News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Revenues Sheltered in No-Tax Bermuda Soar to $10 B... by AnthonyMouse on Monday December 10, 2012 @11:19AM (#4899713)
I agree that tax amnesties are stupid, but you've got the logic wrong. When they've had them in the past, proponents were shocked at how few corporations took them up on it.

The trouble is that there is no advantage to bringing the money back. If you have your money in Bermuda, you can still invest it. You can buy securities, or you can loan it back to your sister companies in higher tax jurisdictions, and then the interest they pay you on it is generally tax deductible in the higher tax jurisdiction. The loan gives you all the benefits of having the money with none of the taxes. In that way they do bring the money back -- they just don't pay the taxes.

Even if they brought it back through the tax amnesty, what happens then? They've now got an extra billion dollars they didn't pay taxes on, so now they go out and invest it and the returns are taxable in the higher tax jurisdiction. Who thinks they're that stupid, when the alternative is to invest the money in the exact same investments but have the profits go to the sister company in the lower tax jurisdiction?

Re:Google Revenues Sheltered in No-Tax Bermuda Soar to $10 B... by nikcub on Monday December 10, 2012 @11:32AM (#4899801)
I remember reading that the US Congressional sub-committee report into a possible amnesty found that approx 50% of the money was back in the USA via securities and loans anyway.

With the 2004 amnesty - you are right - but there are a few things you can't do with offshore funds - which is why this time Cisco, Apple and the big pharma co's are lobbying for an amnesty

You can't do acquisitions, you can't do a share buyback and you can't pay a dividend.

If you are managing smaller reserves it makes sense to leave it offshore - but with larger reserves such as with Apple investors want you to do more with it (they want to _get paid_)

Re:Google Revenues Sheltered in No-Tax Bermuda Soar to $10 B... by AnthonyMouse on Monday December 10, 2012 @03:40PM (#4901376)
>If you are managing smaller reserves it makes sense to leave it offshore - but with larger reserves such as with Apple investors want you to do more with it (they want to _get paid_)

If they hold stock in a company whose share price has appreciated as a result of accumulating undistributed profits and they want money, they can always sell some of their shares.

And are you sure they can't do acquisitions? What stops them borrowing the acquisition money from their sister company, or doing the merger for stock?