News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Douglas Hofstadter: Analogy as the Core of Cognition [video] by hammock on Thursday September 10, 2026 @07:19PM (#49651442)
> to Hofstafer analogy making isn't some higher level cognitive process, certainly not a language based one, but basically is THE cognitive process

This is so funny to me, because as many people know, sharing an analogy with another person is the fastest way to LOSE an argument with someone, or otherwise spiral it into an unproductive place.

I think it’s Scott Adams who used to say analogies work well for explaining. They work terribly for persuasion.

Re:Douglas Hofstadter: Analogy as the Core of Cognition [video] by The_Blade on Thursday September 10, 2026 @08:07PM (#49651814)
> I think it’s Scott Adams who used to say analogies work well for explaining. They work terribly for persuasion.

perhaps you are just not good at analogies... or persuasion

Re:Douglas Hofstadter: Analogy as the Core of Cognition [video] by skinfaxi on Thursday September 10, 2026 @07:54PM (#49651710)
> They work terribly for persuasion.

I just experienced this in a conversation. An analogy offers an opportunity to engage with the straw man and miss the forest for the trees.

Re:Douglas Hofstadter: Analogy as the Core of Cognition [video] by partyficial on Friday September 11, 2026 @02:58PM (#49663528)
Every analogy, by design, has both similarities and differences. The intention is to focus on the similarities, and ignore the differences.

If I say, your face is like the moon, I mean it is bright, not that it is a million miles away.

Re:Douglas Hofstadter: Analogy as the Core of Cognition [video] by Terr_ on Thursday September 10, 2026 @08:28PM (#49651997)
I think that's just because every analogy gives an entire "second front" of ideas for a hostile recipient to find a "flaw", when they ignore the intended boundary between the stuff that does/doesn't matter to the analogy.

Ex:

Explainer: "Getting a spleen means cutting open the patient and taking it out. It's just like how I'm going to unzip this section of the patient-shaped doll, and remove this little purple bean. In both cases a hole is necessary in a similar location."

Hostile listener: "Nonsense! I can just buy beans at the store! So just buy a spleen! No hole!"

Re:Douglas Hofstadter: Analogy as the Core of Cognition [video] by onthrowaway457 on Thursday September 10, 2026 @08:50PM (#49652160)
Constructing explicit analogies for persuasion seems to be a bit of a different thing.

I’m not sure if Hofstadter puts it this way, but to me even the core aspects of your sentences in this post have roots in analogies. What does it mean to lose an argument or to spiral it to a different place? There is no place, there is no lost item, but we talk about these abstract ideas in ways that largely depend upon understanding things like physical objects and space and movement.

Re:Douglas Hofstadter: Analogy as the Core of Cognition [video] by HarHarVeryFunny on Friday September 11, 2026 @10:26AM (#49659037)
There are certainly a lot of analogies to be found in language - it would be interesting to know how much of this is cultural (e.g. business use of sports analogies) vs universal across cultures. Your "spiraling" example reminds me of one I recently came across as a roman coin collector - the origin of the word cataracts, and also portcullis (latin: cataracta) as being analogical to a waterfall (whose greek name gives us cataract), and the notion of something coming crashing down (even if only an eye covering).

Perhaps the common occurrence of analogies in language is because language is distinct from the things it is referencing, so some degree of abstraction is unavoidable?

Re:Douglas Hofstadter: Analogy as the Core of Cognition [video] by cynicalkane on Friday September 11, 2026 @02:38AM (#49654321)
> sharing an analogy with another person is the fastest way to LOSE an argument with someone

This is true if the arguer is hostile, but as I've gotten older, if I get the sense that someone is entering an argument with the primary goal of "winning", I'll try to avoid that framing or just look for an offramp entirely.

Sure, the other party might think they "won", but they were going to think that anyway. For those more inclined to feel that the point of talking to each other is to learn from each other, I'll continue to use analogies and other things reasonable people understand.

Re:Douglas Hofstadter: Analogy as the Core of Cognition [video] by JoshTriplett on Friday September 11, 2026 @08:09AM (#49657072)
> This is true if the arguer is hostile, but as I've gotten older, if I get the sense that someone is entering an argument with the primary goal of "winning", I'll try to avoid that framing or just look for an offramp entirely.

Absolutely. The best kinds of arguments are those where you both have the shared goal of reaching consensus, and treat reaching consensus as a collaborative activity of finding the correct answer, even though you disagree with the starting point. There are a few techniques for this, which work well when operating in good faith, and can backfire when dealing with hostile counterparties. Most things work badly when arguing with hostile counterparties.

Re:Douglas Hofstadter: Analogy as the Core of Cognition [video] by teddyh on Friday September 11, 2026 @08:11AM (#49657094)
> I think it’s Scott Adams who used to say analogies work well for explaining. They work terribly for persuasion.

Yes; here is one instance: <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n45D_zi3O5g#t=14m13s>

Re:Douglas Hofstadter: Analogy as the Core of Cognition [video] by HarHarVeryFunny on Friday September 11, 2026 @08:12AM (#49657112)
Agreed, and while subjective experience can be misleading (being a Hofstadian "strange loop" is a strange thing) you'd think that if our entire perceptual and cognitive processes were analogy based, then this would filter through to our everyday experience. You'd expect us to see analogies, not generalities, everywhere... looking at your car engine and seeing a hologram of your failing football team floating over it, perhaps!

It's notable that when we do use analogies there are really two use cases

1) Trying to use them to communicate an alternate or simpler POV

2) To make a joke, by pointing out a ridiculous comparison

The joke case is interesting, because this seems to be the basis of half of humor - breaking expectations (the other half perhaps being taboo breaking?), which really isn't how you'd want an adaptive cognitive system to work. You need to see the predictive regularities in the world, not see absurd similarities that make you laugh.