And that is one of the main reasons I prefer G+ over Facebook. Facebook is nice to keep in touch with ones family and friends (old and new), but G+ is where I can follow (and occasionally interact with) a number of luminaries, visionaries and tech leaders. God forbid my family and friends fill up my G+ stream!
If G+ never catches up with Facebook in terms of numbers, I'll be the happier for it.
You can see more and more G+ integration into Youtube, why not just turn Youtube into G+ altogether?
I access Gmail exclusively through my Windows Phone. I don't use G+ at all. The community of interest thing doesn't hold much water for me, because I've yet to be pointed at something of interest on G+ that I wouldn't find elsewhere.
Not saying that my particular scenario reflects everyone else's, but it does seem to work for me and my friends, most of whom have GMail accounts as their primary mail address.
If success is defined in terms of ad impressions then that won't work with me either. I use an ad blocker.
But again, I check it every day, which is the same thing I do with Facebook. If you want my eyeballs for an ad, either platform provides the same value. I'm probably not typical, but I'm not completely weird either.
I think you can only look at G+ as a success at this point. Just not a success on the scale of Google Search or Facebook.