Steve Jobs is a huge perfectionist. However he will make you work 70+ hours a week to achieve his perfection and he will ride you every step of the way to get the best out of you. http://www.folklore.org
The key is accepting that people prefer products to promises, and just going ahead with something that's good enough without it being perfect.
It feels like there are two forms of design: "release early and release often" and "release it perfectly". Very few people have the taste necessary to find success in the latter.
Holding something to yourself until it is "perfect" is a solo quest. You may spend too much time on the wrong things and no time on the right things. But you also won't release something that is completely broken.
Aha, now we know what to call that solo quest for perfection: premature optimization.
Just make it look a tiny bit nicer, get a few mentions on various blogs and you'll be fine. A PayPal donate link may help too?
We're just refocusing the site. I'll toss you an email with the outline of the redesign so you can approve or disapprove it.
Edit: Email away
It's currently a productivity site. You'll say "I'm going to run every day". When you've done it you check back to the site and make a post about it and attach a photo. Your post is shared with everyone else doing the same thing as you, and you can upvote posts.
So you'd better be a Steve Jobs.