News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by ipaddr on Saturday May 23, 2026 @08:02PM (#48252884)
Someone else would have taken that job maybe for a higher salary.
Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by bonsai_spool on Saturday May 23, 2026 @08:26PM (#48253035)
At a certain point, there aren't enough Americans for these jobs. So the choice is to let other nations absorb these skilled laborers, or simply hire the best people.

It's funny how we forget about meritocracy as soon as the median American is threatened.

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by pixelatedindex on Saturday May 23, 2026 @09:18PM (#48253362)
> At a certain point, there aren't enough Americans for these jobs

Is that really true? I’m sure in some fields where you need rare experts I believe it. For the average engineer who is just another cog in the wheel of big corp, I highly doubt it.

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by bonsai_spool on Saturday May 23, 2026 @11:08PM (#48253965)
> Is that really true? I’m sure in some fields where you need rare experts I believe it. For the average engineer who is just another cog in the wheel of big corp, I highly doubt it.

Have you ever hired someone before? Did you decide to take the best person you found or did you pick an American?

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by pixelatedindex on Sunday May 24, 2026 @12:04AM (#48254273)
> Have you ever hired someone before? Did you decide to take the best person you found or did you pick an American?

Many times. Sometimes we don’t offer sponsorships so we hired who didn’t need one. Other times not. During the interview process where they’re from isn’t the matter at hand. Either way, there’s no shortage of good candidates - solely American / GC or not.

Though let’s be honest - there is a question behind the question, isn’t there? Why don’t you just ask that instead?

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by bonsai_spool on Sunday May 24, 2026 @12:12AM (#48254298)
> Though let’s be honest - there is a question behind the question, isn’t there? Why don’t you just ask that instead?

You answered it - you picked the best person, who sometimes was not American.

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by pixelatedindex on Sunday May 24, 2026 @01:37PM (#48259326)
That doesn’t directly prove that there aren’t enough Americans who can do the job. Sometimes yeah, the non American is better like in photolithography.

Generally though, the foreign candidate is not so much better that hiring an American would have lowered the bar.

Sometimes it also comes down to leveling - I’ve had to down level people due to budget concerns. Americans can hold out for that better job, but the other cannot so companies take advantage of that.

My point is that it’s not a skill issue, it’s a wage + location issue. Foreigners will find that their wage is better than what they can earn at home, so they can undercut that citizens who’s held out for a better opportunity.

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by bonsai_spool on Sunday May 24, 2026 @02:38PM (#48259854)
> so they can undercut that citizens who’s held out for a better opportunity.

Just to better understand, genuinely, do you mean that the company would increase their budget in the event that a foreign worker had not been available, and that an American would have taken the job at that time, given the higher wage?

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by pixelatedindex on Sunday May 24, 2026 @04:28PM (#48260729)
Why wouldn’t they? It’s a supply and demand thing, supply is lower so pay is higher to meet demand.

Other ways to solve is to settle for less if the job isn’t that crucial, or look for someone who lives in a lower cost of living area who can take the wage. But that also depends on the whole RTO fiasco.

To be clear, if you are doing leading edge R&D or some super special project like SpaceX, etc then yeah you need to seek the brightest minds across the globe. But to maintain your CMS or work in some ERP softwares, you can definitely find an American to do it.

The basic point I’m making is a large majority of H1B work can be done just as well (within an acceptable error rate) by someone here. There are reasons why you need some special talent but those aren’t as common.

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by ipaddr on Saturday May 23, 2026 @10:42PM (#48253845)
With AI taking a percentage of jobs there will be enough people to fill those positions and more. Why bring in workers when productivity is taking away positions.
Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by bonsai_spool on Saturday May 23, 2026 @11:07PM (#48253962)
> With AI taking a percentage of jobs there will be enough people to fill those positions and more. Why bring in workers when productivity is taking away positions.

Have you ever hired someone before?

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by ipaddr on Sunday May 24, 2026 @12:15AM (#48254313)
AI is forecasted to remove 30% of white collar jobs in the next few years. People are not hiring now.

Do you work in hr?

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by bonsai_spool on Sunday May 24, 2026 @11:40AM (#48258171)
> Have you ever hired someone before?

You didn't answer!

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by ipaddr on Monday May 25, 2026 @12:50PM (#48268939)
Not in hr or own small company with 3 workers
Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by jaharios on Saturday May 23, 2026 @09:21PM (#48253393)
So we should strive to maximize companies profits over the citizens?
Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by rjbwork on Saturday May 23, 2026 @09:07PM (#48253278)
>It's funny how we forget about meritocracy as soon as the median American is threatened.

What meritocracy? This is a myth pushed to justify a kind of "just world" interpretation of our social ills. Nepotism is increasing, social mobility decreasing. To believe in meritocracy in the face of this is to deny reality.

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by dnnddidiej on Saturday May 23, 2026 @10:34PM (#48253789)
But then they gave up a tax paying job and thus the net effect is zero.

Looking holistically the person leaving the US (or lets say 100 people to make it easier to see the point) means 1 to 30 less startups and so maybe an entire company or more not being started. That is less revenue for US.

What most people from the "they steal our jobs" mentality (not saying that is you, but this a seperate point) don't get is productive people create jobs by being a customer of many businesses.

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by ipaddr on Saturday May 23, 2026 @10:40PM (#48253836)
Then someone lower got a better job and someone out of work ends up in a job.
Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by bonsai_spool on Saturday May 23, 2026 @11:06PM (#48253959)
There are not enough qualified people in any particular country for all the possible new technologies that could be deployed. You're not likely to hire your plumber to program a webapp.

That doesn't mean your plumber isn't qualified—just that people looking for webapps want to hire workers who know how to make them.

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by ipaddr on Sunday May 24, 2026 @12:05AM (#48254277)
So many computer science grads can't find work many have left the field. I don't think we will run out of workers.

There is the other side plenty of workers successful at programming language could be trained to fill any gap. That's what happened in the 50s and 60s..

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by rtgfhyuj on Sunday May 24, 2026 @02:17AM (#48254897)
lol cs grads can’t do this work
Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by dnnddidiej on Sunday May 24, 2026 @03:57AM (#48255413)
Companies also struggle to hire. It is a skills matching issue.
Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by hunterpayne on Sunday May 24, 2026 @05:57AM (#48255976)
Companies struggle to hire at a rate they want to pay. They don't struggle to hire at a market rate pay or more. Funny how that works.

PS The number of roles that there aren't qualified Americans for could be counted on one hand. This has always been about reducing salaries, not shortages.

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by mlnj on Sunday May 24, 2026 @07:17AM (#48256355)
I highly doubt a company can find 20k senior Photolithography experts in rural Nebraska if a company wanted. No matter what money they are paying. They'll have to bring them in.

Of course I am exaggerating, but this is not a 1 dimensional problem.

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by Saline9515 on Sunday May 24, 2026 @10:42AM (#48257654)
Please check what the majority of H1-Bs are hired for. It's a visa mainly used for cutting costs, not hiring ultra specialized people.
Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by mlnj on Sunday May 24, 2026 @12:41PM (#48258790)
I was demonstrating that throwing money at the shortage does not magically create new talent in a geographical area. It has to be imported.
Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by Saline9515 on Sunday May 24, 2026 @04:58PM (#48260938)
The issue is that if you import all of skilled workers you need, salaries won't rise in the branch, and students or workers in adjacent fields don't have any incentives to learn the skill. If you can hire Syldavian photonics engineers for 50k$/y, no one is incentivized to learn photonics.

This is why in the modern world some sectors are always crying about "worker shortages" while asking always more migrant workers to come in - salaries are compressed as a result, and locals have no incentives to enter the branch.

Hence importing workers may be useful for needs that are limited in time and space (say, install a specialized foreign machinery in a power plant), but systematic importation leads to dequalification of the local workers, who flee the branch that has now low salaries.

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by kasabali on Sunday May 24, 2026 @08:56AM (#48256916)
it's a companies not wanting to spend any amount of time and money training an employee and wanting 100% utilization the second the employment starts issue.
Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by throwaway85825 on Saturday May 23, 2026 @11:33PM (#48254100)
Writing web apps is not the most skilled of jobs. Despite what some egos would have tou believe.
Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by dnnddidiej on Sunday May 24, 2026 @03:54AM (#48255403)
But a jobs worth of GDP was lost due to the lost consumption. Harder to measure for 1 person but imagine 100k people suddenly left a city. That would be felt somewhere. Dry cleaners, cafe, supermarkets etc.

This might be less true if there is resource starvation but we have transport and imports and exports. You can accomodate more people and feed them.

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by konschubert on Sunday May 24, 2026 @06:41AM (#48256160)
This is called the "lump of labour" fallacy:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lump_of_labour_fallacy

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by Saline9515 on Sunday May 24, 2026 @10:37AM (#48257617)
So the job market doesn't exist? Interesting!
Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by itsmek on Sunday May 24, 2026 @01:58PM (#48259537)
To be clear, their point is:

>The facts show that just like the amount of labor is not fixed, neither is the size of the economy (fixed pie fallacy) and as more work is done, the economy grows

Your reply is a glib thought-terminating cliche strawman that doesn't address their point at all. Interesting!

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by Saline9515 on Sunday May 24, 2026 @05:04PM (#48260973)
Those theories are based mainly on the effect of Cuban immigration in Miami, however they lack a control so you can't really conclude anything.

Besides, yeah, if you hire people who will work for any salary, the amount of jobs will increase, but salaries will decrease, for locals as well. After some time, locals will flee sectors where the migrant workers are brought in, creating further self-inflicted "labor shortages"...requiring more migrants!

The main winners are capital owners, who, thanks to the migrant workers, can now acquire a larger part of the added value generated by workers.

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by dnnddidiej on Sunday May 24, 2026 @08:39PM (#48262440)
These one dimensional brush offs of a complex system are a bit tiring. Doesn't sound like genuine curiousity. It is almost like political rhetoric.

Yes the job market exists.

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by Ntrails on Sunday May 24, 2026 @03:59AM (#48255426)
Those seem like bold assumptions about % of startups created by green card holders?

I feel like the better argument is that the greencard holder was the best candidate and thus will be more productive in the role. It is just efficient resource allocation. That, even without new companies, will drive profit/expansion/more jobs

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by light_hue_1 on Sunday May 24, 2026 @01:24AM (#48254663)
Or it would have moved overseas forever.

I can already on the ground see the effect of the Trump policies. So many tech jobs that would have been in the US are being lost. And companies are learning how to be effective with overseas teams.

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by qaq on Sunday May 24, 2026 @01:30AM (#48254693)
You do realize every major tech company has offices in EU and in India. You make it hard here they will hire more there
Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by lmz on Sunday May 24, 2026 @03:02AM (#48255148)
Good. They can go and replace some other country's population.
Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by aweiher on Sunday May 24, 2026 @04:43PM (#48260832)
Just so this doesn't go unanswered:

That is a far-right conspiracy theory for which there is absolutely no evidence.

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by lmz on Thursday May 28, 2026 @03:09AM (#48305646)
Importing people from countries with higher fertility rates into a country that gives citizenship based on birth location. What else could be the result?
Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by ozgrakkurt on Sunday May 24, 2026 @02:48AM (#48255050)
It is questionable if US has the education system or people capital to support all the science based sectors it has IMO.

Immigrants doing a very large portion of tech work can't be just because they get paid less

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by hunterpayne on Sunday May 24, 2026 @06:02AM (#48255998)
"Immigrants doing a very large portion of tech work can't be just because they get paid less"

It is solely about that. Remember, immigrants didn't really play a role in the US tech industry for half of its existence and didn't play a major role until a decade ago. This is despite the fact that US colleges openly and actively discriminate against US citizens for grad school spots for 2 or 3 decades now.

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by dukeyukey on Sunday May 24, 2026 @07:17AM (#48256358)
> and didn't play a major role until a decade ago

Sergey Brin? Paul Graham? Elon Musk?

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by mlnj on Sunday May 24, 2026 @07:27AM (#48256418)
>US colleges openly and actively discriminate against US citizens for grad school spots for 2 or 3 decades now.

Isn't this just because foreign students pay more than citizens? Isn't this just capitalism and the free market efficiently allocating resources?

Something about 'having the cake and eating it too'.

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by jakeydus on Sunday May 24, 2026 @02:49PM (#48259932)
Not just that, universities (especially smaller research universities) love having grad students whose research is paid for. China, Saudi Arabia, Brazil (less so now than in the past), Qatar, and others have all had programs for years where they paid the tuition and research costs of students at universities. Why would the university not pick that over a local kid who the university has to pay for out of their own coffers?
Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by bonsai_spool on Sunday May 24, 2026 @04:06PM (#48260565)
> Not just that, universities (especially smaller research universities) love having grad students whose research is paid for.

> Why would the university not pick that over a local kid who the university has to pay for out of their own coffers?

Universities don't pay for research - and departments usually don't pay for research either.

At the margin, a professor will prefer someone who has her own funding, but that person also needs to be competent, so I doubt the national schemes you are citing have made an impact on who gets into graduate school.

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by gottorf on Sunday May 24, 2026 @11:35PM (#48263200)
To be fair, not many parts of the US higher education system can be accurately described as free markets or capitalism.
Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by ModernMech on Sunday May 24, 2026 @09:41AM (#48257215)
> This is despite the fact that US colleges openly and actively discriminate against US citizens for grad school spots for 2 or 3 decades now.

Can you provide a citation for this specific claim? I used to do admissions to a grad program in the US, and we ended up admitting mostly foreign students soley because very few US citizens actually applied (probably only 10% of apps). Whether that's because they were not qualified or couldn't afford it I do not know. But it's not because they were openly and actively discriminated against.

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by convolvatron on Sunday May 24, 2026 @11:46AM (#48258227)
I've been involved in .. applied CS for 40 years, and the industry has been filled with people of a wide variety of backgrounds for that entire time. Even the I worked for the US DOD many of the people I worked were international.
Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by ytoawwhra92 on Sunday May 24, 2026 @09:41PM (#48262706)
> Remember, immigrants didn't really play a role in the US tech industry for half of its existence and didn't play a major role until a decade ago.

Bell, Wang, Fairchild, Intel, Sun...

Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by bubblethink on Sunday May 24, 2026 @05:10AM (#48255768)
Humans tend not to be fungible.
Re:Green Card Seekers Must Leave U.S. to Apply, Trump Admini... by konschubert on Sunday May 24, 2026 @06:43AM (#48256167)
More likely there would have been one less job.

There isn't a "lump of labour" that gets distributed in the economy.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lump_of_labour_fallacy