Re:Want your images back? Sure... That'll be $5!
by echoangle on Wednesday June 17, 2026 @10:16AM
(#48570893)
Well one complaint is that the OP was told he would be able to get photos for $5 when they actually weren’t any there (which photobucket knew before obviously). That actually seems deceptive enough that I would try to get my money back.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Want your images back? Sure... That'll be $5!
by mbo on Wednesday June 17, 2026 @10:30AM
(#48571085)
Yes that's exactly why I mentioned that in the first line of my comment. I quote directly:
> (I do agree that it's bad that there were no images preserved and that component of the post is justifiable)
Re:Want your images back? Sure... That'll be $5!
by echoangle on Wednesday June 17, 2026 @10:42AM
(#48571225)
So how is it a win-win then? OP only lost?
The rest of your comment kind of assumed that OP paid for the images and then got them.
Re:Want your images back? Sure... That'll be $5!
by mbo on Wednesday June 17, 2026 @11:02AM
(#48571500)
It is a win-win for Photobucket users who have their images (which OP is NOT a cohort of) preserved long term and the startup who snapped up Photobucket's data and liabilities. It is fair to say that OP experienced a win-loss in this specific situation.
I did not assume that OP got the images. That's why I explicitly called it out. In my first sentence. And again in my second last sentence. Jesus.
Re:Want your images back? Sure... That'll be $5!
by xp84 on Wednesday June 17, 2026 @11:30AM
(#48571878)
Imagine you were building this reactivation flow. How likely would you have thought it to be that someone keeps the password to a completely unused account for 10-20 years, then suddenly misremembers it as an actually-used account and goes to reactivate it? This has probably happened on Photobucket maybe 5 times total. I don't even remember the names of any sites I signed up for and never used in 2006, let alone have interest in logging into them decades later. They could have added a check to make it clear the account is empty up front, but I can see how the person designing it thought it might be incredibly rare (and they were right).
Re:Want your images back? Sure... That'll be $5!
by Dylan16807 on Wednesday June 17, 2026 @09:37PM
(#48579479)
If it was that old you likely had a password you used for a bunch of things, and also you can reset the password.
The case of not having images is really obvious.