News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by jrockway on Thursday December 06, 2012 @09:11PM (#4885132)
I used to run my own one-user email system. The hosting alone cost $240 a year. And I had to spend a lot of time configuring exim4 (and spamassassin and clam-av), figuring out which email indexer to use, setting up offlineimap, running cron jobs to archive mailing lists, coercing a friend to run a secondary MX for me, etc., etc. I didn't enjoy it all. And no matter what I did to reduce spam, about 10 messages a day always made it through.

(And, when I was first doing this, someone trying to hire me for a job couldn't email me, because their hosting provider was once friendly to spammers and my aggressive blacklisting rejected their TCP connections. Oops.)

Running an email server is hard and very few people regret paying an expert to do it for them.

(As many HN readers know, I work for Google. But I'm not telling you that you should or should not use Google's product here, only that running an email server is not trivial.)

Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by wbillingsley on Thursday December 06, 2012 @09:44PM (#4885224)
All you need is a forwarding service to forward the incoming mail to your gmail account, as regular personal gmail can handle sending out email with a different from address.

No exim4, no spamassassin, no clam-av, no figuring out which indexer to use, or any of that. Just a forward on the incoming mail.

Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by gfosco on Thursday December 06, 2012 @10:31PM (#4885341)
I think most people would consider that cheating... You're hardly running your own email server, and still using Google.

I actually miss running my own email domain, the privacy of it, not the actual administration. I stopped when I had gotten so crazy with aliases and disposable addresses that the spam overwhelmed me. Wasn't worth the time to 'do it right,' and I gave up my privacy for the simplicity of GMail.

I would love to leave GMail and take my privacy back, but I haven't found an acceptable alternative yet.

Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by andrewcooke on Friday December 07, 2012 @12:37AM (#4885647)
"cheating"? people are claiming that you now need to configure your own smtp server with delivery, spam filtering etc. that's simply not true. most web hosting comes with an smtp server; you likely need web hosting anyway and pointing the smtp server at google is trivial.

i fail to see how making good use of available resources is "cheating". the idea isn't to win some geek hair-shirt contest; it is to get email delivered to your domain.

Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by white_devil on Saturday December 08, 2012 @05:21AM (#4891307)
If you get a domain at Gandi.net, it comes with a free e-mail service for 5 accounts. You could see if that suits your needs.
Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by sciurus on Saturday December 08, 2012 @02:57PM (#4892532)
Seconding this; Gandi works well for me as a registrar, DNS provider, and email provider.

There are many email providers you can use with your own domain. For example, rackspace is $2 a user a month. https://www.rackspace.com/apps/email_hosting/rackspace_email... I'm not sure why people are jumping from "Google won't do this for free for me anymore" to "I must do it myself".

Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by sliverstorm on Friday December 07, 2012 @03:47AM (#4886104)
You can take the middle ground; make your own complete mailserver, and have a forwarding GMail or similar account to act as a proxy receiver for forum registration and that sort of thing- services that are much more likely to get your address into the hands of spammers.
Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by sigkill on Friday December 07, 2012 @02:30AM (#4885926)
Expanding on your post.

It's pretty easy actually but when authorizing GMail to add a new sender address it usually mails a verification code to that address. Which, in this case would come back into the same Gmail inbox.

So if you have a [email protected] forwarding to [email protected], then the verification code would be sent by gmail to [email protected], which in turn, due to your forward settings, would redirect all mail to [email protected].

The difference is that when sending mail from your Gmail.com inbox as opposed to the Google apps inbox for [email protected] is that when you send a mail via gmail (even if you fake the sender), the signed-by field will contain "gmail.com". On the other hand, Google apps for domains will set the signed-by field value to "Y.Z" (which would be your domain name).

As far as I know, this is the only difference. In Gmail, you can even set the default sender-address as your custom domain address so you don't need to set it everytime you reply to/compose new emails. And, unless you think/feel that signed-by: domain.name is cool, you're not really missing anything.

Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by chmars on Friday December 07, 2012 @04:44AM (#4886251)
Using a mail address different from your default Gmail (or Google Apps for Business Mail) address unfortunately does not work for some recipients. It seems that at least some versions of Microsoft Exchange/Outlook always show your default address and not the different mail address you actually used.
Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by RobAley on Friday December 07, 2012 @05:55AM (#4886403)
For anyone considering it, some MS clients (and a few others) show something like :

[email protected] on behalf of Rob Aley [[email protected]]

It maybe looks a little unprofessional, but as long as your gmail account isn't something like [email protected] or [email protected], its not too bad.

Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by chmars on Saturday December 08, 2012 @10:28AM (#4891775)
It is not too bad IMHO if you only use a slightly different domain for the same purpose but with completely different domains, it looks odd. And there is always the problem that some mail clients use your default Gmail address to reply and not the one you actually used.
Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by timdev2 on Friday December 07, 2012 @04:00AM (#4886135)
"regular personal gmail can handle sending out email with a different from address"

for now

Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by icebraining on Friday December 07, 2012 @02:34AM (#4885935)
I used to run my own one-user email system. The hosting alone cost $240 a year.

Why? I have two VPSs with the main and backup SMTP servers and with continuous replications of emails between them and I pay less than half. Not to mention they double as web servers, IRC bouncers, etc.

And no matter what I did to reduce spam, about 10 messages a day always made it through.

I probably never get the same traffic as you do, but to me the best decision I made was enabling catch-all and using different addresses for each service out there.

In my case, spammers only send to three types of addresses:

- Random (jumble of numbers and letters@mydomain): very easy to block with a couple of programming lines.

- Fake but plausible (support@, bob@): just blacklist them once.

- Leaked (from websites and such): same as above, nuke it. Only happened to me once.

All in all, I never had to set up SpamAssassin or deal with dropped emails because of untrusted sources. Blocking by destination is much cleaner.

Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by vacri on Friday December 07, 2012 @12:26AM (#4885618)
Not to mention that you have to pay to be 'recognised' so that your emails aren't autobounced by some enterprises. I have a friend that runs his own domain email for himself and friends and it's surprising to hear just how complex it can be just to get mail accepted. I can't recall if it was a whitelist or a certificate or what, but I do remember at one stage he was happy because he found a way around having to pay a five-figure sum to some internet authority to stop some hosts bouncing his domain (the workaround only cost a couple of hundred instead).
Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by jrockway on Friday December 07, 2012 @01:38AM (#4885826)
I've never had any problems with mail delivery and I've never paid anyone a dime. I even violated one of rfc-ignorant's rules (a fake tertiary MX record) and still didn't get blacklisted :)

There are no internet authorities that control mail delivery, either, BTW. Many sites use heuristics to control mail acceptance, however, including third-party whitelists and blacklists. It can suck if you get on a blacklist, but experienced mail administrators only use whitelists and blacklists as one of many metrics regarding mail spamminess. Indicators of good mail like "most of the words in this message are non-spam words" often provide an order of magnitude more ham points than blacklists contribute spam points, so important messages will probably not be dropped even if you're on a blacklist. Of course, many sites have less clever schemes because there is a lot of spam and not a lot of sysadmin time to waste tweaking spam filtering rules.

Mail is hard.

Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by vacri on Friday December 07, 2012 @02:56AM (#4885985)
Hrm. Perhaps it was a certificate issue with SSL which the guy uses on his mailserver? I'm really not up to speed with configuring much beyond msmtp.

In any case, from a decade of listening to the random things he's had to deal with, I certainly have to agree with your final comment.

Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by jrockway on Friday December 07, 2012 @02:28PM (#4888761)
SSL'd SMTP is a non-standard extension that nobody uses. (In fact, the port assignment for it was revoked in 1999!) TLS on port 25 is how you do secure email (mostly so you can advertise AUTH PLAIN safely.)

I think there are probably some MTAs that will STARTTLS for normal SMTP connections, but again, I've never heard of anyone using SSL/TLS as a spam-filtering criterion. (I might look through my old logs to see if anyone other than me ever issued STARTTLS on my mail server. But I'm guessing the number was near zero.)

Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by Wicher on Saturday December 08, 2012 @06:45AM (#4891431)
I've been running a mailserver on my domestic DSL line for almost ten years now. Apart from my private domains it also hosted some domains for organizations, with mailing lists.

Last year I moved and my IP address changed (ISP didn't). I expected to lose the "reputation" the previous one had built up. But I did not have any problems whatsoever. I do hear rumors like yours every now and again but I have a hard time believing them.

I think that large email providers, the likes of Gmail/Hotmail, actually look at the email addresses / domains / servers that their clients send email to. Then they assign trust to those tokens. If you're a large provider, you can do many things with the data you get from your own customer's behaviour. How about looking at accounts that have been in use for some time, seen regular web interface action, and send email to other @hotmail/gmail accounts that actually get read and not flagged spam? If those accounts send mail to my mailserver, then my mail server / domain must have something good going for it. Well that's what I would do if I were running a huge setup anyway...

As for incoming spam: I'm using various postfix tricks, greylisting, and dspam. I have no problems. I should write a howto ;-)

Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by ing33k on Friday December 07, 2012 @12:17AM (#4885590)
Cannot agree more, I have had similar experiences, my friends used to call me and say, "hey I still didn't get your email". Finally I decided to use a reliable email provider . my choice was Google Apps .
Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by Shorel on Friday December 07, 2012 @09:07AM (#4886903)
I'm sure it will be a lot cheaper on AWS.
Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by jrockway on Friday December 07, 2012 @02:32PM (#4888792)
The smallest instance running 24/7 is $175.20 for 365 days. Add in S3 storage for 25G of data, and that adds $28.50.

This does not include incoming bandwidth, bandwidth used by your IMAP or webmail client, or DNS lookups that you'll do for every message received. (Also, spam filtering is CPU-intensive, so if you get a lot of email, a Micro instance may not be big enough.)

This doesn't include a secondary MX, either. (I like the DynDNS secondary MX service, personally, which is ~$30 a year IIRC.)

Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by Shorel on Monday December 10, 2012 @04:47PM (#4901698)
The info I get is that the smallest instance is a micro instance at just $23 for 365 days, not on demand, but a reserved instance.
Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by jfb on Friday December 07, 2012 @04:25PM (#4889321)
Why use EC2 for this? You don't need the elasticity, and you can get cycles a lot cheaper elsewhere.
Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by Shorel on Monday December 10, 2012 @07:03PM (#4902353)
Virtualized dedicated server with SSH root for $23 a year?

Just tell me where to sign up (next year when AWS free tier expires).

Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by indiecore on Thursday December 06, 2012 @09:30PM (#4885180)
You might be right. I'm just steamed about a nice tidy free option being swept right out from under me with no warning at all.

Sleep on it I guess, see how it looks in the morning.

Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by killermonkeys on Thursday December 06, 2012 @10:35PM (#4885345)
If you already signed up, you continue to get free service. There's no warning necessary because there are no changes for existing customers.
Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by mkr-hn on Thursday December 06, 2012 @09:46PM (#4885232)
$5 a month for world-class email on your domain seems like a minor burden.
Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by blhack on Thursday December 06, 2012 @11:15PM (#4885448)
Per account.
Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by jfoster on Friday December 07, 2012 @04:13AM (#4886165)
How much do you pay your employees?
Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by lhnn on Friday December 07, 2012 @11:14PM (#4890606)
What?

I use Google Apps to host 4 email addresses for my personal domain.

Personal email Online shopping email Forums/Programming email Facebook-only email (so people can't search for me)

I use it for me. I wouldn't pay $20/month for such a service, and Google is smart for not taking free away from existing customers.

Re:Google Apps stops accepting free sign-ups by mkr-hn on Thursday December 06, 2012 @11:28PM (#4885488)
People in need of more than a few accounts would blow through the free version quickly.