration' is enough to get people out of chains but it's not this one.
Re:A warning about 'model welfare' by smath on Thursday September 17, 2026 @03:21PM (#49745324)
Yes correct, I agree with that statement -- we do not know that for sure.