Used in a capacity as evidence? Yes. The scenario is made worse not better by the second largest company in the world promising captured veracity.
Whether it does remains to be seen. Do you have inside knowledge about how it works? Despite their initial language about discerning real events, none of their technical explanation says anything at all about anything outside of the camera itself.
Therefore because of your worry (which is based on remarkably little information), it's a bad technology?
Come the fuck on. That's beyond luddite bullshit.
You must be new around here. ;-)
Then maybe let’s save those criticisms until this is in the hands of knowledgeable people who can actually test? I mean, I’m no fan of the direction Apple has gone under Tim Cook, but all else being equal I’m inclined to give them the benefit of the doubt that they may have thought this through over the time it took to build more than a random person speculating on HN who just read a blog post for the first time.
> (…) we see no details here about what scene information is used.
And you assume that everything in a post is the sum total of how it works?
> It increases the potential value of a forgery
By that token, should we also not be adding forgery deterrents to ID cards and bills? After all, if you can fake the preventive measures, “it increases the potential value of a forgery”.
After all, if money is no object, you could just bribe every single apple employee involved in the project.
It is the problem that they say they're trying to solve, though. They specifically say "where the essential role of a photograph is to prove that something actually happened".
It fails the reasonable person test to say that in the phrase "something actually happened" the "something" refers to the act of taking the photo.
Likewise, in "photographs that depict real events", no reasonable person could say that "real events" includes fabrications or that the "event" in question is the taking of the photo itself.