News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by jaggederest on Saturday August 15, 2026 @01:59PM (#49312738)
I have some individual anecdotal evidence. I spent a long time, basically a year, relatively heavy but on a very small dose of GLP drugs due to tolerability issues, and my labs improved dramatically, to a degree we redid them out of disbelief, even without weight loss. I believe one of the suspected underlying causes is reduction in fatty liver despite constant body weight and composition, and also inflammation reduction directly through GLP influence in other areas of the body.

I'm not great evidence because N=1 and all the confounders, but I found that it absolutely made me much healthier without weight loss. I then went on to increase the dose slowly and have lost a bunch of weight and my labs improved even more, which I attribute mostly to the body mass reduction.

Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by alyandon on Saturday August 15, 2026 @02:07PM (#49312801)
Similar experience here on minimal dose of GLP-1. There is definitely something going on here other than "you are just losing weight and that's really why you are healthier".

With my labs at my current weight you can not tell that I am a type 2 diabetic. Previously, when I was at this very same weight in the past - all my labs indicated I was prediabetic.

Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by anon291 on Saturday August 15, 2026 @04:30PM (#49314047)
A lot of metabolic stuff is due to insulin and insulin sensitivity. This drives pretty much everything. Insulin sensitization is pretty terrible and it gets more important as you age. Unfortunately natural selection doesn't need to fix this as it doesn't cause issues until after reproduction and often until after your grandkids are born.

Semaglutide and glp1s resensitize it which is why they have these effects.

My opinion

Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by alyandon on Sunday August 16, 2026 @01:22PM (#49321889)
I strongly suspect that it has had an impact on my insulin sensitivity as well.
Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by aucisson_masque on Saturday August 15, 2026 @05:17PM (#49314429)
Could be just because you stopped eating bad food. Things improve dramatically once you limit your intake of industrialized food.
Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by preg_match on Saturday August 15, 2026 @07:10PM (#49315157)
Not that dramatically. Things like fatty liver take a long time to reverse. It’s not like you stop eating junk food and then suddenly your body is chilling. No, the damage is done and takes a long time to repair. It’s like smoking. You can benefits from quitting smoking within 20 minutes. But to reach the full benefit and reversal, you need 15 years.
Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by basilgohar on Saturday August 15, 2026 @10:33PM (#49316380)
There are other significant factors beyond the ones you mentioned, such as inflammation due to processed foods, certain oils, and more that are common in industrialized medicine.

Plenty of anecdata of people who stopped eating certain categories of food and certain conditions they had for a long time went away. In my son's case, a severe case of eczema that persisted for years went away in a matter of weeks after we significantly reduced the amount of hydrogenated oil products available to him to eat.

Sure enough, when we would visit my mom's place which had it, and he'd indulge, the symptoms came back. Same thing when we would buy it at home and he's splurge, he'd have the same problems recur. Cutting it out of the diet is the only thing that correlated highly with the absence of the condition. This happened even after a move from one state to another.

One case, not proof, but definitely repeatable in our circumstances. I have heard a LOT of similar stories. Is it proof? No, but it's an amazingly easy thing to try. It's takes an adjustment, but it intuitively makes sense. Processed food of today is something our ancestors wouldn't even recognize as food. It's just not what our bodies were designed to handle. Some can handle it better than others, but such a processed food and artificial sugar-heavy diet can't be called natural or even healthy.

Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by preg_match on Sunday August 16, 2026 @01:42AM (#49317221)
A lot of this largely is not true. People think that paleothic humans ate a lot of meat - they did not. They ate very little meat, we eat the most meat we’ve ever eaten now.

And the meat they did eat was lean game meat. It was high in unsaturated fats - like our modern day oils. Not like a steak. A steak is a product of farming. It’s a new invention, <10,000 years. Prior, humans ate almost exclusively nuts, fruits and foliage.

Yes oils are “refined”, but humans have been eating unsaturated oils predominantly for almost all of our existence. The proliferation of animal fats is very, very new. Really, it’s past 100 years. Before that meat was rare, it was a delicacy, very expensive for people.

Now, high sugar is a different story. But the oil thing is complex, it’s not as a simple as oil bad animal fat good and natural. No, it’s very unnatural.

Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by somenameforme on Sunday August 16, 2026 @02:36AM (#49317455)
No idea where you're getting this from. The paleolithic was during an ice age full of big fatty game like sloths, mammoths, and so on. Some believe we hunted these animals to the point of extinction with a tiny population, which would imply a very high level, arguably unbelievably high, of consumption of meat. Even if we didn't hunt them to extinction we certainly did engage in relatively large scale hunting and consumption of vast quantities of them, which already largely falsifies your concept.

Meat only became more of a luxury in the agricultural age where we started squeezing more and more people into smaller and smaller regions which meant there was no longer enough to go around. So plebs got the carbs, and royalty got the protein. FWIW you can also see this in the groups that have ancient traditions dating back far into the past, like the various tribal groups in Russia, Mongolian nomads, etc. Meat, and many highly creative ways of preserving it [1], remain the majority of their diet. They probably don't date back to the paleo, but at least far back enough to falsify the claim that animal fats are even remotely novel.

[1] - https://www.rbth.com/russian-kitchen/334150-dish-kill-kopalk...

Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by adjejmxbdjdn on Sunday August 16, 2026 @09:51AM (#49320078)
This is just not true.

In reality we have little to no idea what the proportion of meat to non meat humans ate at the time.

More realistically, different groups of humans ate different ratios of such foods.

There were almost certainly a pretty large group of humans, for example, who were basically frugivores.

You can simply look up Wikipedia and find all the references about our limited knowledge and the high likelihood that there was no single paleo diet.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paleolithic

Ultimately, humans have been opportunistic omnivores capable of eating and surviving on whatever was most easily available, which is part of why they spread so successfully across the globe.

Trying to look at our history is a silly way to determine what is a good diet for humans today when we can scientifically examine humans today and identify what foods are healthier than others for them.

It’s like instead of noticing that drinking purified water has better outcomes for human beings today, insisting that we shouldn’t live drink untreated water straight out of streams and lakes because that’s what our Paleolithic ancestors did.

Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by somenameforme on Sunday August 16, 2026 @11:05AM (#49320771)
On topics like this that have any chance of being politicized, don't just read Wiki - but actually look at what those numbers link to, go to them, and decide if you find them compelling. Because there will be entire sections of Wiki that are based on extremely fringe views. In other cases what is said on Wiki misrepresents what it links to.

The idea that paleolithic humans, in any significant number, may have been 'frugivores' - living off fruit, is based on a fringe book for which I was able to dig up very little other than a somewhat scathing review here, [1] concluding: "If there is any science that is influenced by our cultural background, expectations, and desires it is anthropology, and we must take care to make sure that what we want to be true doesn't obscure our vision."

---

As for just 'sciencing' food, it doesn't really work because health is more holistic than basic measurables. Your example hits on one aspect of this. The motivation for 'real water' is because we've relatively recently learned that the human gut biome has a dramatic influence on our health and psychology. It even has a potential link to autism. I'm not ready to start going for 'real water' to address that but there are related issues.

For instance glyphosate was believed to be safe because it having no apparent reaction on the human body, but it turns out that (amongst other issues) it completely wrecks the human gut biome with effects that are not well understood. Yet if you look at the nutritional content or other measurables of e.g. glyphosate desiccated wheat, there's not going to be any red flags outside high levels of glyphosate. It's even a viable explanation for the odd rise of seemingly inconsistent 'gluten sensitivity'.

---

Anyhow, point of that all being that we know what worked in the past, worked and worked extremely well. The dramatic rise of various issues in the present ranging from declining IQs, increasing obesity, falling testosterone levels, sharp increases in many forms of mental illness - autism not least of all, and so on - suggests that we're doing something, or more likely - some things, that are quite harmful to ourselves, but that we probably believe to be safe.

[1] - https://www.wired.com/2009/06/book-review-man-the-hunted/

Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by inglor_cz on Sunday August 16, 2026 @01:10PM (#49321786)
IIRC you can analyze dental calculus found on teeth and detect the proportions of various protein sources in the diet of that individual, but IDK how far back in time you can do this.

Several hundred years is certainly possible, Medieval cemeteries can be analyzed like that.

(Whenever my dentist cleans my calculus, we joke that we are ruining some future archeologist's work :)

Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by aucisson_masque on Thursday August 20, 2026 @01:27AM (#49370682)
I did read your link but it doesn't prove your point at all.

Population in specific places used to eat meat because nothing grows there, but they were an exception to the rule. It's been known that our ancestors were mostly scavengers.

Hunting animals is much more dangerous that picking strawberry, back then a cut may lead to death, a broken bone was death.

Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by inglor_cz on Sunday August 16, 2026 @09:58AM (#49320143)
People in certain regions always ate a lot of meat. For example, the Inuit don't really have anything else to eat. Nothing edible grows that far North. And they are neither obese nor suffer from classical diseases of civilization, until they start eating highly processed modern food.

The Maasai are also known to eat a lot of meat and dairy.

Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by preg_match on Sunday August 16, 2026 @11:10AM (#49320815)
I'm sure you can eat a diet fairly high in meat and dairy and be healthy, IF you are lean enough and exercise enough. However, I can pretty confidently say the Intuit did not eat nearly as much meat and dairy as modern Americans. And, the meat they did eat was not the same because it was wild, not farmed.

But, humans have been eating unsaturated fat from nuts, seeds, and meat for millennia. Unsaturated fat is not the devil. We have very strong evidence that a diet high in meat, particularly farmed red meat, is both carcinogenic and causes heart disease. When you look at high processed diets across the globe today, you'll notice they have similarities:

1. Extreme consumption of fatty, farmed meats

2. Very little fruits, vegetables, nuts, and other foods high in fiber

3. Processed shelf-stable goods

4. Extreme portion sizes

When people look at the Mediterranean diet, it's not just that they eat much more food high in unsaturated fat as opposed to saturated fat. They also eat less and move much more.

Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by jaggederest on Sunday August 16, 2026 @12:38PM (#49321561)
> However, I can pretty confidently say the Intuit did not eat nearly as much meat and dairy as modern Americans.

Incorrect, your points are otherwise true. Inuit diet was close to 100% animal products, way more than anyone but carnivore diet people today eat.

Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by preg_match on Monday August 17, 2026 @09:33AM (#49330576)
By percentage, sure, by absolute value, no.

Most Americans are obese, so we’re already eating way more than the intuit. Probably 1000+ calories more a day.

And then, Americans eat multiple servings of meat with every meal.

Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by inglor_cz on Sunday August 16, 2026 @01:03PM (#49321739)
The Inuit don't really have any choice, nothing of nutritional value grows up there. They also prefer fat to lean meat, no surprise in conditions of the Far North. Also, during the Polar Night, they didn't move that much.

I agree that the fact that this meat and fat is wild may be the root cause of the differences between their and our health outcomes. That indicates, though, that we may have something in our forms of meat and dairy that potentially harms us - and that if we identify what, we may be able to get rid of that specific problem.

Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by aucisson_masque on Thursday August 20, 2026 @01:20AM (#49370642)
True but the Inuits are the exception, not the rule.

It's been pretty much accepted that out ancestors (a long time ago) were scavengers, then became farmers/Livestock farmers and then industrialization.

It's only with the latest that we did start to produce meat in large quantity.

Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by basilgohar on Sunday August 16, 2026 @06:48PM (#49324559)
If you got out of my comment that oils and fats are bad, then you didn't understand my point. I was emphasizing on the negative effects of processed foods.
Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by tbugrara on Sunday August 16, 2026 @12:50AM (#49317012)
This isn't true, fatty liver can improve very quickly. Where are you getting "15 years" from?
Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by preg_match on Sunday August 16, 2026 @01:38AM (#49317201)
The 15 years is for smoking. Fatty liver can improve but it’s not gonna be a one day thing. It’s a consistent lifestyle change.

Also, simply cutting out junk food will absolutely not reverse fatty liver. You need to eat less and lose weight.

Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by blensor on Sunday August 16, 2026 @01:59PM (#49322182)
About 2 years ago I my cardiologist wanted to put me on medication because my blood test was already so bad ( prediabetic, liver was impacted, overweight, etc. )

However I wanted to try to get it under control myself ( cutting out almost all carbs, liver friendly diet, lot's of exercise ), she didn't think it would make a difference but she humored me and gave me a 3 month period to try and get it back to normal.

This year ( about 2 years since I started and about 1 3/4 years since my values were good ) she told me that she now has to completely remove prediabetis from my diagnosis because she can no longer justify it based on all the tests we did since then.

Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by anovikov on Sunday August 16, 2026 @08:50AM (#49319575)
People's habits usually don't change. They still eat the same plastic crap, just less of it.
Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by alyandon on Sunday August 16, 2026 @01:19PM (#49321859)
My diet consisted mostly of lean meats like chicken and vegetables.
Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by BobbyJo on Sunday August 16, 2026 @01:55PM (#49322148)
Being weight X while gaining weight is a significantly different metabolic state than being weight X while losing weight.
Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by highfrequency on Sunday August 16, 2026 @02:33PM (#49322461)
Very cool - to be clear, are both your diet composition and calorie intake similar before vs. after?
Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by Suppafly on Saturday August 15, 2026 @09:26PM (#49315991)
I really wish my insurance would cover GLP-1s, because I think reduction in fatty liver and other ancillary benefits, along with the weight loss, would be medically helpful for me.
Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by wildrice on Saturday August 15, 2026 @10:45PM (#49316440)
I was paying $1400 a month of my GLP-1 (on top of the $2400 monthly health insurance premium). I eventually just bought a batch from a reputable online compounding pharmacy for a very small fraction of that (about 12 months of meds at a time), and send one of the vials in for testing at a mass spectrometer for about $500.
Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by SwamyM on Saturday August 15, 2026 @11:49PM (#49316725)
Would you mind sharing the online pharmacy and the testing facility you used?

I've been wary of using online pharmacies due to concerns with knowing what's legitimate and what's not, so maybe a recommendation would help.

If you don't want to share publicly, can you put you contact info in your profile and I'll reach out to you?

Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by JKCalhoun on Saturday August 15, 2026 @11:06PM (#49316539)
I've been given a sheet of prices for self-pay in the U.S. and they range from $150 to $350 for the lower doses (the oral versions are $150, the injections $300 and $350). These are not online prices, just local pharmacy prices.
Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by Suppafly on Saturday August 15, 2026 @10:46PM (#49316447)
I thought they closed whatever loophole that let compounding pharmacies do GLP1s, but I suppose online there are ways around that.
Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by jsjohnst on Sunday August 16, 2026 @09:41AM (#49320016)
Amazon Pharmacy sells name brand GLP-1s (Ozempic, Wegovy, Zepbound, etc) for $250-400/month without insurance.
Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by derektank on Sunday August 16, 2026 @09:59AM (#49320151)
Yeah, Eli Lilly is selling Zepbound direct to consumer for roughly the same price too (with a prescription, obviously). People should generally avoid compounding pharmacies unless they have a specific need, many are not based in the US and not subject to the same regulatory standards as manufacturers (either generic or brand name).
Re:Semaglutide linked to 26% lower 5-year predicted dementia... by sgerenser on Sunday August 16, 2026 @10:53AM (#49320677)
Yep, check out lillydirect. Relative of mine barely missed the cutoff for insurance coverage (in terms of starting BMI) but lillydirect will sell you actual zepbound for something like $399/month. The cost is also reimbursable with an HSA if you have one.

You do need a prescription, but generally most physicians will write you one if you are overweight even if you don't meet the high bar for insurance coverage.