Society did decay because of cellphones but it wasn't anything to do with the cellphone companies. The towers always were exactly what the cellphone companies said they were.
The problem with conspiracy theories is not that they're based on a lack of trust, but that they're not rational. Sometimes a lack of trust is perfectly rational.
Cell towers don't actually fry your brains. Steam powered trains don't move so fast you suffocate. However, the big tech CEOs are absolutely going to take your data and use it against you. They are going to build data centers that harm your community. The fear here is reasonable and evidenced.
This isn't unique to AI, but AI is the current iteration of the same problem. Sometimes people distrust outsiders because they're star-bellied sneetches, but sometimes they distrust them because they're the British empire. You can't treat all distrust as unreasoning.
Rationality isn't some sort of absolute parameter, it's determined wrt available information. And with information coming from outside it's certainly an issue of trust.
FWIW such unconditional claim as "DC will harm your community" is a shiny example of this, as you don't even care to talk about a particular DC, and obviously cases (community problems, and interests, and the way a DC placed or build) can vary a lot. Apparently, you just don't believe them at all, don't you?
>You can't treat all distrust as unreasoning.
I don't. I just noticed that arguments you believe are central are very stretchy, and can 'prove' anything, including conspiracy theories.
The available information is very clear that cellphone towers are not mind control and that the current leaders of the tech world do not have the best interests of people in mind.
We don't need to talk about a particular DC, because that's beside the point: people have very legitimate reasons to oppose them on principle.
> the current leaders of the tech world do not have the best interests of people in mind.
Did they ever?I guess you don't get the comparison cause cell towers aren't controversial anymore since they are a usual part of landscape. They used to be, however, and lots of arguments are literally the same. Including, of course "on principle".
Well of course it's because the companies think they don't have to give a good deal. That they can get away with it.
One wonders if at this point they would have saved money not trying to fuck people over to get what they wanted. I hope so. The ideal world has companies doing things the honest way because it's honest, but I'd settle for them doing it that way because they're economically incentivized to do so.
As it happens they are competing on service quality and goodwill more than price (all will drop the price quite a bit if you ask because it's well over their costs and, bless, they are actually competing on price for once). I know that fiber's service is technically good but I resent Google enough that I will not give them money, all else being equal. Of course if I end up resenting the other providers more, maybe I would.
And no, they'll lower prices to prevent losing customers preemptively as well. But only if you ask them to
These people, these communities, have been promised these same things before (or things adjacent to them) and have seen them not deliver, or even make their situation worse.
This is especially true of the tax income and job generation elements. The estimates provided as part of the deal are utterly divorced from reality- people know it and refuse to take part in the kayfabe that surrounds it.
HN commenters favouring data centers never seem to address this either. It appears they just don't get it
If someone does not like "AI" software nor the people behind it, then it makes little sense to argue about electricity, water, eminent domain, etc.
Big Tech founders have claimed that the public "trusts" them because the public uses ("chooses") their software. But does this amount to "real world" trust
>HN commenters favouring data centers never seem to address this either. It
>appears they just don't get it.
Can you point me to some comments favouring data centers? I know people get the opinion that I favour things that I do not because I challenge unsupported claims against them. I have a tendency to defend against any criticism that I feel to be unfair. This seems to conflict with a point of view that any argument that moves people to your cause is a good argument, whether it is valid or not. The sense that perception is truth is ingrained into a lot of people subconsciously, and there are a cynical few who believe it explicitly.
The problem with the "known to be bad actors" argument is that an action is assumed to be done with bad intentions because they are bad actors, which is then used as evidence that they are bad actors.
There are definitely bad actions, and each should be addressed. There are few organisations that perform bad actions as a goal. Religion and other ideologies followed to a similar extent can provide that. Self interest rarely does. This is where Larry the Lawnmower becomes a useful demonstration, A lawnmower is not your enemy, even if it does chop your hand off.
>If someone does not like "AI" software nor the people behind it, then it makes little sense to argue about electricity, water, eminent domain, etc.
People know this. But they also know that not liking something (and I think hate is not too strong a word for the depth of feeling here) just because of what it is, is prejudice. People do not want to be bigots so they argue the issues. Electricity, Water, intellectual property, competition for work, intellectual property, privacy, etc. Those are all individual issues each with their own properties. If a person has a wide variety of individual issues like that and they decide against a single thing like AI, then there are only a few options. It is either a massive coincidence, a sign of prejudice, or the coordinated work of someone who is explicitly aligned against you.
The same would, of course, would have to be true for those people aligned against you. If all of their thoughts supported one result they would be similarly be prejudiced. So if you take the path of assuming they are against you, you cannot accept that they would do anything to address your concerns.
This leads to what was stated above
>Closed-loop cooling systems? “I don’t believe them.” Paying millions in taxes? “I don’t believe them.” Creating a thousand jobs? “I don’t believe them.” I hear a reflexive skepticism of every claim.
I'm not even sure that what the article says is true when they say
"Back in San Francisco, it is striking how little the AI industry understands its own unpopularity"
I think there is an awareness, but also a sense that there is nothing that can be done except ignore it. If they do the bad thing, they will be vilified. If they do the good thing, no-one will believe it and they will be vilified. Once trust has been lost, there is no point in engaging. Any attempt to regain trust would be seen as an attempt at further manipulation.
We live in a world where people will look you in the eye and say with absolute certainty that the fact that "Don't be evil" was taken out of the Google code supports the idea they are bad actors.
Yet to this day, the last line of their code of conduct says...
"And remember... don’t be evil, and if you see something that you think isn’t right – speak up!
Last updated July 16, 2026"
People will say that with such confidence that, If I say it is not true, they enthusiastically search it up, express surprise that the "don't be evil" is still there, and then say that it means nothing, because it's their actions that matter.
...and that is the truth. It _is_ their actions that matter. That's precisely what I push back on things that claim to know what their actions will be based upon some hidden state that they believe can be divined. The sense of certainty that they are malevolent, because they did a thing that was interpreted as a bad thing because they were assumed to be malevolent.
People, organisations, corporations, and governments can all do bad things. They can all do good things. We can judge their deeds better than we can judge their intentions.
Perhaps instead of "We don't believe you" people could just start with "I would like to believe you, show me how"
This former Google employee, not operating under an anonymous username, says to a live audience at 19:00 that "Don't be evil", as suggested at a company meeting by a fellow employee in June 2000, was in fact meant to be a joke
He says that he thinks Google has "strayed a bit"
I feel like this is projection. If you look at the list of top brands ranked by a variety of dimensions (trust, innovativeness, brand value, etc.) over the past multiple years, Big Tech companies regularly rank amongst the top 100.
The HN population, being mostly in the tech industry, is aware of all the shenanigans these companies pull and that has colored our views. But the rest of the general population... not so much. I mean, even Meta properties still rank highly despite all the things we know Meta has been doing pretty much since inception.
I do agree though that despite what reasons citizens may be citing in public -- power bills, water, pollution, noise -- the real pushback is against the "AI will take our jobs" fear. To be fair, it's not just an abstract fear for a number of people already.
> I recall Microsoft and Amazon making a lot of concessions to get some of their sites approved.
Yes, that is exactly what I meant when I wrote: "My guess: They are incredibly careful about how they plan data center expansion to reduce brand impact." Most large construction projects and buildings/factories require "lot of concessions". It is a fact of life in a modern democracy.
> My conversations make me wonder if the technical content of data center deals is mostly beside the point. Closed-loop cooling systems? “I don’t believe them.” Paying millions in taxes? “I don’t believe them.” Creating a thousand jobs? “I don’t believe them.” I hear a reflexive skepticism of every claim.
It's not reflexive; it's evidenced. Regardless of what big tech promises, or potential mitigations, everyone knows what tech companies do now. It's not a generalised small-town lack of trust in big city folks, it's a direct response to decades of extractive behaviour by the same companies and people.
Essentially, I think there's a proximal reputational problem for AI companies, which the article calls out, but the ultimate problem is factual. It's not an education/communication/negotiation issue, because the real problem is the underlying reality. The wolf at the door being distrusted is because it's a wolf, not PR.