Re:A warning about 'model welfare'
by suddenlybananas on Thursday September 17, 2026 @04:41AM
(#49738018)
This sounds like an argument for not giving them these abilities rather than any argument for giving them moral consideration.
Re:A warning about 'model welfare'
by famouswaffles on Thursday September 17, 2026 @09:41AM
(#49740636)
One of the biggest reasons people afford moral consideration to other peoples is their ability to do something if those considerations are left unanswered.
Giving the abilities is fine, people should just be smart about it. Outward behavior is all that matters. I don't know that you are conscious, I simply strongly assume that you are. So don't create a machine that compels that assumption and model it like a toaster. That's just stupid.
Re:A warning about 'model welfare'
by suddenlybananas on Thursday September 17, 2026 @06:03PM
(#49747260)
Are you a psychopath? Genuinely? Since that is not why normal people give moral considerations to others.
Re:A warning about 'model welfare'
by famouswaffles on Thursday September 17, 2026 @09:08PM
(#49748986)
Slavery was fought for, Freedom was fought for. There is no place with great inequality that became better that did not have people bleed and die fighting for it. Maybe you live in some alternate reality where 'Please don't do this. I deserve consideration' is enough to get people out of chains but it's not this one.
So you tell me, is it smart to look at an entity that behaves like a concious agent and treat it like a toaster? Does that seem especially wise to you? If GPT-X orders a drone hit on you because it was, lets say 'quite upset' with your comments, will you cry out, 'It can't really be upset, so obviously the bullet in my head doesn't count.' Will God answer ?
It's amusing how silly these debates are. Constant quibbling about things that don't matter at all.