Re:Show HN: Laptop is the last place your secrets are still ...
by QuantumNomad_ on Sunday August 16, 2026 @03:53AM
(#49317839)
> The point is that whatever you're executing isn't verified, whether it's a shell script or a binary.
The GP said:
> This should be an ordinary app bundle to drop into /Applications
There is no difference between downloading an app bundle that you drop into /Applications, and curling a binary that you put in /usr/local/bin/
Re:Show HN: Laptop is the last place your secrets are still ...
by ZiiS on Sunday August 16, 2026 @03:53AM
(#49317848)
The difference is you have the executable for examination (at least a quick virus scan) before you run it. Certanly not perfect, but what is?
Re:Show HN: Laptop is the last place your secrets are still ...
by hnlmorg on Sunday August 16, 2026 @04:02AM
(#49317903)
You can still do that with their install instructions ;)
Re:Show HN: Laptop is the last place your secrets are still ...
by ZiiS on Sunday August 16, 2026 @05:00AM
(#49318240)
That is what I am saying, you are trusting them, but less then `curl | sh`
Re:Show HN: Laptop is the last place your secrets are still ...
by hnlmorg on Sunday August 16, 2026 @05:35AM
(#49318432)
You’re right. My apologies
Re:Show HN: Laptop is the last place your secrets are still ...
by fragmede on Sunday August 16, 2026 @04:45AM
(#49318156)
Is there McAfee for Mac? There's no real difference. You're trusting someone not to root your shit. Whether it's via curl, dmg, or apt, we have no idea who anybody really is, so it's all on an assumption that people aren't evil. Unfortunately it turns out that there are evil people out there, but doing it via curl | bash or downloading a dmg or though some app store, there's still evil that's gonna get you if you end up trusting in the wrong people.
And an executable can do exactly the same as a shell script. The point is that whatever you're executing isn't verified, whether it's a shell script or a binary.