News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by ajross on Sunday August 09, 2026 @09:42AM (#49231349)
Two things can be true: the construction can be technically legal and at clear odds with community opinion.

I mean, yes. Amazon can likely do this. But is this strategy really in keeping with its long term interests? I mean, look at the comments in the rest of this very topic. Do you want a communist insurrection? This is literally how you get communist insurrections. People are fucking pissed, and the bourge^M^M^M^M funding-focused growth-minded startup set here are throwing gasoline on the fire.

Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by Miner49er on Sunday August 09, 2026 @09:59AM (#49231503)
6 years ago when the work to build the data center started, nobody cared about data centers.

Should 6 years of planning be thrown away because data centers have recently become fashionable to hate?

Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by Matl on Sunday August 09, 2026 @10:17AM (#49231660)
So noise and pollution that makes it impossible to live in or sell your house is now simply 'fashionable' to hate?
Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by ACCount37 on Sunday August 09, 2026 @10:26AM (#49231743)
Yep.

The "noise and pollution" of a datacenter are bordering on nonexistent. The same goes for water use concerns and more. The environmental concerns are extremely overblown - but NIMBYs really don't need much to get going.

Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by throwaway173738 on Sunday August 09, 2026 @11:19AM (#49232228)
So which data center do you call neighbor?
Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by ajross on Sunday August 09, 2026 @10:25AM (#49231732)
This is going to sound like I'm flipping sides in this thread: but yeah, absolutely. Otherwise people in Gilroy would have hated datacenters when the planning started and Amazon would have built in Fresno or wherever.

Really both sides are insane in this battle. People are angry about social change, injustice, perceived loss of status and are taking out those frustrations on totems like "Buildings Owned by Big Tech". Which is wrong. But it's equally wrong to ignore those concerns and try to align with their political enemies, which only makes this worse. (We saw exactly this thing happen with the vaccine madness just half a decade ago!)

To wit: we're all going to hell in a handbasket and this community is 100% as much at fault as the big data opposition front.

Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by halJordan on Sunday August 09, 2026 @03:36PM (#49234902)
I guess i don't understand why reneging on a binding agreement is the cool thing here. They went through all the requirements. If the requirements should now change that's fine. But hold yourself to the agreement you made. Or appropriately terminate it
Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by Matl on Monday August 10, 2026 @03:47PM (#49248745)
Amazon is not exactly known for playing fair or treating their workers well, so trying to play it like this is somehow the little guy being oppressed here or something is pathetic.

Did it ever occur to you that politicians signing a 'binding agreement' may not be the same as public interest? That they are often paid to hide the full implications from the public? Do you understand that some people actually want to live and raise family in a livable environment?

I understand that Ayn Rand fans who do not have to suffer the consequences of that philosophy or 'futurists' who think purely in 'make AI go brrr is cool' do not understand this, but some people place value on other things in life besides this and yes, they do deserve a place at the table.

As generally a tech optimist, but also someone deeply aware of the awful trajectory modern tech is on, such as their waste, war on general purpose computing, ownership, privacy and repairability, I think a lot of this needs rethinking and perhaps of brute forcing your way to stripping people of their livehoods by polluting, straining the grid and depriving people of places they'd want to live in, slow down and consider if there's not a smarter, more efficient, more humane way to move forward.

Failing to do so may produce a backslash that will harm even the things we love about our space.

The 'contract' is not sacred above everything. Especially when that contract affects a lot more people than those who signed it as 'binding'.

Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by ofjcihen on Sunday August 09, 2026 @10:23AM (#49231700)
6 years of planning can be thrown away if the community is just now becoming aware of the potential impact.

It’s not on the community to adhere to the companies looking to make a profit while ignoring how their presence affects those around them. Quite the opposite really.

Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by arcbyte on Sunday August 09, 2026 @09:47AM (#49231393)
10 years ago these same people were worried about 5g towers going up everywhere.

Nobody intelligent opposes data center construction.*

* There are weird places that daya centers, solar panels farms, adult stores, and all kind businesses have attempted to build. Opposing a prominent location for an undesirable business is not what we are talking about.

Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by Avicebron on Sunday August 09, 2026 @09:59AM (#49231504)
"Nobody intelligent opposes dovecote construction"*

*French nobility circa 1789

Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by nucleogenesis on Sunday August 09, 2026 @10:36AM (#49231831)
Your premise is a straw man so maybe keep your opinion on the intelligence of others to yourself.

Plenty of journalists are eating well reporting on the negative externalities actively felt by residents who live near data centers. It is not hard to find if you look.

Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by InsideOutSanta on Sunday August 09, 2026 @09:51AM (#49231420)
5G towers have no negative externalities except looking kinda dorky. In fact, they're nice; they improve your reception. The same cannot be said for data centers.

(Instead of just downvoting this, I'd appreciate it if you could point out exactly what I said is wrong. Thanks.)

Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by giaour on Sunday August 09, 2026 @10:36AM (#49231832)
5G towers are typically much smaller and less conspicuous than the towers they are replacing. One of 5G's hallmarks is its "small cell" architecture.
Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by peyton on Sunday August 09, 2026 @10:13AM (#49231618)
I think we should refrain extending “negative externality” to mean “things people don’t like that might affect them.” Non-pecuniary externalities, in the Pigouvian sense, are really something you analyze to achieve efficiency. In this case, following a 5-year permitting process and plopping the industrial activity on industrial land is basically a form of bargaining and is probably acceptable from a social efficiency standpoint. Amazon’s hardly mining cobalt next to a daycare here.
Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by InsideOutSanta on Sunday August 09, 2026 @10:16AM (#49231642)
> I think we should refrain extending “negative externality” to mean “things people don’t like that might affect them.”

But that's pretty much the definition of the term. It's a negative impact on a third party. If I'm living next to a data center, and it's noisy, or my electricity costs more, those are negative externalities.

There are real reasons not to want data centers next door, unlike 5G towers.

Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by Apocryphon on Sunday August 09, 2026 @10:38AM (#49231850)
In the South Valley, the pre-data center nemesis were distribution hubs, lambasted for the traffic they caused. Ironically also a key component of Amazon’s physical infrastructure.
Re:Amazon circumvents Gilroy community vote for AI data center by mindslight on Sunday August 09, 2026 @10:26AM (#49231737)
I'd say you're trying to define some ambiguous criteria to keep harms illegible to the analysis and thus deny that they exist. Noise pollution is very much pollution, certainly causes real problems, and falls right into the externality paradigm wherein a party unilaterally causes harm while making others suffer it.

That the effects of noise pollution are hard to formally describe (and extra hard to quantify in monetary terms) does not mean we can just throw up our hands and pretend they don't exist. In fact, I'd say this is exactly why we stake out lofty non-economic ideals like human rights etc - markets have friction (ie are not efficient), and this combined with your reasoning means we could justify anything that produces negative outcomes for humans by simply writing it off as non-economically-legible. But the entire human-value justification for letting markets do their thing rests on the positive benefits they bring to us humans, so that is absurd. And so we always need to look at the larger picture and judge the real-world effects on humans.