I'm not sure what you're saying. Good OCR should recognize the text when it's distorted slightly, right? Which would yield false positives, no?
As much as I'd like to pick this apart, I think the slide captcha is actually pretty clever. We can nitpick implementation details all day, but most of those can be fixed. I wish I had thought of it.
About the OCR - what I meant is that most of their images had text meaning I can OCR every step and if I get something with dictionary words I submit. It will work even the OCR is very permissive (recognizes distorted text as you put it) because this implementation accepts not only the perfect straight solution but also "close enough"s.
Again, fair point on this particular implementation. However, there's no reason to have the fudge factor. It's already plenty easy to get the exact answer.
Ignoring that fudge factor, there are at least 6 options on each side of the correct answer that (I would assume) can be OCRed also. So the OCR method only cuts out maybe half of the wrong answers... perhaps better because the correct one will me closer to the middle?
I think a more foolproof attack vector would be too look for vertical and horizontal lines, which are only going to show up in the correct image.
More generally speaking - it's a very nice idea, but basically there are too few invalid answers to make it practical. You changed an open-ended question of a conventional captcha into a multiple choice.
This is Yet Another Complete Crap CAPTCHA. It isn't solving the problem of prevent real spammers from sending you real spam, it's solving the problem of looking enough like a CAPTCHA to think you're getting somewhere. Or in this case, selling you something.
Also, at least the spiral one I got is flat-out solvable; run "find edges", run a search for the characteristic slope relationship of the lines at various points in the images... would probably take a decent computer vision student about four hours, tops. That hardly even qualifies as trying.
* Moving the slider bit by bit and OCRing will solve 90% of the images I've seen.
* If the image selection is small you could just build a DB of all slider positions and just teach it how it is supposed to look once.
* It's not only easier for the users. It is also easier for captcha solvers in India, China, etc. This will improve their productivity immensely and free up their other hand.