News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Reference Image: A New Approach for Verified Photog... by BugsJustFindMe on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @11:20PM (#49721735)
iPhone lidar only works up to like 16 feet in the easiest lighting conditions (indoors) and may be functionally ineffective outdoors.
Re:Apple Reference Image: A New Approach for Verified Photog... by pveierland on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @11:29PM (#49721778)
Still, that means that either the fake target scene and your screen presenting it would need to be outside of LiDAR sensor bounds, or you'd need to find a way to make the depth sensor data conform with your fake scene, both increasing the difficulty of producing a forgery.
Re:Apple Reference Image: A New Approach for Verified Photog... by BugsJustFindMe on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @12:41AM (#49722170)
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49721878

> increasing the difficulty of producing a forgery

The problem with this thinking is twofold:

1) Whether it actually meaningfully increases the difficulty of a forgery remains to be seen. Despite their initial language about discerning real events, we see no details here about what scene information is used.

2) It increases the potential value of a forgery because now your forgery is attested by Apple.

So it either makes it easier to defraud people or more worthwhile to put in the effort to defraud people or both. None of those outcomes are great.

Re:Apple Reference Image: A New Approach for Verified Photog... by moffkalast on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @12:01PM (#49729063)
A sufficiently light absorbing material is indistinguishable from infinity to a lidar. Or simply add a mirror that redirects it sideways, those can't be detected either.
Re:Apple Reference Image: A New Approach for Verified Photog... by gruez on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @11:29PM (#49721776)
So you need a big enough screen to cover the entire field of view at 16 ft? Sounds expensive
Re:Apple Reference Image: A New Approach for Verified Photog... by nomel on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @11:48PM (#49721878)
Or, probably just some optics, like a slanted $9 IR mirror [1] in front of it, to direct the lidar to the sky/absorption box. Then you can point at the high res HDR TV that's probably already in your living room.

[1] https://commonlands.com/products/ir-cut-filters-csp650?srslt...

Re:Apple Reference Image: A New Approach for Verified Photog... by BugsJustFindMe on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @11:36PM (#49721818)
Well, first, that's only expensive if you're poor. The world is absolutely full of people who can easily piss away your entire annual income throwing a house party.

But I really mean that if the lidar barely works outdoors anyway then actually you don't need to be 16 feet away at all.

Anyway, one may presume that they've thought about this.

Re:Apple Reference Image: A New Approach for Verified Photog... by brookst on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @12:00AM (#49721940)
Thought about it and also are bright enough not to fall for the “if a single person dies wearing a seat belt, we should abandon seat belts because they do no good at all” fallacy.

It’s almost certainly possible to fool v1 of this system, for some images, in some contexts. It would be shocking if the first implementation was completely perfect. But maybe it’s better than nothing?

Re:Apple Reference Image: A New Approach for Verified Photog... by BugsJustFindMe on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @12:04AM (#49721962)
> But maybe it’s better than nothing?

I think this will depend on how it gets used. I can imagine numerous outcomes where it's in fact worse than nothing (significantly more effective blackmail, for instance).

Re:Apple Reference Image: A New Approach for Verified Photog... by brookst on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @11:48PM (#49736163)
I guess? The bailey version of that argument is that we should do away with the concept of truth altogether, because some truths are harmful.
Re:Apple Reference Image: A New Approach for Verified Photog... by akersten on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @12:26AM (#49722077)
> maybe it’s better than nothing?

While that is not quite my bar of confidence when implementing wide-reaching technologies that have numerous unexplored knock-on effects, I guess the calculus must have been different on Infinite Loop recently.

Re:Apple Reference Image: A New Approach for Verified Photog... by dd8601fn on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @12:41AM (#49722172)
I like that seatbelt argument example.

I’ve seen that type of argument a million times, and I’ll certainly reuse that.

Re:Apple Reference Image: A New Approach for Verified Photog... by MisterKent on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @12:53AM (#49722240)
The problem is that if defeating it is trivial, then it _authenticates_ fake images.

The problem is that it makes it easier to fool people and provide "cryptographic" evidence of validity, backed by big tech.

It's purpose is to stop bad actors from passing of fake as real just as much as it is to prevent real images being dismissed as fake.

Re:Apple Reference Image: A New Approach for Verified Photog... by alwillis on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @01:28AM (#49722435)
> It’s almost certainly possible to fool v1 of this system, for some images, in some contexts. It would be shocking if the first implementation was completely perfect.

Knowing Apple, they've been working on and testing Apple Reference Image for years.

It being perfect isn't the issue; it's that random people on the internet who are just learning about this assume Apple's engineers haven't already thought about everything (and more) mentioned in this thread.

Re:Apple Reference Image: A New Approach for Verified Photog... by ben_w on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @03:03AM (#49722995)
> It being perfect isn't the issue; it's that random people on the internet who are just learning about this assume Apple's engineers haven't already thought about everything (and more) mentioned in this thread.

Given how many bugs there are in macOS and how long they have remained there, I (who have been writing iOS apps from the release of the first retina iPod touch until AI got good) functionally agree with such people; at best, I think Apple's engineers haven't actually solved everything (and more) mentioned in this thread, even if every one of these things may have come up in discussions and even reached an official backlog or task list or similar.

Re:Apple Reference Image: A New Approach for Verified Photog... by archagon on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @03:02AM (#49722992)
If they thought about it, then why isn't this very obvious failure point even mentioned in the technical breakdown?
Re:Apple Reference Image: A New Approach for Verified Photog... by mitxela on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @06:03AM (#49724222)
It's bad to begin with that Apple should be the arbiters of reality.
Re:Apple Reference Image: A New Approach for Verified Photog... by croon on Friday September 18, 2026 @05:55AM (#49752125)
If fake images get certified as real, that's a net negative compared to now where the verification boils down to chain of trust.
Re:Apple Reference Image: A New Approach for Verified Photog... by somethinsfishy on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @01:02AM (#49722296)
Put some sugar on it. Please.
Re:Apple Reference Image: A New Approach for Verified Photog... by BugsJustFindMe on Wednesday September 16, 2026 @01:04AM (#49722306)
Def Leppard, is that you?