News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trade (and Tariffs) by CGMthrowaway on Thursday August 27, 2026 @11:24AM (#49466355)
I totally agree trade should feel fair. If the US sends jobs, money, food or goods to other countries, then we shouldn't get garbage back.

Tariffs are a way of warning other countries "don’t take us for a ride." They help American workers, factories and towns that were hurt when jobs went overseas.

Tariffs shouldn't feel like hurting yourself for no reason. They are an important tool for standing up for yourself when other countries (to say nothing of bad trade deals) want to take advantage of you

Re:Trade (and Tariffs) by hartator on Thursday August 27, 2026 @11:27AM (#49466409)
Tarrifs are the worst decision a politician can make.

The main reason we have open-ish border for people and goods is to reduce the risk of war. You are not going to wage war with a country that do business with.

This undermines this idea.

Re:Trade (and Tariffs) by CGMthrowaway on Thursday August 27, 2026 @11:31AM (#49466471)
Maybe letting other countries rob us blind is worse. The US has hardly any factories left. Is that "peace" or is that just losing, slowly?

Open borders can be GREAT, but they can also be a point of vulnerability if we lose control of them

Re:Trade (and Tariffs) by analog31 on Thursday August 27, 2026 @12:16PM (#49467230)
They're not robbing us blind. They're taking care of our manufacturing so that we can invest in things like the financial industry, fossil fuels, and AI.
Re:Trade (and Tariffs) by 9x39 on Thursday August 27, 2026 @12:44PM (#49467628)
This is great until you're at war (economic or kinetic) with who does your manufacturing.

But for a beautiful moment in time we created a lot of value for shareholders.

Re:Trade (and Tariffs) by padjo on Thursday August 27, 2026 @12:41PM (#49467591)
Who exactly is robbing you blind? Could it be your own billionaire class?
Re:Trade (and Tariffs) by phaedryx on Thursday August 27, 2026 @01:07PM (#49467941)
Trade happens because both sides agree and make an exchange. I don't understand how "other countries rob us blind."
Re:Trade (and Tariffs) by warkdarrior on Thursday August 27, 2026 @01:13PM (#49468013)
> The US has hardly any factories left.

Feel free to start your own factory in US, nobody is stopping you. Just keep in mind that for commoditized products (most consumer stuff, for example), prices are all that matter. "Buy American" is not a product feature.

Re:Trade (and Tariffs) by cooggog on Thursday August 27, 2026 @01:23PM (#49468173)
Some years ago. I learned about a new -ish technology that fascinated me. I started to research ways to get in on the development of this technology: i.e. what sort of opportunities might there be for a startup or small business in the space.

The answer I found was very sobering and mildly depressing. There was no room for developing the technology itself. That had already been done by large companies with the capital and resources to commoditize things early.

Instead, the real opportunities were found in business/management consulting selling the product and tangential things, like having a construction company to help build out infrastructure needed for the technology.

At this point I think technology no longer interests me because it doesn’t have a place for me.

Re:Trade (and Tariffs) by picafrost on Thursday August 27, 2026 @01:18PM (#49468093)
> Maybe letting other countries rob us blind is worse.

I find this argument interesting because the US economy is the largest in the entire world by a fairly wide margin. That the US is being robbed implies it's operating from a position of weakness, which is an absurd idea.

Are other countries with factories really responsible for US companies outsourcing manufacturing to them? Do you want cheap goods or do you want your fellow Americans paid pennies?

Re:Trade (and Tariffs) by pessimizer on Thursday August 27, 2026 @05:39PM (#49471625)
No, we're robbing them blind. We used "free trade" to dump subsidized agricultural goods into countries, destroy their farmers, then buy up their farms. We used it to push wages down both here and overseas so that our poor got poorer, and so in other countries they couldn't take advantage of the work to improve their lives, just inflate the incomes of a bunch of elite middle men.

The international monetary system as envisioned by Keynes was supposed to use a central world bank and settlement currency (the Bancor) to make sure that strong countries couldn't be parasitic on weak countries. This was sabotaged by a US official who was also working as a Soviet spy, Harry Dexter White. Neither pole of the new postwar bipolar order wanted anything that would limit their dominance.

The long-term outcome, however, was that the poverty of the world was much more attractive to exploit than the workers of the US, the consumer base for all of this production was left to deteriorate - to shrink to just the wealthy whose income came from investments, as all production shifted overseas.

Everything would have gone great if it weren't for those dastardly Chinese, who didn't let oligarchs shape their economy, and planned for the well-being of China, not their own personal well-being. Western oligarchs were going for a slave planet controlled by the largest bank accounts; this required no competition because it had (and desired) few real assets. China cultivated a manufacturing powerhouse, perfected its infrastructure, and operated from a base of actual, controlled domestic capital.

The West is now stuck trying to trade paper, and manufacturing whose only value is the poverty surrounding it, for Chinese goods. Now they're going to treat the US like the US treated Mexico. Manufacturing will come back in the US, owned by the Chinese.

Tariffs and the well-being of US workers are the only way out of this. Elite Americans will do anything but this, because they are 1) bad people, and 2) barely American.

Re:Trade (and Tariffs) by inigyou on Thursday August 27, 2026 @11:30AM (#49466454)
There's never been a war the US has chosen not to start.
Re:Trade (and Tariffs) by jpadkins on Thursday August 27, 2026 @12:44PM (#49467620)
Then why did Canadian politicians tax milk products at > 200%? https://www.cbsa-asfc.gc.ca/trade-commerce/tariff-tarif/2024...

(starting long before the current trade war)

Re:Trade (and Tariffs) by bigyabai on Thursday August 27, 2026 @01:22PM (#49468148)
It's a surplus tax, and one that apparently doesn't exist for the majority of dairy imports: https://archive.is/kKsYc

  that tariff would only apply if we were able to reach and exceed the quota on U.S. dairy exports agreed to under the U.S.-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA). 

  [...] the U.S. has never gotten close to exceeding our USMCA quotas
Re:Trade (and Tariffs) by jpadkins on Thursday August 27, 2026 @02:37PM (#49469279)
thanks, key quote from the link (for others) "“It is accurate that Canada imposes a tariff of approximately 250% on U.S. exports of certain dairy products into Canada, and even more with Canada’s 25% retaliatory tariffs in place. However, that tariff would only apply if we were able to reach and exceed the quota on U.S. dairy exports agreed to under the U.S.-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA). Frustratingly, the U.S. has never gotten close to exceeding our USMCA quotas because Canada has erected various protectionist measures that fly in the face of their trade obligations made under USMCA."

So I think this supports the point that Canadian politicians are bad for protectionist trade policies, right?

Re:Trade (and Tariffs) by upboundspiral on Thursday August 27, 2026 @01:03PM (#49467891)
The idea that trade decreases the risk of war is old. It dates back to pre-WW1.

Think tanks around Europe were celebrating an "end to hostilities". And then WW1 happened. Trade does not prevent war. War is not always a rational consequence or act.

What does prevent war is a good standard of living. Eliminate resentment, and one of the great causes of war is lost.

Whether you need tariffs or not to ensure good standard of living I don't know. But the goal should always be to increase standard of living and uphold justice, tariffs or not.

Re:Trade (and Tariffs) by squigz on Thursday August 27, 2026 @11:27AM (#49466397)
It also seems to ignore the companies and individuals that got rich because they chose to move jobs overseas.
Re:Trade (and Tariffs) by CGMthrowaway on Thursday August 27, 2026 @11:28AM (#49466421)
Totally, that is a great and valid add
Re:Trade (and Tariffs) by phaedryx on Thursday August 27, 2026 @01:15PM (#49468040)
You act as if it's the countries that are doing the trading; it's not. It is the businesses and other entities within the countries that are doing it. They are doing it because it benefits them. If a company is doing overseas manufacturing it is because they benefit and it isn't the United States that made that decision.
Re:Trade (and Tariffs) by Hammershaft on Thursday August 27, 2026 @03:05PM (#49469703)
Economists universally think tariffs are dumb policy.

https://kentclarkcenter.org/surveys/steel-and-aluminum-tarif...

Literally 100% of the 50 expert economists polled by the Kent Clark Center think tariffs overall make Americans worse off.

Nobody in politics can say this simple truth because the rust belt states are critical swing states.

Re:Trade (and Tariffs) by tim333 on Thursday August 27, 2026 @04:28PM (#49470772)
You've posted that five times now. Bit excessive?
Re:Trade (and Tariffs) by Hammershaft on Thursday August 27, 2026 @07:52PM (#49472727)
Unfortunately there are a lot more than 5 people saying the same misinformation in the comments.