I'm not sure it will be more foolproof since images don't really need to have long horizontal or vertical lines, but it is indeed another great attack path.
If it has non-handwritten text, it will. If it has a banner or button, it will. If the layout contains a rectangle or divider or border, it will. I don't expect to see ads without the previously mentioned items very often.
Again, fair point on this particular implementation. However, there's no reason to have the fudge factor. It's already plenty easy to get the exact answer.
Ignoring that fudge factor, there are at least 6 options on each side of the correct answer that (I would assume) can be OCRed also. So the OCR method only cuts out maybe half of the wrong answers... perhaps better because the correct one will me closer to the middle?
I think a more foolproof attack vector would be too look for vertical and horizontal lines, which are only going to show up in the correct image.