News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by jenius on Thursday December 13, 2012 @11:16AM (#4916318)
Hey guys - project creator here. Would love to get any and all feedback - this project has been my passion for over a year and I'm super excited to finally release it!

Also, this website is open source in addition to the project. It's here on github: https://github.com/jenius/roots.cx

Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by alexcabrera on Thursday December 13, 2012 @01:31PM (#4917239)
This is really nice and a great way to rapidly build without resorting to templates or bootstrap. Highly polished, great work.

We released something built on the same stack (jade, stylus, coffeescript) that's a bit more lightweight, more geared towards building prototypes called [proto](https://github.com/droptype/proto). Because it's focused on building small prototypes, it saves everything to gists and provides a viewer at http://proto.es/{gist-id}.

Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by jenius on Thursday December 13, 2012 @01:34PM (#4917264)
Thanks so much! I really appreciate it. Proto looks like top quality stuff - excellent work. I'm going to check this out in depth - perhaps our tools can learn something from each other or combine in some way : )
Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by alexcabrera on Thursday December 13, 2012 @01:55PM (#4917401)
That would be fantastic. As I said, root is very highly polished and you've done a great job. We have something in the pipeline that might make sense to collaborate on. Will shoot you an email to discuss.
Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by jenius on Thursday December 13, 2012 @02:26PM (#4917567)
Awesome, thanks. Got your email, will be in touch shortly!
Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by msutherl on Thursday December 13, 2012 @11:45AM (#4916504)
Really great job, excited to try this out. Are there any other similar projects out there (aside from Yeomen)?
Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by jrmoran on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:03PM (#4916639)
There are a few

http://mimosajs.com/

http://brunch.io/

----

On a related note, I'm currently using Grunt.JS with few plugins for Compass, CoffeeScript and Live Reload. Similar to Guards (ruby based), it's the plugin ecosystem that makes it valuable and able to suit multiple needs.

Needless to say, roots sounds interesting.

Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by jenius on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:25PM (#4916806)
I will admit that this is a rather opinionated framework. I'm kind of shooting for the apple philosophy - reduce flexibility for a lighter and more beautiful product. I've worked with a lot of compiled languages and for me, these are the cleanest and easiest to work with. I did try to build in a bit of flex though with the plugin interface and the fact that it compiles html, css, js, and ejs in addition out of the box.
Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by doctorpangloss on Thursday December 13, 2012 @07:32PM (#4918953)
I'm a happy user of Meteor. It has few opinions.
Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by jenius on Friday December 14, 2012 @09:52AM (#4921137)
Meteor is not the same type of project as roots at all, so this comparison doesn't exactly make sense. Although meteor is an awesome project and in addition is backed by at least 3 people working on it full time : )
Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by msutherl on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:22PM (#4916785)
Thanks!

Mimosa seems less opinionated, supports everything. Has modules. Ugly website.

Brunch seems less opinionated, supports everything. Has skeletons, plugin API. Nice website.

Grunt seems like the roll-your-own option and is probably more well supported than the others...?

Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by dbashford on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:31PM (#4916844)
Mimosa author here! I'll work on the website. =) I do think the tool is better documented than some of the others, and I was really going for having the docs rather than making them super pretty.

Mimosa is very pluggable (http://mimosajs.com/modules.html), moreso than Brunch, but slightly less so than grunt, though, to be honest, my grunt experience is slim. That said, grunt obviously has quite the ecosystem of plugins that all the others lack.

Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by msutherl on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:41PM (#4916910)
Hey, sorry about dissing your site. It's not that bad and could be tuned up quite easily.

– The text shadows on the main page are a bit much. 1px offset is sufficient and the shadow color probably doesn't need to be so light.

– Grey boxes around text are too tight and probably shouldn't be so rounded.

– Headers on home-page are either too big or aren't given enough space. Whitespace! Don't be afraid to use it.

– Darker shadows on headers have the same problem – too much offset – just looks tacky.

– Title and description on homepage looks crammed into the top. Give it more space. Maybe smaller text.

– Red headers are way too bright. Tone it down.

– The bathroom-tile background image is kind of weird.

– Body text is too wide throughout the docs.

– More whitespace throughout the design would help (between all typographic elements), especially given your choice of a large, open typeface.

Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by dbashford on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:47PM (#4916947)
HackerNews commenting n00b, but guessing it only lets replies go so deep? Hence my reply to the site suggestions goes here. =)

Crazy kinds of awesome to get that kind of feedback! I'll take a look at all that stuff. Big site update content-wise with my next release and I can make some changes then.

Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by nightpool on Thursday December 13, 2012 @04:22PM (#4918167)
Hacker News has exponential delay time on comments based on depth. So the deeper a comment is, the longer you have to wait to reply to it. It's supposed to help cool off flamewars.
Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by jenius on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:51PM (#4916965)
I'd be happy to help out advising on the design as well if you want. Great work on mimosa, obviously I'm a fan of these kinds of tools : )
Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by dbashford on Thursday December 13, 2012 @01:07PM (#4917087)
Your site definitely looks slick! I'd take any suggestions anyone has and as long as they make sense, implement them. I'd rather be writing node than thinking about design anyway. =)
Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by mcrider on Thursday December 13, 2012 @02:06PM (#4917463)
Sounds like a good blog post if someone went more in depth here. I for one am really happy to see these tools coming out of the woodwork!
Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by dbashford on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:48PM (#4916954)
Thanks for the Mimosa mention!
Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by jenius on Thursday December 13, 2012 @11:46AM (#4916517)
middleman (http://middlemanapp.com/) is a solid alternative for ruby as well - this is the only other one i know of apart from yeoman as you mentioned
Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by roxxor on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:11PM (#4916703)
Cool project. Also, you should checkout Punch (http://laktek.github.com/punch). I like it mainly for the JSON based content definitions, which is really helpful when it comes to prototyping web apps.
Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by jenius on Thursday December 13, 2012 @12:16PM (#4916746)
this looks really cool, thanks for sharing! i'm definitely going to check it out and pick it apart : )
Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by JungleGymSam on Thursday December 13, 2012 @11:25AM (#4916378)
In that case please consider redoing your videos with more care. Both the audio and video are poor. Your microphone should be near your mouth so that you don't sound like you're far away and the video resolution is really low.
Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by jenius on Thursday December 13, 2012 @11:27AM (#4916384)
I know, I definitely need to do a better job with the videos. I just did them this morning (wasn't planning on having them but i thought it might be a good idea) and vimeo really murdered me on the resolution, not sure why. I'll have new ones up soon, promise : )
Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by raimondious on Thursday December 13, 2012 @11:47AM (#4916528)
Not to mention being able to hear every single tap click and movement on the laptop is really distracting. However everything else looks pretty slick!
Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by eranation on Thursday December 13, 2012 @09:50PM (#4919360)
Very exciting, it's hard to keep up with all the moving parts nowadays, I like it. Reminds me of rails composer a little.

as for feedback:

* would love it if you'll add TypeScript support somehow. I come from the Java / Scala world and it will be an easier transition to node dev this way

* best download to launch-in-browser sequence Iv'e seen yet. (roots create foo, cd foo, roots watch) browser actually opens for you, nice touch.

* you seem to put a lot of effort on usability and convenience, please continue.

* good documentation and usage print-outs

* the js client side package manager is a great addition, any dependency management there?

Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by jitl on Thursday December 13, 2012 @10:33PM (#4919471)
It looks like roots is using Bower to manage client-side packages. Bower is Twitter's "front-end JavaScript" package manager. Bower does indeed manage and track dependencies for you, see http://twitter.github.com/bower/
Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by jenius on Thursday December 13, 2012 @10:18PM (#4919422)
Thanks for the feedback, and so glad you like it!

I made a plugin interface just for things like adding typescript support. I know pretty much nothing about typescript through, are there any good node compilers out there? It would be incredible if you made a plugin for it - if not I'd be happy to try to tinker one together myself.

Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by eranation on Thursday December 13, 2012 @10:24PM (#4919437)
Yep

  npm install -g typescript
  tsc helloworld.ts
More info here: http://www.typescriptlang.org

Will give it a shot :)

p.s. I would add a tweet button on the site, I actively looked for it, although I'm lazy I tweeted anyway, but this might give you some extra shout-outs, especially for the shot grace period you are on HN front page

Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by jenius on Friday December 14, 2012 @09:42AM (#4921092)
Thanks! I'll check it out. Feel free to ping me on twitter if you're having trouble or want me to put one together - http://twitter.com/jescalan
Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by jjoe on Thursday December 13, 2012 @06:04PM (#4918635)
Congratulations on releasing this. I think you meant to say sftp instead of ftp.
Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by jenius on Thursday December 13, 2012 @06:34PM (#4918764)
Do you mean on possibly future deploy to ftp implementation? There's a pretty long story behind that one too - ftp is brutal to work with.
Re:Show HN: roots - a toolkit for advanced front-end dev by jjoe on Thursday December 13, 2012 @07:24PM (#4918928)
Sorry for being unclear. On the video you recommended using ftp to transfer the pub folder over to the web server for go live. It's best to recommend a tool that operates on an encrypted ssh transport like sftp/scp/etc.

Regards