Just so we're clear and can read past the headlines. This database doesn't exist and there has been no evidence that a database built off of meta ray-bans exists. And I would obviously dump the ray bans if this was actually a thing.
The technology exists to build it. The pipelines exist to populate it. The marketing engine exists to leverage it for targeted delivery of content.
And yet, somehow, nobody's built it?
How sure are you of that?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Facebook
> And if it has been, where can I buy this?
Depending on your preference: their advertising portal, or a stock broker.
you can do that, but you have no clue as to why people/companies don't tend to do those things?
big tech ignoring gdpr, ignoring or working around privacy protections, their technology being easily abused for stalking or harassment with no effort put into curtailing bad behavior, location data being bought and sold, etc.
i think the only thing from your list i haven't seen in the news in the last couple of months is employees of big tech doing break & enters.
(and this is all before we even approach the topic of data breaches!)
we're talking about meta supposedly using facial recognition on the glasses to build a master database of faces or something
like if I was Zuckerberg I would not want to do that, it would lead to a congressional hearing and all kinds of lawsuits I'd imagine.
like where do we draw the line on plausible?
or do we just go and say yeah meta must be spying on everything and feeding everything to a database where they sell everything about you
like what about CCTV backups or robo vac camera feeds? should we assume that companies are deliberately sending all the data so they can sell raw video feeds and they just don't tell you?
I'm not counting in incompetence and data breaches, I'm talking about intentional stuff
I mean, it's literally in the name?
Why?
Given Meta's history of disregarding everyone who's not Zuck (and him being a sociopath), why give them the benefit of any kind of doubt? Right now, everyone should assume malice as the first explanation, and then accept that maybe there was some ineptitude once evidence appears.
So, nothing except the main sales pitch then?
> There is no Rayban data in Facebook
There is no war in Ba Sing Se?
I’d be happy to join some kind of rage-off at metas general practices but my claim was specifically just about the glasses data
The Meta glasses, like everything Meta does, is marketed as a tool for interacting with Meta's services. Including Facebook.
This was my only claim. Which remains true. Videos off of the glasses voluntarily posted on FB is no different than iPhone videos posted on FB so it has nothing to do with the glasses themselves. If your claim is “posting videos in FB is a bad idea”, I agree, I don’t do that but again, that has nothing to do with the glasses either. It doesn’t make posting easier or force me to opt-out of automatically posting or anything silly like that
And you can’t do any “facial recognition” against Facebook either. I’m glad meta figured out that was a pointless bad idea.
You don't have to be constantly filming your kids, that's optional.
This is a cute spin, but what you're saying is "I like the glasses because I can film people without them knowing" it just happens the people in this case are (mostly) your children.
Again, I'm not saying this out of some bad faith, I just think this argument doesn't work the way you think it does. We actually have no data as to what its most commonly used for, apart from the headlines. Anecdotally, all my friends who have them use it for the exact same reason I do.
There is an alternative to your stealthy camera glasses, which you are aware of, and your admitted use case for them is filming people who are unaware that you are filming. Yet you can't imagine other people use them for the same purpose? I'm trying to assume good faith but you're not making it easy.
For the record the "people" here is my 2 year old. And I'm the one making a bad faith argument?
This confirms it, you're being deliberately obtuse.
Good faith question:
If your worry is, "I don't know you're recording", what did you do with that information when someone was using a digital camera to video record their kids 15 years ago, with you in the background?
P.S: if your answer is just "you could be a creep", I totally empathize, but this is for the situation where I am actually just a parent.
Would love to see it if I missed this.
https://www.yahoo.com/news/articles/meta-workers-seeing-dist...
It’s made clear during onboarding, but I’m sure it could be better.
This data - which includes their facial features, geolocation, and activities is not yours to take and immortalize.
This should be intuitive to any empathetic human being. One person saying "this breaches my sense of safety and privacy" should be enough for you to understand.
If someone shoves a camera in my face in public I am going to move away from that person. If I see them filming someone with me in the background at least I know what is going on and can judge the situation accordingly.
Now I don't know. Everyone with glasses is a suspect. It's more public tension, hyper vigilance and uncertainty.
I'm the asshole that covers his face while flipping off the person with the camera. I've done this for years. It used to be for news or other TV based content that they would blur out the finger gesture which meant blurring out my face. I've also noticed a camera in public places and deliberately stepped behind someone else as a blocker, or just moved to be behind the person with the camera. These are easy to do when it's obvious there's a camera. Glassholes are much more difficult to notice. Comparing these as equivalent is just a lack of being rational.
Given pockets, I don't think the camera part has ever been an "everyone"-level problem.
I hope, for the kids' sake, in addition to normalizing the idea that it's okay for dad to be recording them without their awareness, you teach them that most people find the idea of strangers doing this to be creepy and distasteful (for good reason), so they need to be wary around Meta glasses despite seeing them as a quotidian thing.
"in addition to normalizing the idea that it's okay for dad to be recording them without their awareness"
They're 2 man. You're at the point of questioning whether parents should be allowed to film their infants. Do we think we're off the deep end a bit?
going to hold my tongue regarding the majority of this conversation, but i couldn't help myself here.
meta has one of the worst track records of doing untoward things with data. a pattern of abusing its user's data, built over years. if you are still okay with them now, i am doubting your words that anything they could do would make you "dump them immediately".
You think Meta is going to create CSAM with my data?
Like I would dump them for using my data for analytics without my permission, but we probably should recalibrate our expectations a bit here.
- https://www.wsj.com/tech/ai/meta-ai-chatbots-sex-a25311bf - https://www.404media.co/instagram-is-blocking-minors-from-ac...
Back to the original inference, anyway… generative ad Personalization instances DO NOT (afaik) appear in the public repository of ads. Researchers can't see it, but do we have to strain our imaginations to think that things like nudify apps aren't taking advantage of tools that do things like drop user avatars into their pitch? e.g. https://www.reddit.com/r/Fauxmoi/comments/1uhy9yn/instagram_...
I don't have a specific citation to offer, but tbh I've seen enough.
I’m not feeling bad for him, but I’m also betting he’s not about to do something stupid like that.
And at this point, let me say you seem to care about your kids and probably have the technical skills and attention to make sure they never end up in his database. But you are an exception, and society needs to protect the children of parents who care less.
What type of people is that? I am just a dad who has them and films his kids doing cute things without making the phone camera an ever present intrusion while outdoors.
It's fine, it's Meta, suspicion is warranted, but I'm hoping it can be moderated and directed. People like me are kind of left out right now in what seems to be a runaway narrative.
P.S: Would love a suggestion that doesn't involve angrily telling parents to not take pictures of their kids as an alternative. It sucks that I have to explain that this will be happening anyway.