News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:RFC 10008: The new HTTP Query Method by Joker_vD on Wednesday June 17, 2026 @04:59PM (#48576811)

    Unlike POST, however, the method is explicitly safe and idempotent, allowing
    functions like caching and automatic retries to operate.
Re:RFC 10008: The new HTTP Query Method by account42 on Thursday June 18, 2026 @06:34AM (#48583396)
Putting something in a spec does not automatically make it true. In the real world if you repeat expensive queries more than an undefined amount you get blocked or at least bot-checked.
Re:RFC 10008: The new HTTP Query Method by projektfu on Thursday June 18, 2026 @08:13AM (#48584158)
From the browser POV it doesn't need to ask if you want to re-send data.
Re:RFC 10008: The new HTTP Query Method by themgt on Thursday June 18, 2026 @10:30AM (#48585990)
Putting something in a spec does not automatically make it true.

Terrible news for computing.

Re:RFC 10008: The new HTTP Query Method by spockz on Saturday June 20, 2026 @02:20AM (#48606828)
The point is that you need to take care to make the implementation of that endpoint safe. It isn’t safe magically by itself.
Re:RFC 10008: The new HTTP Query Method by themgt on Saturday June 20, 2026 @09:58AM (#48609292)
Great, got it. I'll update my running "how computing works" chart with this new information:

  | implementation = reality | magic  |
  |-----------------------------------|
  | 999,999,999,971 (+1)     | 0      |
Re:RFC 10008: The new HTTP Query Method by spockz on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @10:51AM (#48645940)
Why the snark? The existing methods have been around for ages. Many engineers I’ve encountered were not even aware that there was a distinction between “idempotent” and “safe” as attributes of a method and generally conflated them, using “safe” in the sense of the dictionary definition instead of the spec’s.

Elsewhere it was suggested that we can now replace POST with this query. I was trying to be cautionary because just changing the method alone will bring different behaviour. I did so in brevity because I was in a rush. IMHO, that does not call for snark.

Re:RFC 10008: The new HTTP Query Method by spockz on Thursday June 18, 2026 @01:14PM (#48588479)
Yes. That is what the spec says. However, if the search query is expensive you need some form of caching. Either on the endpoint itself caching the data, or the mechanism with location to redirect to the location of the result.