The reason they are kept offshore is because if the funds were naturalized back in the USA they would be double-taxed. It is difficult to argue that Google should pay local taxes once where a product is sold and then pay taxes again on that same money when it is transferred back to the USA.
Many large corporations that hold large cash balances keep them offshore. Around 75% of Apple's large cash holdings are held offshore. They have already paid tax on that money. It is the US naturalization laws that are broken, and the perception that Google, Apple et al aren't paying taxes or somehow avoiding them.
The best thing the US Government could do would be to institute another repatriation tax holiday. There is precedent for it as happen in 2004. As much as a trillion dollars could make its way back into the US economy if a deal could be worked out - a private mini-stimulus that the economy of 2 years ago really needed.
Saying they've paid anything in the "local tax jurisdiction[s]" isn't quite true. In most cases they've passed through Ireland and the Netherlands, even if the income is from other European countries. In most cases they haven't paid any corporation tax at all on the profits made in the local countries.
Take Starbucks in the UK as an example. They had sales of £400m but paid £0 corporation tax by ensuring the company didn't make a profit in the UK. It paid various license fees to foreign sister companies, and even purchased its coffee from Starbucks Switzerland to help offset profits. £0 profit in the UK, £0 corporation tax due.
> The reason they are kept offshore is because if the funds were naturalized back in the USA they would be double-taxed. It is really hard to argue that Google should pay local taxes once where a product is sold and then pay taxes again on that same money when it is transferred back to the USA.
They wouldn't be double taxed, the USA have double tax treaties with many countries. The reason they keep it off shore is because they're waiting for one of those amnesties that would allow them to bring the cash home to the US and pay far less than they would have outside the amnesty.
Example with no amnesty:-
Google pay 12.5% corporation tax in Ireland on European Revenues by using "license fee", loan or other perfectly legal schemes.
Google move money from Ireland to Bermuda tax free.
Google move money back into the US and pay (to the US) the difference between tax due originally and tax already paid (in Ireland).
Net result is Google pay the standard 35% (or whatever it is in the US) tax on the money. It's just a chunk of it goes to Ireland rather than the US.
Example with amnesty:-
Google pay 12.5% corporation tax in Ireland on European Revenues.
Google move money from Ireland to Bermuda.
US announce amnesty rate of 5.625% and Google moves money back to the US paying a total of 18.125%. That's a whole lot less than 35%.
It's exactly those amnesties that mean large US corporations can do this. Without them there would be little reason to hoard money offshore as it could never get back to the US without the full amount of tax having to have been paid on it.
The trouble is that there is no advantage to bringing the money back. If you have your money in Bermuda, you can still invest it. You can buy securities, or you can loan it back to your sister companies in higher tax jurisdictions, and then the interest they pay you on it is generally tax deductible in the higher tax jurisdiction. The loan gives you all the benefits of having the money with none of the taxes. In that way they do bring the money back -- they just don't pay the taxes.
Even if they brought it back through the tax amnesty, what happens then? They've now got an extra billion dollars they didn't pay taxes on, so now they go out and invest it and the returns are taxable in the higher tax jurisdiction. Who thinks they're that stupid, when the alternative is to invest the money in the exact same investments but have the profits go to the sister company in the lower tax jurisdiction?
With the 2004 amnesty - you are right - but there are a few things you can't do with offshore funds - which is why this time Cisco, Apple and the big pharma co's are lobbying for an amnesty
You can't do acquisitions, you can't do a share buyback and you can't pay a dividend.
If you are managing smaller reserves it makes sense to leave it offshore - but with larger reserves such as with Apple investors want you to do more with it (they want to _get paid_)
If they hold stock in a company whose share price has appreciated as a result of accumulating undistributed profits and they want money, they can always sell some of their shares.
And are you sure they can't do acquisitions? What stops them borrowing the acquisition money from their sister company, or doing the merger for stock?
1. Companies are not necessarily double-taxed on foreign profits when they enter the US - they can actually claim a foreign tax credit to offset their US taxes. See here: http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-soi/06itcorptaxsnap.pdf. There are issues with this - you cannot have a tax credit that results in a refund - but it is not a given that all profits are double-taxed.
2. Google (along with a lot of other companies) utilizes the so-called "Double Irish" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement) - and this, specifically, is a tax avoidance strategy. Thus, it is a misrepresentation to say that they are not avoiding taxes. Granted, they have passed through one local tax jurisdiction (Ireland) on their way to Bermuda, but that means that a lot of other countries, in addition to the US, do not get access to the taxes from companies that are operating in their countries.
3. US companies are already holding enormous amounts of cash on their books - but that hasn't lead to large-scale increased capital spend.
4. On 2004: the argument then (as now) was that these funds would result in jobs and new capital being spent. But that didn't happen. Instead most of the money was just paid out in dividends which really only affects, a big scale, people in the 1-2% incomes who get a lot or most of their income from dividends.
Comments welcome!
I'm sure you'd like the money to be "repatriated" to the US, but I'd like just some of it to stick around in the UK and Europe to pay for roads, schools, hospitals (and nuclear submarines) first.
Nothing particularly unusual or illegal about this.
So they have been "avoiding" tax - but there is nothing illegal about that, or from my perspective, particularly immoral about it.
£6M in corporate income tax, which is only one of many taxes (and usually the smallest component) that a corporation pays.
For eg. they would have collected a 20% VAT (consumption tax in the rest of the world) - which is another £80M, a 13.8% national insurance contribution, which would work out to be approx another £40M, and then on top of that a payroll tax.
I am not familiar with the other payroll tax rates in the UK but it is similar in most other countries - the three or four different tiers. In the USA payroll taxes are 5-6x larger than corporate income taxes. Add them up for Google in the UK and you get to £130-140M contributed from a gross of £395M - a very different story to the headline figures that are being argued.
edit: forget the figures, I don't know the UK tax system enough to even guesstimate, but the tl;dr is that corporate income tax is the smallest of a number of tax components that a corporation pays and arguing by taking out corporate income tax figures alone is misleading. This is the point that Google attempted to make.
Consumer VAT and consumer income tax are not tax paid by a company, and it's disingenuous to suggest that 'a corporation pays'. They merely collect them from the customer/employee for the government, it's not as if the corporation contributes anything on top of that. They do contribute to NI as you mention, and local business rates on property in the UK at least, but the vast majority of revenues can escape taxation, and I don't think customer VAT, and employee IT can be considered paid by the employer, they are paid by the customer or employee.
There are of course many benefits to having a company setting up in your country (the aforementioned VAT and income tax receipts from the employees, rates, and jobs generated), but companies offshoring profits and shopping for tax jurisdictions by setting up fake subsidiaries whose sole purpose is to evade tax is a huge problem for all western countries, and not one they can address with current tax law. That's the reason that many receipts in Europe nowadays bear the legend 'S.a.r.l, Luxembourg'. All major corporations from Apple, to Amazon, to Google do this to some extent, and it results in tiny countries like Luxemburg collecting huge amounts of tax (in proportion to their size, and the true number of business who truly transact business there (as opposed to claiming they do)), simply because they're willing to give corporations the lowest international rate,and let them set up shell companies to funnel online revenue through the tax haven.
I'd also argue that it is employees who pay income tax - not the employer (even with PAYE meaning that employees don't see that money).
Considering that over 50% of Google's revenues are non-US, I personally find appalling how they avoid paying little-to-no taxes in other countries. Here are the self-proclaimed "don't do evil" and "down with Wall St." institutions acting as "vampire squids".
On the point of why would tech companies want to do this instead of helping the community, I argue it may actually help California. Instead of doing the responsible thing and moving the firm to somewhere with a lower state corporate tax rate, the firm can simply avoid taxes. This keeps employees in the area contributing to state income and property taxes. In a world or multinationals, I am not certain corporate income taxes make sense.
These tax systems also apply to the smallest of startups operating online. Its just that Google can afford the best advice and are the biggest target.
My concern is that further changes to tax laws that are aimed at Google and Apple could end up affecting smaller companies and startups as collateral damage.
Google and Apple will wriggle their way out of any changes to transfer pricing laws, as they usually always do, while small startups and businesses might not.
Do you take any deductions (i.e. the standard deduction, or itemizing)? By the reasoning of your post, that would make you "something close to evil."
I could set up my salary through some finance companies in europe that help you keep up to 85% of your salary, but I don't.
I see the danger in the system you mention that lots of money will go to niche organisations out of proportion with societies requirements. Better to pay taxes in the hope that they are distributed where they are most needed.
Speaking for myself, I enter deductions into the H&R Block program and watch the estimated payment. When the payment is something I think is reasonable, I stop entering deductions. So yes, I do send more than I have to.
(and often less, if they think they can get away with it)
Of course, it is not so easy to avoid tax as a salaried individual, which is why your comparison is failing. Somebody on PAYE (i.e. most people) can't create a clone of themselves in Ireland to pay their income tax there instead of the UK. If that option was available to individuals then I'm sure plenty would take it (assuming Irish income tax is lower, I have no idea). That is what the debate is about though: some entities have great flexibility and can avoid tax if they want, others (individuals of average means or less) don't have the choice to pay less.
On a side note, one point I've been stuck on is what to call the commentors above me. I know there's established language for it (parent, grandparent) but I have trouble using it right. Anyone know what I should have called the poster of the hypothetical, and the response that I responded to?
Assuming that this is entirely legal, I don't see how this is a problem in Google's behaviour. If there is a problem, it is in the tax code, and the Government has sole responsibility for that.
Making tax codes simpler would make it easier to not leave loopholes, but politics always seems to drive it in the other direction. Perhaps the need to avoid this kind of situation can be a good force in keeping tax codes simpler.
I am defining a loophole as anything that the media are getting into a frenzy about that is perfectly legal. If one prefers that they weren't using some technique to minimise tax, then it [that technique] is a loophole. If this means that they've failed to "define a framework for computing net income as opposed to gross income" that works, then that's a loophole.
> In the corporate tax case, complexity also comes from trying to avoid taxing companies for profits that have nothing to do with American operations.
I don't see what has got to do with it. Clearly no jurisdiction can justifiably claim that it deserves tax revenue unless a company has operations there. If it has operations there, it falls under that jurisdiction's tax code. If the company can avoid paying some tax in any particular jurisdiction that one would like it to be paying, then the tax code of that jurisdiction is broken.
It's just more fun to yell about tax loopholes that corporations utilize, because big faceless corporations sound more evil than tax breaks that John and Jane benefit from.
But once you've established the deduction and people have already bought homes expecting it, they require its continued existence to be able to keep making the payments.
What they really ought to do is remove the deduction for new mortgages but not existing mortgages (or refinances of existing mortgages that don't increase the loan principal).
The result of this is that better off people underestimate how much direct government assistance they have received [1]. I won't comment on the potential political motivations for dividing up the welfare state in this way
[1] http://themonkeycage.org/blog/2011/02/08/the_invisible_ameri...
Also, even if it is not much of a win for the wealthy households, higher property prices generally mean higher rents so it disadvantages the class of people that rent. A similar argument applies to housing benefit in the uk, which is something you receive if you are poor (working or not). The recipient doesn't really see the money, but it helps to keep rents high so it's more of a 'landlords benefit', much like your mortgage deduction seems to be of more benefit to the banks than home owners.
The first problem you could address by capping the benefit somehow. The latter you cannot.
Or, if the government decides to tax everyone at 100%, but then gives out a series of "tax breaks" that lands everyone at their current tax level, is whatever government people get to keep welfare?
I don't want to go to far in the other direction. It's 100% possible for politicians to spend money via tax breaks. So neither worldview really works, but you have to have something between them.
Ultimately, I want corporations to be as profitable as possible, because that is good for our economy. Profitable companies buy and sell goods, hire individuals, the usual talking points. If we want to give more money to public education, increase income/capital gains tax (e.g. individuals)...not corporate tax.
Besides, you can make the case that only a small portion of the taxes Google pays actually improves the roads or public education. A large percentage will go towards things like defense research, healthcare, bridges in Alaska, any number of things that have no bearing on Google at all.
(I'm not a Google apologist, this would apply to any company.)
What if they spirit all of that money out of the country to somewhere else? Surely it benefits the host country more to tax profits rather than just let them escape entirely?
I'll freely admit my knowledge of corporate finance falls apart somewhere around here.
Collecting a portion of their profit just because it's another place to add a tax doesn't seem to make sense. Imagine Google compared to a trucking company. Google makes 100x the profit of this particular trucking company. Does Google add 100x the wear and tear on roads that the trucking company does? Why should they be liable for a larger portion of maintenance on said roads simply because they have a larger profit?
But here is the rub, what if the Government spends the money you gave them on an all expense paid trip for themselves to Las Vegas where they ran up big bills at strip clubs and on luxury suites? How do you feel about that?
How about the Greek people, their economy in flames, their country ruined, where "not paying taxes is a national pastime" according to The Economist.
The insight you are missing is that when "your" opinion of the government's fiscal policy is destroyed by abuse, "you" feel completely justified in exploiting all the legal ways to not give them any more money than you have to.
It is hard for an individual to fix government it is easy for an individual to minimize their tax burden. So people take the easy way out.
This is not really true. There are many ways to make money without expending much effort. Example: capital gains. By simply having a lot of money, I can invest this and make a solid profit...and be taxed in a lower bracket.
It has no bearing on effort expended. In fact, you can easily argue that "More Effort = More Money" has a very definite ceiling which you can't cross. At some point, you have to start leveraging other assets (money, employees, etc).
Taxing based on the amount of income earned is really the only sensible way to tax. You can't tax "effort"
But wonder if you are arguing that earning money through non-manual labor is 'effortless' ?
This could use some clarification:
" By simply having a lot of money, I can invest this and make a solid profit...and be taxed in a lower bracket."
Is there some magic money pool somewhere that I can put a million dollars into and count on it to make a "solid profit" ? What is a 'solid profit' ? Is it inflation + 4%? 5%? 10%?
People have told me that programming takes no effort, they say "Oh yeah, you just go in there and type in some stuff and make a word processor or something and then sell that again and again for $100, its like printing your own money!" I realize that they don't understand what programming involves in terms of making a living at it.
For the last 15 years or so I've had the opportunity to manage the funds that I rolled over from a 401K as a 'self managed IRA'. I haven't found making that money 'grow' either easy or effortless. Rather it has been very much a challenge.
During the dot-com frenzy I knew people who mortgaged their houses to raise capital that they were going to 'make money hand over fist' with. But I don't know any of them where that turned out to be the best use of that capital. Not definitive I know but it made me cautious.
That's one of the reasons wages and investment are treated differently: your effort can be wasted in either case, but with investment you can also lose your capital.
In regards to investing, nearly everyone is best off just investing in an index fund of the entire market.
In regards to government expenditures, I'd say generally, it makes sense morally to reduce your tax as low as possible, and than donate that amount to charity, research, or whatnot, not just because government wastes money, but because they use money to engage in horrific activities such as the Iraq War.
A dollar spent on Google's self-driving cars program will improve transport in California more than a dollar spent on resurfacing highways; a dollar spent on removing SEO spam from search results will improve education in California more than a dollar spent on paper textbooks full of lies sold by corrupt monopolies; and a dollar spent on developing Android will improve smartphones more than a dollar spent adjudicating pointless patent cases filed by patent pirates like Apple and Intellectual Ventures to eliminate competition.
And then there's the benefit to the rest of the world outside California.
And then there's the fact that a third of your tax money goes to the military, whose mission is to make the world a shittier place for everyone outside the US.
I'm not a huge fan of Google (see http://lists.canonical.org/pipermail/kragen-tol/2011-August/...) but in a competition with the US and California governments for cost-effective ways to use dollars to improve the world, Google wins hands down.
This is the wrong perspective. They're working toward maximizing their profits, not minimizing their benefit to the state.
$1 billion of taxes into the state does not even come close to producing $1 billion of benefit to themselves. Considering how much money gets distributed to parts of the state hundreds of miles away and how inefficiently (and sometimes wasted) the government handles money, it's probably fractions of a penny on the dollar that they actually get back in some benefit.
Is it worth it to you to avoid taxes? Yep. Even if it means that your local school where your children actually go to gets a bit less money, you save a couple thousand dollars and the school misses out on a hundred bucks. The impact on you personally is beyond negligible.
Say California closes tax loopholes. Then all California companies are placed on an equal footing. But they're now at a disadvantage to non-California companies that don't pay taxes.
Usually higher/simpler taxes will be the better solution. The higher the level they're applied at, the better, as far as the companies are concerned.
Recall that Amazon has been pushing for Federal rules on state sales taxes. Absent those, it's been simpler for amazon to fight paying taxes rather than set up a compliance system and pay taxes on a state by state basis.
A city of 36,664 with a 16% unemployment and a per capita income of $24,800 paid its council men twice of what is the salary of the POTUS[1].
I am personally opposed to capital punishment but I would not mind the strictest possible sentence to these people other than a death sentence. Perhaps suspend their drivers' license and passport and make them pay some enormous amount of money (in addition to the money they took from the government) which they cannot wipe away with a bankruptcy.
It seems to me that Google, especially being in California, is being...well, something close to evil by making sure they help out their local governments and people as little as legally possible.
I understand that their profits are higher each quarter because of this. I understand that's what shareholders demand. But why?! Can this attitude lead to anything except terrible news? I just don't get it.