News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man... by variety8675 on Sunday June 07, 2026 @05:21PM (#48438686)
I'm no fan of flock, but I dislike how these articles are blaming the technology when the real issue is the police not bothering to check the information they're given
Re:Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man... by loteck on Sunday June 07, 2026 @07:31PM (#48439729)
We blame the technology because police misusing their powers is a tale as old as police, is demonstrably not fixable, and this technology is at fault for aggressively selling itself to police to give them these powers that we all know will be misused. Flock absolutely bears significant responsibility for creating the technology and conditions for this unjust behavior to exist, and continuing to advocate against those pushing back on it by trying to brand them as terrorists.
Re:Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man... by SoftTalker on Sunday June 07, 2026 @05:22PM (#48438692)
Yeah this reads like the cops simply didn't properly identify the vehicle. If anything, the Flock camera photo proves he was miles away.
Re:Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man... by garyfirestorm on Sunday June 07, 2026 @05:40PM (#48438846)
But flock hit is the entire reason for the cops to go arrest them. And you’re right if they did careful assessment of other flock camera data, even the data of this particular flock camera they would have known this car was 5 miles away 23 seconds later. The whole point being misusing/abusing flock data to wrongly jail people and that is precisely what happened here. Flock is the center of this story.
Re:Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man... by bhickey on Sunday June 07, 2026 @05:45PM (#48438898)
> [T]hey would have known this car was 5 miles away 23 seconds later.

Tack on a reckless driving charge and a speeding ticket.

Re:Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man... by Wingy on Sunday June 07, 2026 @05:54PM (#48438965)
782.6mph is way too fast.
Re:Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man... by snerbles on Monday June 08, 2026 @10:32AM (#48445948)
As long as the vehicle traveling above Mach 1 remains a ground vehicle, the FAA won't get involved.
Re:Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man... by wombatpm on Sunday June 07, 2026 @05:51PM (#48438935)
Police would just argue that the second datapoint was wrong.
Re:Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man... by cwmoore on Sunday June 07, 2026 @08:08PM (#48439950)
Obviously so, maybe society should hire criminals to catch the police.
Re:Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man... by garyfirestorm on Monday June 08, 2026 @11:54AM (#48446989)
Schrodinger's flock - the 'hit' helped us catch the criminals and the hit is wrong. but we are going ahead with prosecution nonetheless.
Re:Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man... by loteck on Sunday June 07, 2026 @07:35PM (#48439758)
They simply didn't properly identify the vehicle because Flock's ALPR gave them the pass. The innocent person would not have needed "photo proof" of his distant location if the ALPR didn't exist in the first place. Then he would not have been forced to spend a month of his life in jail.
Re:Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man... by dlcarrier on Sunday June 07, 2026 @06:06PM (#48439066)
Ironically, they're showing a situation where more tracking makes innocence clear. There's countless examples of innocent people being caught in a dragnet, based on data that correlates with but does not prove guilt, where more data collection leads to more innocent people suffering. That's what they should be focusing on.
Re:Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man... by turtlesdown11 on Sunday June 07, 2026 @05:59PM (#48439004)
A tool that requires perfect human oversight to avoid harming innocent people is a problem
Re:Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man... by FireBeyond on Sunday June 07, 2026 @06:28PM (#48439225)
There is absolutely that, but the CEO of Flock has said he believes a false-positive is better than a false-negative, so everything around the stack pushes police that way, too.
Re:Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man... by aaomidi on Sunday June 07, 2026 @05:56PM (#48438976)
Re:Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man... by OutOfHere on Sunday June 07, 2026 @05:41PM (#48438859)
It is Flock's responsibility to grant access only to trained professionals who undergo routine training and testing in how to and how not to use the system.
Re:Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man... by pixl97 on Sunday June 07, 2026 @05:55PM (#48438970)
So they can't show it to the police in the US?
Re:Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man... by OutOfHere on Sunday June 07, 2026 @05:56PM (#48438982)
Every police officer with access to the system must ideally have to undergo mandatory annual training and testing in using it to protect the rights of innocents. If they don't pass the testing, they ideally should not be granted access.

Flock should be held accountable for ensuring adequate protections exist to prevent misuse.

Re:Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man... by pixl97 on Sunday June 07, 2026 @08:12PM (#48439972)
It's kinda funny that all our personal data leaks out of companies all the time and little to nothing happens to them, and now you're thinking Flock is going to be held accountable?!

We should have laws against collecting this in the first place.

Re:Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man... by OutOfHere on Monday June 08, 2026 @02:12PM (#48448996)
What do you mean nothing happens to them?:

https://news.google.com/search?q=location%20data%20lawsuit%2...

Re:Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man... by pksebben on Sunday June 07, 2026 @06:03PM (#48439042)
It's not a training problem, it's an incentive problem. You put these guys in a structure that requires them to justify their jobs at minimal cost of effort and then ooh ack surprise when they don't take the proper care to ensure that they're not stepping on innocent people in the pursuit of a healthy career.

Couple that with overburdening them with petty nonsense all the time and training them in military equipment and tactics and like it doesn't matter what tools you give them, those tools will be abused at convenience.

The issue is structural, not technical, but power tools = more damage per capita.

Re:Flock license plate reader wrongly linked a San Diego man... by OutOfHere on Sunday June 07, 2026 @06:10PM (#48439095)
It's not a dichotomy. "Checks and balances" are a thing since the founding of the United States. If the local government fails to institute them, it should be the complementary responsibility of the vendor to have them. In their absence, lawsuits targeting all parties are highly desirable.