News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by mapmeld on Friday June 12, 2026 @02:12PM (#48507465)
I think it's an interesting perspective, because translation is one of the jobs that I (a) hear is the first to lose work due to AI, and (b) often used as an example of "acceptable" AI by people who are skeptics of LLMs and AI-generated art.
Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by xigoi on Friday June 12, 2026 @02:17PM (#48507528)
> often used as an example of "acceptable" AI by people who are skeptics of LLMs and AI-generated art.

As one of such people, I think there is a nuance to it. AI is great when you’re translating something to yourself. But when translating things for others, more caution and human judgement is needed. Espesially when translating instruction manuals, where bad wording could cause someone to injure themself.

Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by inigyou on Friday June 12, 2026 @02:27PM (#48507666)
This. I put things through Google translate all the time and they're always unreliable. Sometimes they're correct, sometimes I need to know roughly what the original said. Infamously, Google used to say "geiler Typ" meant "horny guy" when it means "awesome guy". Google used to think "geil" meant "horny" in general, which it can but not usually
Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by smallerfish on Friday June 12, 2026 @02:38PM (#48507801)
Google translate is primitive compared to Claude at translations.
Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by carlosjobim on Friday June 12, 2026 @02:38PM (#48507791)
Google Translate is at the bottom of the barrel. All other AI translation tools are vastly superior. You'd want to evaluate those, and forget about Google Translate completely.
Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by numpad0 on Friday June 12, 2026 @03:51PM (#48508703)
It's all the same, except LLMs are less precise with names.
Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by carlosjobim on Friday June 12, 2026 @04:33PM (#48509135)
Just like a car and a school bus are the same because both have four wheels?
Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by edude03 on Friday June 12, 2026 @04:45PM (#48509236)
Googles machine translation team wrote the Attention is all you need paper that introduced transformers specifically to solve the problem that you can just model language by mapping one word to another. I'd be floored if they weren't using the tech they invented for intended purpose
Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by numpad0 on Friday June 12, 2026 @11:53PM (#48512858)
Yeah. LLMs, machine translations, CJK keyboards, they are all the same technology; faster cars to each others, not cars vs horse drawn carriages. It'll be surprising if they didn't directly apply any applicable learnings back to Google Translate.
Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by ai-x on Friday June 12, 2026 @02:25PM (#48507633)
Exactly, it's never about absolute results, it's always

Expected Value (Upside, given time/cost savings + Downside, given %reliability).

So, every task falls under a spectrum

Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by duffycommaryan on Friday June 12, 2026 @03:06PM (#48508184)
Language is incredibly complex. I remember a TikTok from a bilingual English-Korean speaker comparing the English subtitles from a Squid Game scene to what was actually being said by the characters. The nuance and info density lost in translation made the subtitles feel completely remedial. Americans were basically watching a different show altogether.
Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by ClimaxGravely on Friday June 12, 2026 @05:21PM (#48509567)
I'm by no means a native level Japanese speaker but I'm frequently surprised at how off Japanese-English subtitles can be.
Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by alex0015 on Saturday June 13, 2026 @02:34AM (#48514069)
I was watching the Netflix show The Empress with Chinese subtitles that did a pretty good job translating the German. I switched to English subs for one episode and couldn't stop telling the people I was watching with "That's not what he said! That's completely different!"
Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by ClimaxGravely on Monday June 15, 2026 @09:19PM (#48549344)
Oh weird! I wonder why that is. I wonder if they just put more effort into translating to Chinese? Very curious/interesting.
Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by raincole on Friday June 12, 2026 @02:23PM (#48507610)
There are translators and there are translators. Translating legal/business documents is a completely different thing from translating movies/books/games.

I can confidently say that LLMs do a better job than the average traditionally published fictions in my country, at least when the original works are in English. Every single time I watch a subbed movie there will be some lines noticeably wrong.

Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by anigbrowl on Friday June 12, 2026 @05:24PM (#48509602)
Yes, I've become very leery of artistic translation, in part because the paradigm of translators as adapters and localizers often ends up at odds with the job of faithfully and accurately representing the original material.

The most egregious example I came across recently was where a friend enthused about some manga he was reading and I agreed to read a few chapters, only to discover that the translator has decided to render the countryside accents of western Japan (engaging with a protagonist visiting from Tokyo) by having them say 'y'all' and 'bless your heart' and other Southern USA tropes. I get the aspiration of the translator, but it was excruciatingly unpleasant to read. At that point, why not just say the protagonist was from New York and on vacation in Florida, or draw in some meshback caps on some of the characters and add alligators here and there in the background?

Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by layer8 on Friday June 12, 2026 @02:24PM (#48507623)
Translators already started losing jobs due to machine translation a decade ago (e.g. DeepL), before LLMs. Remuneration going down made it more difficult to make a living as a translator already then, even if you still received offers.
Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by qsort on Friday June 12, 2026 @02:24PM (#48507617)
Not all translations are the same. Literary translations are often works of art in and of themselves, and automating them would be missing the point entirely, like automating homework or weightlifting at the gym. I don't really know what's the state of the art, but I do buy that, on the other hand, translating toaster manuals or generic copy could soon be automatic.
Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by greiskul on Friday June 12, 2026 @02:33PM (#48507739)
Yup. If you are bilingual, you quickly realize how some translations are very bad. How some translations are very good. And how hard it is to translate. With dry, simple text, it might be easy. But when it involves art? Some jokes don't translate directly. There is pun. Sounds of words. Double meaning. Ambiguity. Cultural background. The creation of new words.

It can be reasonably argued that some poetry can be impossible to translate from some languages to others. A poem might be explained, but by a lenghty, dissecting explanation, that completely loses the point of it.

Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by graemep on Friday June 12, 2026 @02:37PM (#48507789)
Or if you compare a poetic translation to a literal one, of different translations of the same work to the same language to each other.
Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by duffycommaryan on Friday June 12, 2026 @03:07PM (#48508193)
When it's one one-hundredth the cost, "good enough" is generally good enough.
Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by geon on Friday June 12, 2026 @02:41PM (#48507845)
"Could not connect to translation service" was apparently good enough for someone, so the bar must be extremely low.

https://www.reddit.com/r/funny/comments/3e786n/chinese_hair_...

On the other hand, a lot of people become extremely put off by the smallest sign of ai slop. And the llms have a tendency to impart their style to any text they touch.

Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by anigbrowl on Friday June 12, 2026 @05:26PM (#48509622)
I prefer to get my hair cut at 'Usage limits exceeded.'
Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by SecretDreams on Friday June 12, 2026 @02:28PM (#48507680)
It'll be a similar theme for all facets of work involving any language, slowly - human or code. We'll parrot about humans in the loop this and that, but I think it'll be less humans in the loop over time and I think most people will even be willing to settle for a slightly more mediocre translation or coded project. It all comes back to our dopamine addiction, where we like fast feedback. And the oligarchs like tools to suppress wages. We will be our own demise for not advocating for either UBI or job protections, instead, happily using the technology while also rolling our eyes that it could never replace us.
Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by Marsymars on Friday June 12, 2026 @06:25PM (#48510134)
Well it's more than acceptable to translate e.g. web pages for reading, but it's not something you'd want to professionally publish.

Kinda conceptually similar to how typos and grammatical mistakes aren't a big deal if you're shooting off a quick text or email, but publishing if you've got typos in your advertising copy, in your resume, on your medicine label, etc. it's a real bad look.

Re:"Don't You Just Upload It to ChatGPT?" by fzeroracer on Saturday June 13, 2026 @08:59AM (#48516869)
I think the only people that genuinely think AI translation is viable are those that never read in the first place.

There are a number of games I've seen and played on Steam which use MTL to get the game playable in English and universally the translation is absolute shit. Sentences that don't transition into another, wordplay that becomes nonsense and a completely flat affect to everything.