Perhaps you could contact the author with your suggestions?
Why do you disagree with them?
> What are your thoughts on the other comments in this chain that claim that the references and citations as they are in the linked post are acceptable?
> Why do you disagree with them?
Which comments in particular are you talking about?
And I mean, the post doesn't have "references and citations" plural that I can see. It has one clear reference. I see two comments defending that reference, and a whole bunch of comments saying that a post like this doesn't need references.
I don't need to disagree with any of those comments. My point isn't about whether a post that lacks citations is "acceptable". I was talking about whether a post could add historical citations without losing momentum, so it could do a better job of fitting into context. A dozen notes sprinkled around about when/where different ideas came from, not just the mention at the very end of what decade arithmetic coding is from and the mention of the 2023 paper.
I will say it's bad that the 2023 paper is described as "arguing that language modeling and compression are two views of the same thing", emphasis in the original. That very much makes it sound like a new idea when it isn't.
I'm confused by the comments that seem to imply that the author is taking credit for ideas that they're writing about, as I didn't get that impression from writing in the article at all.
I'm also confused by the idea that they didn't provide enough citations for concepts in a non-academic source. I feel like in the day and age of Wikipedia it should be sufficient to colourize / bold terms like "Entropy coders" or "Huffman Encoding" to indicate to the reader that these are important terms that they can research for more details if interested.
Overall I guess my position on this is that ~80/285 comments on this post are related to whether not this is a good post which I think is far too many. There are slight issues with the post but they aren't worth 80 comments.
Specifically the comment I replied to suggested it was a style tradeoff but I don't see why you can't do citations in either style. That's all I came here for.
> I'm also confused by the idea that they didn't provide enough citations for concepts in a non-academic source.
It's useful information about how we got here. That's good in any long story about an idea.
> I feel like in the day and age of Wikipedia it should be sufficient to colourize / bold terms like "Entropy coders" or "Huffman Encoding" to indicate to the reader that these are important terms that they can research for more details if interested.
It works to some extent but some of the concepts don't have fancy words for them and then they don't get that searchability.
> ~80/285 comments
Sometimes tangents spark a discussion. I don't think those numbers are an issue. And they're mostly not calling it a bad post, they just have an objection.
When standing on the shoulders of giants it's hard to tell what is below them.
It's wild to me what people here expect out of something they got for free and that was offered as a gift.
Snarky replies always appreciated
I have no idea why you think the world owes you endless 101-level discourse, but I hope you recognize you're setting yourself up for equally endless disappointment. If you take a little responsibility for your own education, you'll be happier.
I think one method is superior to another.
Anybody, anything, obligated, and any related information are hyperbolic terms I would have avoided. I understand with a weak position people often resort to hyperbole.
I believe adding more terms to be googled is superior to fewer search terms. When working with ideas from first principles sharing the roots and development is superior to making no reference.
I have no idea why you think the world owes me anything. I was describing what I prefer.
I'm not sure why you think I'm not already endlessly disappointed by the state of the world and it's discourse. not having expectations always helps.
I think that if you stop projecting ideals on strangers might help your mood.
But taking you at your word, if there are things that don't meet your personal tastes, maybe move on to the next thing to read? Not everything has to be for everybody. There are plenty of audiences where people are capable of digging deeper when they want it. Personally, I prefer writers who don't spell everything out. The kind of writing you favor I generally find tedious. I'd much rather read something that shows a little faith in the audience.
james burke connections https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XetplHcM7aQ&pp=ygUXamFtZXMgY...
Tim Hunkin Secret Life of Machines
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CJlrbMHLBd4&list=PLtaR0lZhSy...
I have read plenty of blog posts that meet my standard. If I can think of one I will post it.
The con is that you don't get to understand and see any of the history of the ideas or even the ballpark when it was discovered, you attribute it to the blog mentally and you don't know what is how new or old and can't reference it properly when talking to others.