News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by kennywinker on Thursday November 22, 2012 @04:13PM (#4820017)
I would guess most of the vendors of these types of systems are going RFID. Magnetic stripes are fragile, as anyone who's had their visa de-magnatized can tell you. They are also perceived as "less secure", as anyone who knows anyone who's had their visa card "skimmed" can tell you.

For these reasons alone, RFID is where the puck is going to be. Then on top of that you add in you can sell institutions on tracking packages and analytics software and all that crap? I'm sure you can still buy mag-stripe versions of all this, but the people who do this are probably pushing RFID hard.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by cbhl on Thursday November 22, 2012 @04:21PM (#4820050)
RFID chips are fragile in different ways (try holding three in front of a reader at once). When NFC enabled chip and pin cards first came out (and RFID enabled e-passports for that matter) came out, there were concerns that these cards could be skimmed from hundreds metres away as opposed to skimming requiring the card being placed in a modified payment terminal.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by csense on Thursday November 22, 2012 @04:44PM (#4820123)
> there were concerns that these cards could be skimmed from hundreds [of] metres away

Why is that no longer a concern?

I would certainly be concerned about it.

Even if the cards can't be cloned from a distance, couldn't they still be tracked from a distance? Could the school actually be helping stalkers follow students unobtrusively?

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by cbhl on Thursday November 22, 2012 @09:58PM (#4820811)
It's debatable. Some steps have been taken to mitigate the impact (foil envelopes for your Passport Card, basic shielding on e-Passports, the introduction of MiFare DESFire as an alternative to MiFare Classic) but AFAICT it's still possible to skim the cards remotely. There was a period of time when these concerns were all over mainstream media (especially in Canada and Europe, during the migration to Chip-and-PIN, particularly for credit cards) but you don't see it often these days (except in extreme cases like the one in this article).
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by TeMPOraL on Thursday November 22, 2012 @04:54PM (#4820151)
It is, and the cards still can be cloned. You just need a big enough antenna.

See: http://hackaday.com/2012/05/27/reading-rfid-cards-from-afar-...

+ I recall someone else building a big antenna that allowed to read cards from range of meters.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by Wingman4l7 on Thursday November 22, 2012 @05:19PM (#4820221)
Reminds me of the "bluesniper", which was basically a Yagi antenna on a rifle stock, meant for sniffing Bluetooth devices from a distance.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by colanderman on Thursday November 22, 2012 @06:02PM (#4820346)
RFID chips are fragile in different ways (try holding three in front of a reader at once).

Mind sharing what exactly happens, before I have to explain why me and two co-workers suddenly need new ID cards?

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by Evbn on Thursday November 22, 2012 @06:47PM (#4820448)
Scrambled message so the reader can't recognize them.
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by iamdave on Thursday November 22, 2012 @04:18PM (#4820039)
I would guess most of the vendors of these types of systems are going RFID

Actually this makes sense, didn't think of that way. However, comparing security issues of credit/debit cards with student ID badges doesn't work; I'm not suggesting they don't exist, but on the whole are less likely in the setting we're looking at.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by objclxt on Thursday November 22, 2012 @04:24PM (#4820059)
You'd be surprised - when I was at college there was a student who was caught skimming ID cards, duplicating them, and selling them on (for access to various areas and also for payment, since our ID cards were used a declining balance cards). They switched over to RFID shortly afterwards. I'm sure this has happened at other colleges too.

And whilst this sort of thing is almost certainly less common than card fraud, the potential consequences are actually far more serious. If someone skims your credit card it's inconvenient, but hopefully your bank will cover the loss. If someone skims your ID card in a college environment where ID cards typically let you into controlled areas like dormitories and labs you've got a big problem.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by iamdave on Thursday November 22, 2012 @04:26PM (#4820072)
You'd be surprised - when I was at college there was a student who was caught skimming ID cards, duplicating them

But in a high school? Not that I'm disagreeing with you; but in high school the incentive seems to be much lower to forge ID cards. Maybe I'm just crotchety about this whole thing and am projecting to find whatever reason I can to dismiss the idea of forcing tracking on kids.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by tass on Thursday November 22, 2012 @06:34PM (#4820419)
RFID is the future. Magnetic cards were a problem waiting to be solved. They wear out, have to be big enough to comfortably swipe, and are easy to copy.

Credit cards, door locks, train tickets and anything with a magnetic swipe or barcode will eventually be replaced with RFID or similar.

The tracking part, however, is optional.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by kennywinker on Thursday November 22, 2012 @04:22PM (#4820052)
I was mostly thinking of the perception of security. Everyone knows you can clone a mag-stripe card cheaply and easily.

I assume you can do the same with RFIDs (and you don't even need physical access to do it, right?) but I think people assume they're safer.

Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by knowaveragejoe on Thursday November 22, 2012 @06:00PM (#4820339)
To be fair, skimming is and likely always will be an issue with RFID as well, unless there are low power microprocessors in the card that generate unique keys that are somehow syncronized with an external database...maybe someone with more experience can weigh in on this?
Re:Student Suspended for Refusing to Wear a School-Issued RF... by gizmo686 on Thursday November 22, 2012 @06:49PM (#4820454)
I would imagine existing cryptography could work. Each card could have a unique private key, and the public key would be associated with the students ID. At this point, someone can verify a card is who it says it is by asking the card to encrypt a randomly generated message. Assuming we are using the method I described (as apposed to a crypto-system optimized for identification), the card would only need to be able to encrypt 1 block (probably 512-bits) for each identification. This seems quite doable.