News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Regret Migrating to Codeberg by nozzlegear on Thursday July 23, 2026 @12:57PM (#49024748)
Extremely tangential, but:

> As highlighted by [...], status quo for now due to being sent for voting, minor edits can be made by the board/presidium if the text generally passes.

It's fascinating to me how relatively unknown projects like these have very fancy governance terms like board and presidium for what amounts to a handful of people in a private Discord DM discussing a text document. It's kinda like bureaucracy larping.

Re:I Regret Migrating to Codeberg by throwaway89201 on Thursday July 23, 2026 @02:22PM (#49025956)
Nobody is LARPing an Eingetragener Verein, they're just being one, and the law requires them to have a board and presidium.

As they got hundreds of votes on the issue, that means tens of thousands of euros in membership contributions. It doesn't seem unreasonable to want to create a legal entity for that, and an e.V. is easier to set up in the beginning (although it can lead to a lot of drama later).

Re:I Regret Migrating to Codeberg by nozzlegear on Thursday July 23, 2026 @03:24PM (#49026795)
I believe you, but it still gives the outside impression of nerds taking themselves quite seriously. Leave it to the Germans to be tediously bureaucratic, I suppose?
Re:I Regret Migrating to Codeberg by pseudalopex on Thursday July 23, 2026 @05:04PM (#49028033)
You are American? American non profit associations must have officers and a board of directors.
Re:I Regret Migrating to Codeberg by nozzlegear on Thursday July 23, 2026 @07:28PM (#49029472)
I am, and I'm sure there are rules for non-profits in the US that are just as tedious! Like I said in a different comment, I didn't realize Codeberg had a whole German non-profit thing behind it.
Re:I Regret Migrating to Codeberg by Valodim on Friday July 24, 2026 @03:40AM (#49032362)
This tends to be necessary as soon as you move any non trivial amount of money around. You can't get a bank account without some bureaucratic overhead
Re:I Regret Migrating to Codeberg by kps on Thursday July 23, 2026 @05:07PM (#49028058)
I have German background, so that was a genuine concern for me when I started using Codeberg 3 years ago. It's not a great surprise that they end up being more interested in rulemaking around FOSS hosting than in FOSS hosting itself.
Re:I Regret Migrating to Codeberg by zem on Friday July 24, 2026 @05:19AM (#49033058)
https://www.jofreeman.com/joreen/tyranny.htm is a good look at why taking themselves seriously enough to have a formal governance structure is a good thing for a healthy organisation of any sort.
Re:I Regret Migrating to Codeberg by anaisbetts on Friday July 24, 2026 @06:02AM (#49033308)
Germany requires e.Vs to have democratic governance as a response / reaction to what happened during WW2, where every organization was retooled to run under "Führerprinzip" aka, one person decides everything, zero democracy or accountability. Reconstruction decided this was really fucking bad, and made all organizations required to be the polar opposite
Re:I Regret Migrating to Codeberg by Aachen on Thursday July 23, 2026 @01:22PM (#49025138)
Sort of yeah! I got used to it by now. At the local hackerspace we have a voorzitter, penningmeester, and secretaris -> president, treasurer, and secretary I think would be the English terms. All sounding fancy and together they're the board. But they don't dress up or anything, it's just terms that are commonplace for small organisations here, in Germany (like with Codeberg) as in the Netherlands (like our hackerspace). In practice people just do as they see fit, the titles are often just a formality and not taken seriously unless you can use it to teasingly redirect work onto another person :)
Re:I Regret Migrating to Codeberg by mcv on Thursday July 23, 2026 @02:51PM (#49026361)
That's normal for any "vereniging", "Verein", union or association. My VVE (HOA) has that too. So did both of the student unions I've been a member of. There are organisations for playing games that have the same structure. As soon as you've got any kind of money or responsibility involved, you need some governance structure, or you're just giving your money to some guy.
Re:I Regret Migrating to Codeberg by tosti on Thursday July 23, 2026 @03:25PM (#49026802)
And the complexity of the governance structure is related to the amount of money involved.

The weirdest thing is when the money of a non-profit NGO exceeds roughly 10e6, the decisions made by upper management tend to make an inversionally proportionate amount of sense. Reason being, it's not their money to spend.

Took me a while to figure this out but now it's everywhere.

Re:I Regret Migrating to Codeberg by CodesInChaos on Thursday July 23, 2026 @01:55PM (#49025582)
I think German non profit organizations are required by law to have a certain level of governance structure.
Re:I Regret Migrating to Codeberg by nozzlegear on Thursday July 23, 2026 @02:24PM (#49025994)
Ah, interesting! I didn't realize they were German, and didn't realize it's a non-profit as well. I thought it was just an open source project and that was that. That would explain the bureaucracy.
Re:I Regret Migrating to Codeberg by inigyou on Friday July 24, 2026 @12:07PM (#49037667)
The open source project is Forgejo. You can host is yourself with any policies you want.
Re:I Regret Migrating to Codeberg by nozzlegear on Friday July 24, 2026 @10:55AM (#49036621)
Guess the Germans woke up and had a board meeting about this comment lmao