But it seems that the problem here is that google accepts DMCA requests that are not signed by an individiual but mass produced by a computer. That really shouldn't be allowed and I don't know why it is (what other legal documents are mass produced by a computer with no human oversight? Deeds? wills? power of atterny? Didn't think so).
In this example he plagarist has no dicincentive to plagarise again from some other source.
The nice thing about the zero to the stronger student without consequence to the weak student is that they didn't go down together, which tends to make the affected more likely to go confront the issue.
Sure, what I'm saying is not based on any hard data except my years at uni and the fact that a physics professor in my campus did the exact same thing.
The bigger problem is the "knowingly" in "any person who knowingly materially misrepresents...that material or activity is infringing...shall be liable for any damages". Enforcement has no teeth because that is a barrier that almost no discovery process will be able to overcome.
Mortgages and foreclosure documents come to mind. See "robosigners".
http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/false-affidavits-fore...
Why wouldn't both students be immediately expelled for this behavior?
In university I took advantage of a lot of my peers by having them critique/edit my assignments (of course, I'd offer the same in exchange). One of my editors could have a moment of weakness and plagiarize my work, but that's never happened in all those years. However, it was always possible. Would that merit expulsion on my part? Or should the punishment be a slap on the wrist and a reminder to exercise better judgment in the future?
On the other end, sometimes the person committing the plagiary isn't aware that what they're doing is wrong. I've seen a lot of it at the writing center, and this happens a lot with (especially east-asian) foreign students. Here in the US, we teach that individuals should have our own ideas, but in some places, they encourage adopting ideas from great thinkers (understand and make their ideas your own; stand on the shoulder of giants so to speak). And even with local students, some genuinely don't understand that copy-pasting 2 lines from the wiki is a breach of conduct.
In the end, it's much better for these students that you take the time to teach them the hows and whys of avoiding plagiarism. There are a few bad eggs that will never learn and will consistently plagiarize, and its at that point when expulsion is merited - and probably best for these students, since they probably weren't meant for academia. However, the majority of students (even the foreign ones) catch on and grow to be very successful academically.
Now, I don't know how it's possible any student could have completed all those years of school prior to college without having encountered this lesson. Our school system truly is dysfunctional.
So... I wish Google would selectively remove links that are clearly submitted erroneously (claiming that, since the studios own these sites, no third party is claiming fair use) whereas preventing links where fair use appear clearly reasonable (such as wikipedia and reviews from news outlets) from being removed.