If everything is antisemitism then nothing is antisemitism.
A perceived attack on circumcision is an attack on the fundamentalist religion that the Americans currently in power claim to follow.
I chose to use a throwaway because this topic in particular frequently invites accusations of ill-motivation, sort of like the one you were reaching for.
No one here is getting arrested for doing a normal at-home bris, even if it's technically illegal.
Circumcision is an absolutely fundamental rite of Judaism. Banning it would be much more serious even than banning yarmulkes or Bar Mitzvahs (or crucifixes); it would be something approximately like banning baptism or the Eucharist for Christians. There are stories of oppressors through the millennia banning circumcision, and Jewish people resisting.
Every Jewish male is circumcised, as far as I know. I've never heard of someone complaining about it. The idea that it has something to do with Zionism is absurd; it looks like a broad-based attack using every Jewish-related word.
Prejudice rarely volunteers itself by saying 'I hate ____'; it doesn't say, 'I hate Jews so lets persecute them'. It aims for cruelty - another consequence of hate - and finds pernicious reasons. And for those reasons it persecutes: Jewish people, immigrants, Black people, Muslim people, etc. - such as banning religious practices. Because of the reasons, reasonable bystanders might let it pass or even participate, unaware of the context or that they are being used by liars. That's the aim of any disinformation - like the comment above - to make enough people passive (or paralyzed).
At some point we need to accept that in a relfrespecting society health and free will must prevail over any practice that infringes on them.
That said, I also agree that there's a political angle too - some people (atheist activists, right-wingers, religious fundamentalists etc.) only use this for identity politics against Judaism and / or Islam.
> not a medically licensed
> hire a doctor and do it in sanitary conditions.
Most procedures are done at home by unlicensed people (e.g., family, home healthcare aids). The people who perform circumcisions are trained, experienced, and, afaik, licensed.
There's no crisis of bad health outcomes. It's a non-issue created by anti-semites to attack Judaism, and persuade some others to join in (see the GP).
The reason we accept these crisis is due to societal, cultural and religious tradition/pressure. IMO, in an ideal world, many of these things should draw additional scrutiny.
Why should your - or anyone's - assessment of weirdness affect other people's freedom? I think your comment is much worse than weird, it's dangerous to freedom and helps the cause of antisemitism. By your argument, your comment certainly should be banned based only on my opinion.
> Move the age of the procedure to a consenting age and nobody will give a damn.
You don't understand what's happening; with this victory the antisemites will seek more. There's a term of art for people they, and similar manipulators, capture:
You seem like you are interested only in defending the parent's freedom to mutiliate their child's genitals, not the child;s right to not have parts of their flesh flayed off for no reason.
Do you not believe a child has a right to not have parts of their body removed for non-medical purposes without their consent?
FWIW I reject this characterization entirely and I think your position is ideologically eroded by you reaching for it.
People are allowed to criticize circumcision as a practice without being antisemitic. The entire reason I'm posting under a throwaway right now is because I expected this kind of accusation to come out.
Everything in your comment tries to redirect from the issue of antisemitism.
Offering animal sacrifices in the temple was once an absolutely fundamental rite of Judaism. And that changed. At times, halachic scholarship/philosophy/politics reaches decisions that some commandments (mitzvot) can be followed/maintained symbolically, or semi-symbolically rather than literally. It is conceivable this may happen with circumcision. I mean, the point of circumcision is to signify the covenant of Jehovah with Jews (or with Abraham); it is not the lack-of-foreskin that is the point.
> Every Jewish male is circumcised, as far as I know
You know wrong. Some - not many, but some - Israeli Jewish parents eschew circumcision.
Bodily autonomy is a fundamental right. Rights > rites.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Defamation_League#Circumc...
When Iceland tried to ban it, the ADL had some very choice words about the potential consequences.
> Greenblatt sent Iceland's Parliament a letter regarding a proposed infant circumcision ban in that country, arguing that the ban should be rejected due to circumcision's religious significance and health benefits. Greenblatt also said that if the ban passed, the ADL would report on any celebration by antisemites and other extremists, asserting that this would deter tourism and harm Iceland's economy
It's scary stuff.