News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by stouset on Friday August 07, 2026 @12:17AM (#49205847)
> There shouldn't even need to be a label. A USB-C cable should be a USB-C cable should be a USB-C cable.

Then USB is forever frozen in time, unless we start using new connectors.

This was the tradeoff we got when standardizing on one connector. The protocol versions change (USB, USB-PD, Thunderbolt), the cables that go between each connector change based on the needs of the spec they supports. But the connectors stay the same.

In my opinion, this was a poor tradeoff and now we’re living in the hell we asked for.

If you want every cable to support the latest and greatest of whatever exists as of right now, you can do that. By all means, buy Apple’s USB-C Thunderbolt 5 cables. They’ll run you $70 apiece but you’ll be buying a cable that makes no compromises.

My personal approach is to just use whatever cable came with the device for anything for which that’s convenient and plausible. For mobile devices with relatively limited charging speeds over USB-PD and for which portability and durability are typically important, I buy the latest Apple woven cables. For high-bandwidth devices I spend the big bucks on the Apple Thunderbolt 5 cables. I discard any cables of unknown provenance.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by kuboble on Friday August 07, 2026 @03:09AM (#49206914)
> now we’re living in the hell we asked for

N=1, but my quality of life has greatly improved. Literally all devices I use daily (laptop, phone, mp3 player, Bluetooth speaker, headphones) I charge from a single cable.

I'm still grateful for this unification every time I charge my phone via the laptop charger.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by riffraff on Friday August 07, 2026 @03:34AM (#49207064)
I'm also happy we have a single connector but, n=1, I have a couple things that will not work with all cables.

I have no idea why, nor have I bothered to find out, I just marked the cables they came with (which are USB-A to USB-C) same as GP did.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by mrheosuper on Friday August 07, 2026 @03:54AM (#49207211)
>I have no idea why, nor have I bothered to find out

The reason is simple; your device violated the USB-C spec by saving $0.0000002 of BOM cost

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by hulitu on Friday August 07, 2026 @08:04AM (#49209125)
> your device violated the USB-C spec

I heard there are more than one USB-C specs.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by stouset on Friday August 07, 2026 @06:01PM (#49216750)
USB-C is a physical connector layout.

The full cable that is between the two connector ends has an enormous matrix of specifications it can support. There are variations of bandwidth, power delivery (or not), Thunderbolt versions (or not), DisplayPort versions (or not) and other things I’m forgetting.

A cable that supports all of these things costs like $70+.

Between two devices, the cable, and enormously complicated interop between variations of the supported standards, there are myriad ways for devices to fail to work together.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by mrheosuper on Saturday August 08, 2026 @12:58AM (#49219004)
Im not talking about the cable.

Im talking about whatever the device Parent was mentioning, they violate the spec, that's why they only work with usb a-c cable

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by pwagland on Friday August 07, 2026 @05:03AM (#49207731)
Exactly this. Or charge my laptop via the phone cable, sure, it's slower, but it still works.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by stouset on Friday August 07, 2026 @05:45AM (#49208001)
Now we live in a world where any cable can connect any two devices, but what happens and what’s supported is a complete and total crapshoot. The more devices and cables you own, the more chaotic things become.

I have devices that take USB-C cables but won’t charge if the cable supports USB-PD.

I have a monitor that supports Thunderbolt 3 and two Thunderbolt 3 laptops. It took me multiple tries with various switches and Thunderbolt cables to find a combination that worked.

I have had multiple other situations like this, and the only practical solution I’ve found is to aggressively get rid of cables of questionable provenance, unless you can keep them permanently connected to or associated with the device they came with.

I suspect I’m running into this sooner than most because I’ve gone all-in on USB-C. I have gotten rid of every device possible that used USB micro or USB-A.

For simple electronics that just need to charge? Fine, sure, outside of random cable/device pairs charging slower than expected, it’s nice. For anything that actually depends on features on the cable or on a combination of features supported by the devices on each end? Total chaos.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by Yujf on Friday August 07, 2026 @03:31AM (#49207045)
There is no hell. Just buy a couple of good cables and life is nice
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by fragmede on Friday August 07, 2026 @12:48AM (#49206002)
> just use whatever cable came with the device

the problem comes when the device and cable get separated, and the cable is "helpfully" organized into the bin with the rest of the USB-c cables.

Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by tosti on Friday August 07, 2026 @03:07AM (#49206901)
Oh how this brings back memories of finding all my cables all rolled up and tucked together as if a cable is a cable.
Re:I stopped trusting USB-C cable labels and started testing... by stouset on Friday August 07, 2026 @06:02PM (#49216760)
This not being a problem is supposedly the entire reason for USB-C.