I see this sentiment often, and I’m honestly not sure where this comes from, as it’s really not been my experience. I feel like this must come from people feeling threatened and just moving the goals posts, or not knowing how to use the tools effectively.
1) lies and/or cope
2) lack of actual software ability, therefore over evaluating your own skill
3) haven’t actually used LLMs, and want to do a “look at me I’m so unique and different”
I roll my eyes whenever someone says “AI bad” “AI sucks” “AI can’t replace me”
Yeah. Load of
Isn't it possible that people who think LLMs are awesome at coding are in fact bad at it themselves, leading to them over estimating the LLMs "skill"?
To me it feels like people telling on themselves that they aren't very good
Question to you, have you actually used a leading model like Fable when it was available? I did.
I can’t take anyone seriously who says they can program better or faster than a model with those capabilities. I’m sorry but you are either a liar, or coping. And I don’t know what is worse.
Architecting yes people are still better. Raw coding skill? No. Speed? No. Output? No.
So can just copying from Stack Overflow, or taking from Open Source repos
There have always been reasons why we didn't prefer to do that in the past, but I guess laundering it through LLMs is fine. And that's just the tip of the ethical ice berg
High volumes of unvetted code is a bad practice. If the code winds up working out fine then congrats you won the slot machine. It's still a bad practice and very, very stupid to become reliant on
And by the way, I had been programming for longer than you have before I even graduated high school, if that matters
Who said it’s unvetted?
Sure it matters
I've heard a million people say their LLM workflow produces amazing code. But I have never actually seen the amazing code allegedly being produced. Where are the people saying "I love when my coworkers send me AI-generate PRs"?
that’s like saying a book is only worth reading if each sentence is beautiful
To me I couldn’t care less as long as the overall story is coherent, and I care more about the idea density in the book.
Lord of the rings is a great book because of the ideas, not because Tolkien is the best writer ever.
Same with AI. I couldn’t care less if some of its code is crap, if it is dense with ideas and generally good execution. If it writes crap code sections I can “beautify” myself.
Plus LLMs are only going to improve… they have improved so much since ChatGPT 3. It’s insane.
And the arguments saying they haven’t can’t be taken in good faith
Claude Code is excellent at writing (C++) code. Especially multi-threading code. However I still need to verify everything because it will occasionally make mistakes.
Oh well. Time to start building a new career before I'm completely irrelevant I guess
1 - I wonder why my other social circles are so different.
If you see people saying it often, but you are convinced they are just feeling threatened, what AI generated software would point to to say, "Look at this! Definitive evidence that they are just coping!"
/s
But really I’m just comparing against my personal experience. Once I learned how to use the tools well, and what to expect (and what not to), I’ve found LLMs to be very powerful.
This is a trap. Anyone who answers this will see the goalposts being moved yet again.
95% of our code at a top in market global fintech is now written by agents. We make it write good code, and it does.
Basically, the people that leave dozens of bikeshed code review comments.
Sure, sometimes I might ask the AI to break out a helper function or structure things differently, but that's the same as working with another dev
People need to read the slop they're throwing at reviewers.
If that's what the token providers themselves can get out of their SOTA models, imagine how bad it is for other companies.
One of the things I've started doing is to write the high level scaffold myself, create stubs (with comments) and have it fill out the details. I haven't done this for long, but I feel like my mental model of the code rots less, and I can review code faster.
I used to do this in the past, when these models were not all that capable, now there is a huge temptation to leave everything to the model. But long term I lose track of whats going on, and have a hard time even communicating with the model about the changes I want. Just a total decay of my mental model of the system, and it's really hard to recover from that state.
It works quite well for me, a lot better than when the LLM makes these decisions.
I write code myself and use the LLM to find mistakes then fix them manually. I recommend inverting the conventional wisdom on LLMs:
Is this as fast as AI writing the code? Not at first but possibly over time. Maybe faster. Certainly better quality.Plus you don't lose any of your skills in the process.
You're still doing the gruntwork necessary to keep your skillset.
And the token cost is a small fraction of what it takes to get LLMs to write good code.