News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google shuts down Nobel Prize winning AlphaFold by colingauvin on Wednesday July 29, 2026 @01:00PM (#49100051)
>DeepMind started developing AlphaFold in 2018. In 2020, it was recognized as a solution to humanity's 50-year-old "protein folding problem," which sought to answer how amino acids automatically fold into complex 3D shapes.

This is not even close to reality. AlphaFold is not a solution to the protein folding problem, it's (useful) pattern matching to the end state of solved folded protein (in situations that can be pattern matched). If this is considered "solving the protein folding problem" then X-ray crystallography solved it first, 75 years ago.

There is essentially zero "how" information coming to us from AlphaFold. This type of reporting is incorrect, and irresponsible to the folks that are still working on that how problem.

Re:Google shuts down Nobel Prize winning AlphaFold by chermi on Wednesday July 29, 2026 @01:20PM (#49100353)
Pissed me off since day one that got by with that "solving" shit. Not to downplay what they did, but it had little to do with the problem as it's been understood to mean.

And to be clear I do think it was nobel worthy.

Re:Google shuts down Nobel Prize winning AlphaFold by HarHarVeryFunny on Wednesday July 29, 2026 @03:43PM (#49102068)
Yes, they have a probabilistic model, not an analytical solution.

OTOH I don't think they made up the "solved" label - the CASP benchmark had always considered reaching the AlphaFold level of predictive accuracy (within error tolerance of our ability to experimentally verify via X-ray crystallography etc) as "solving" the problem.

Re:Google shuts down Nobel Prize winning AlphaFold by chermi on Thursday July 30, 2026 @02:53PM (#49114112)
CASP is explicitly structure prediction. That's not the folding problem.
Re:Google shuts down Nobel Prize winning AlphaFold by HarHarVeryFunny on Friday July 31, 2026 @08:58AM (#49122554)
Yes, but in the AlphaFold documentary they did explicitly mention "solving" CASP as the target.
Re:Google shuts down Nobel Prize winning AlphaFold by moralestapia on Wednesday July 29, 2026 @01:51PM (#49100725)
I do not think it was Nobel worthy for Hassam et. al.

David Baker is the GOAT of that field, it should have been awarded to him only.

Re:Google shuts down Nobel Prize winning AlphaFold by chermi on Wednesday July 29, 2026 @03:01PM (#49101585)
I know baker's work quite well, no it shouldn't have
Re:Google shuts down Nobel Prize winning AlphaFold by moralestapia on Wednesday July 29, 2026 @05:10PM (#49103129)
Can you name others that deserved it more?
Re:Google shuts down Nobel Prize winning AlphaFold by chermi on Thursday July 30, 2026 @03:01PM (#49114211)
For what? I thought your trying to argue only baker deserved solo compared to what happened?

If you're asking about solving the actual folding problem? Probably Dill, Onuchic, Wolynes, maybe Sosnick would be top of my list off the top of my head. Anfinsen if he was alive.

Re:Google shuts down Nobel Prize winning AlphaFold by Legend2440 on Wednesday July 29, 2026 @01:36PM (#49100540)
The kind of solution you want may not be possible.

There is no guarantee that a tractable method exists to analytically invert protein folding. Data-driven methods like alphafold may be the only option.

Re:Google shuts down Nobel Prize winning AlphaFold by colingauvin on Wednesday July 29, 2026 @02:25PM (#49101158)
This has nothing to do with what I am talking about.
Re:Google shuts down Nobel Prize winning AlphaFold by nifets on Thursday July 30, 2026 @07:23AM (#49108487)
then maybe it's worth clarifying what it is you're talking about instead of making vague statements
Re:Google shuts down Nobel Prize winning AlphaFold by bobsmooth on Wednesday July 29, 2026 @01:40PM (#49100581)
That has nothing to do with the fact that the article is inaccurate.
Re:Google shuts down Nobel Prize winning AlphaFold by Legend2440 on Wednesday July 29, 2026 @01:44PM (#49100624)
Tell that to the nobel prize committee.

The article is fine. AlphaFold is widely regarded as "solving" protein folding.

Re:Google shuts down Nobel Prize winning AlphaFold by goatlover on Wednesday July 29, 2026 @02:52PM (#49101491)
Gemini says it did not solve the physics of how a protein actually folds.
Re:Google shuts down Nobel Prize winning AlphaFold by geremiiah on Wednesday July 29, 2026 @01:08PM (#49100177)
Yes and correct me if I'm wrong, but they never did deeper work on dynamics. I think that's very telling.
Re:Google shuts down Nobel Prize winning AlphaFold by the_real_cher on Wednesday July 29, 2026 @02:58PM (#49101541)
It's an NP hard problem.

To SOLVE it would easily win the Nobel, possibly the Turing and more.

Designer proteins would change the world and medicine also in unimaginable ways.

Re:Google shuts down Nobel Prize winning AlphaFold by lukeplato on Wednesday July 29, 2026 @02:00PM (#49100844)
they're probably referring to CASP13/14