News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by fn-mote on Thursday June 25, 2026 @12:34AM (#48668940)
My assumption is the credibility of a non-PhD-holding medical student’s research is 0, just like (almost) any other inexperienced researcher.
Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by BrtByte on Thursday June 25, 2026 @04:10AM (#48670427)
A med student can absolutely contribute useful work, especially with good supervision. The issue is more that inexperienced authors plus publication pressure plus easy tooling is a bad combination
Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by thomasfedb on Thursday June 25, 2026 @02:32AM (#48669770)
As a clinician-academic who published in The Lancet during medical school, I think this goes a bit far. Unfortunately student doctors are encouraged to publish whether or not they actually have an interest in research… but that shouldn’t discount the work of those who are genuinely engaged.

But certainly we should always approach the literature critically, including the author list, journal of publication and its peer-review practices, and the methods.

Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by BrtByte on Thursday June 25, 2026 @04:11AM (#48670437)
I think this is the right distinction
Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by bflesch on Thursday June 25, 2026 @03:31AM (#48670149)
I was severely disillusioned about the quality of clinical studies.

Would you publish if the head honcho of your double-blind study insists to know what treatment a certain patient is receiving?

You have this discussion about research ethics and subsequent beratement once, and then you either mentally check out or go to another hospital.

Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by gbnwl on Thursday June 25, 2026 @06:22AM (#48671409)
As usual HN posters are hyper aware of other's credentials while ignoring that their BS in CS (if that) doesn't magically qualify them to assess everything in every domain.

"I'm a software engineer, I'm sure if I had the time to study Neuroscience, I'd figure out what all of these researchers failed to realize all these decades! I (alone) have the magic of critical and logical thinking"

Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by Avicebron on Thursday June 25, 2026 @07:57AM (#48672112)
A lot of us here have masters, PhDs, have published in academia, worked in the hard sciences or different engineerinf disciplines.

But I agree, when youre on the internet no ones knows you're a dog.

Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by tremon on Thursday June 25, 2026 @07:10AM (#48671755)
> student doctors are encouraged to publish whether or not they actually have an interest in research… but that shouldn’t discount the work of those who are genuinely engaged.

How do you propose the interested public make the distinction between genuine engagement and forced encouragement? Isn't it the task of journals to make that distinction before publishing? I don't think you can fault the public for dismissing everything out of hand when both academia and the journals are actively turning scientific publishing into a market for lemons.

Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by frollogaston on Thursday June 25, 2026 @05:56PM (#48679741)
Check the incentives. I know how much pressure there is for medical students to publish research just to get into residency programs. That match process often determines where they'll live for the foreseeable future. A few years later and suddenly they have MDs and things are more set.

Likewise view an MS (the degree itself) with suspicion if it was the only good way for that person to even be in the country.

Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by thomasfedb on Saturday June 27, 2026 @02:56AM (#48695839)
It is my (unpopular I suspect) opinion that the contents of medical or other academic journals is not intended for consumption by the “interested public” as much as I can understand the desire to do so.

That’s not the same as saying that the interested public shouldn’t be able to learn about these things, but I do think they will often need assistance from those who are trained to read and discriminate this content.

And yes, journals should also do better, and peer review should be high quality and paid (you get, ultimately, what you pay for…)

Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by gowld on Thursday June 25, 2026 @10:39AM (#48674142)
Were you first-author on an unsupervised project and paper, or did someone stake their reputation on your work?
Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by mishellaneous on Thursday June 25, 2026 @04:13AM (#48670446)
a friend of a friend who did a stint in biomedical academia told me that the researchers in their field did not hold research coming from the medicine community in high regard
Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by boelboel on Thursday June 25, 2026 @06:10AM (#48671323)
Knew a professor statistics from a world renowned institution. He worked in nephrology for 10-20 years and would tell many stories about the worst practices he's seen and researchers pushed him to allow.

Medicine was among the worst if not the worst according to him. Didn't really want much to do with it anymore. Basically a case of subpar statistical knowledge and bad incentives.

Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by gowld on Thursday June 25, 2026 @10:50AM (#48674324)
How can you tell when you are reading a paper?
Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by dekhn on Thursday June 25, 2026 @01:35PM (#48676751)
The author list will show "M.D." instead of (or in addition to) "Ph.D.". The paper terminology will be skewed towards medical terms.
Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by mishellaneous on Friday June 26, 2026 @05:36AM (#48684453)
my impression is that inside these niches, people know each other personally, or are only separated by a small number of degrees. reputations form, etc. so any paper they end up reading, most likely does not have completely unknown authors from completely unknown institutions. without this information, yeah, it'd be harder to judge. surely anyone can find out anyone else's (using full name and institution) academic background online today, but it'd not be so easy to judge it without being an insider.
Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by elendilm on Friday June 26, 2026 @05:47AM (#48684529)
There will be clues and leaks hidden in the sentences of the paper. Compression always leaks out.
Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by niekmaas on Thursday June 25, 2026 @03:03AM (#48669935)
Well, that is a statement..! As an MD PhD with over 60 (co-)publications including multiple in top 1% journals I can say for sure that this is untrue. Of course this may be different per topic and country, but there is perfect research being published by non-PhD scientists. In fact, the PI from a top-tier US university I collaborate with for over 10 years doesn't even have a PhD.
Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by KeplerBoy on Thursday June 25, 2026 @03:18AM (#48670043)
You can be a PI without having a PhD?
Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by internet_user on Thursday June 25, 2026 @04:53AM (#48670800)
Even Hassabis found time to do a PhD. This is extra strange.
Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by dekhn on Thursday June 25, 2026 @01:31PM (#48676692)
I've seen this a few times- for example, my manager at Berkeley Lab was a PI but only had an undergrad degree. This is very rare, however.
Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by 11101010010001 on Thursday June 25, 2026 @10:08AM (#48673668)
Both your statement and the OPs are an appeal to expertise which is not a substitute for the scientific method.
Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by sebmellen on Thursday June 25, 2026 @01:49AM (#48669460)
This is really far too broad a brush.

Do most medical students publish useless case studies trying to jockey for residency spots and signal hustle/devotion? No doubt!

But there are a good handful of medical students who are still (surprisingly) in it for the medicine and not the money. And that handful is exceedingly capable; no reason they can’t publish valuable work with the right collaborators and resources.

Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by mishellaneous on Thursday June 25, 2026 @04:05AM (#48670400)
in that case, it's a question of proportion. we cannot automatically conclude that a (supposed) "good handful" doing good research makes up for "most students" doing bad research.
Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by myroon5 on Thursday June 25, 2026 @02:09AM (#48669605)
> no reason they can’t publish valuable work with the right collaborators

Despite h-index claiming to balance quantity and quality, it obviously incentives quantity over quality (no single publication can increment h-index as much as churning out a few worthless publications that cite each other); med students overwhelmingly follow those incentives trying to secure better residencies

Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by aardvark92 on Thursday June 25, 2026 @01:36AM (#48669371)
I guess it depends on who the coauthors and PI are - some academic mentors can be overly trusting and ‘hands-off.’ A lone medical student’s self published paper shouldn’t be worth much though…
Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by bflesch on Thursday June 25, 2026 @03:29AM (#48670125)
In the end it is about personal integrity and idealism, no matter what the titles are.

Totally different if someone's self image is that of a researcher for benefit of humankind or if they pick the career because they want to drive a Porsche.

Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by NotGMan on Thursday June 25, 2026 @02:21AM (#48669699)
Since we have seen that 50%+ of findings even in medical and other natural sciences are not repruductible it's obvious that even PhD people are mostly incompetent.
Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by samuraijack on Thursday June 25, 2026 @04:25AM (#48670562)
LLVM was a masters thesis project (not medicine related but research by non PhDs should not be disregarded imo)
Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by philipallstar on Thursday June 25, 2026 @04:52AM (#48670780)
LLVM was a thing that demonstrated its value by working when you used it. And you can't judge a population (all non-PhD theses) by its tippety-top performers, particularly when there are poor incentives involved.
Re:Medical students are using popular research tool to pump ... by elendilm on Thursday June 25, 2026 @05:47AM (#48671193)
What has PhD got to do with anything. Research is research regardless of who does it if using proper scientific method.

Such obvious common sense appears not obvious after all.