News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by peterlk on Monday May 18, 2026 @05:28PM (#48185926)
Bluesky, threads, mastodon, and everything else built on activitypub AT, etc. are still there. You can leave X behind; the only thing stopping you is the other people who could also leave X but are still there because you’re there. There are real problems with the fediverse, but they are solvable and the biggest problem is the social connections/stickiness. So start with that!
Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by TFNA on Monday May 18, 2026 @05:49PM (#48186194)
I’d argue that microblogging inherently trends towards social pathologies, since there is little room for nuance in such short-form text. Not to mention that those other platforms already have their own established cultures and shibboleths, where not everyone coming from a competing network will feel comfortable. If someone manages to shake off an X addiction, they might be better off giving up microblogging entirely.
Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by kccqzy on Monday May 18, 2026 @07:08PM (#48187115)
Microblogging in the fediverse somehow does not trend towards social pathologies. I just don’t ever feel the need to shorten my posts because the word limit is generally generous enough for significant nuance. It’s like HN: comments tend to be short just because of the medium, but longer comments with significant nuance are possible.
Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by TFNA on Monday May 18, 2026 @07:40PM (#48187397)
> Microblogging in the fediverse somehow does not trend towards social pathologies.

The fediverse, too, trends towards social pathologies; something or some things is causing craziness on all the mentioned platforms, even if the exact manifestations vary. For example, well into 2023, almost daily among the top-ranking posts on Mastodon was one advocating for harsh anti-Covid measures: e.g. that live music and theatre should never have been permitted again, insisting on masking in public at all times, etc. This was after countries lauded for their responsible Covid response had already returned to normality. The fact that posts like these could get such a welcome reception, sending them to the top, says something about how highly online and out of touch a significant portion of fediverse users are.

Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by krapp on Monday May 18, 2026 @07:47PM (#48187456)
Mastodon isn't a single web platform like Reddit. The phrase "among the top-ranking posts on Mastodon" is meaningless. There is no "the top" of Mastodon.
Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by dlcarrier on Monday May 18, 2026 @07:58PM (#48187543)
It's a federated communication protocol, like email and SMS. There's very much a culture for each, regardless of whether or not it's hosted on a single server. Most users don't even know whether or not a communication system is federated, they just know they can use it to send messages and that there are social protocols around using it.
Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by TFNA on Monday May 18, 2026 @07:50PM (#48187478)
I’m obviously talking about the main Mastodon instance and its Trending view [0]. The main instance has cultural prestige for the other instances that form the fediverse as people here normally define it and is regarded as exemplifying its values. But we’ve seen you disingenuously try to downplay issues here with the fediverse before.

[0] https://mastodon.social/explore

Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by krapp on Monday May 18, 2026 @08:05PM (#48187590)
You know there are tens of thousands of instances yet you chose to use language that implied that you were speaking about "Mastodon" as a whole, and then you chose to make judgements about fediverse users as a whole, based on a description of a single post on a single instance some unknown number of years ago. That is at best disingenuous, and at worse intentionally deceptive.

>But we’ve seen you disingenuously try to downplay issues here with the fediverse before.

Who is "we?" Jumping immediately into the defensive and accusatory personal attack? I don't know what caused you to harbor this sort of grudge against the fediverse and people who use it but get over it. Just let people have their space, and find your own.

Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by TFNA on Monday May 18, 2026 @08:13PM (#48187661)
Try reading my post again. I wasn’t making a judgement about “a single post” but a trend that lasted months and months.

But look at the Trending view right now (and tomorrow, and the next day, and the day after that). The Mastodon instance with the highest prestige isn’t showing from those “tens of thousands of instances” a wide variety of subject matter discussed in longform, nuanced manner. It’s showing mainly political posts and memes. It depicts the fediverse as pathological a forum as any of the other microblogging platforms, even if the particular politics differ.

Even if some people across instances use the fediverse to discuss other matters, a healthy ecosystem would be one that discourages highly-online stuff, not does the opposite and boosts its visibility.

> Just let people have their space, and find your own.

The whole topic of this subthread was about people leaving X and possibly finding another space. I’m showing why those people might not “find their own” in the fediverse (or at Threads or Bluesky, for that matter) and would be better off avoiding microblogging entirely.

Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by kccqzy on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @08:29AM (#48192446)
> almost daily among the top-ranking posts

Why would you even care about the top-ranking posts when it doesn’t even have an algorithmic timeline? It’s not like an algorithm will push such top-ranking posts onto your timeline. Your timeline remains under your control, with sophisticated muting and blocking capabilities.

Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by TFNA on Friday May 22, 2026 @07:31PM (#48242893)
Mastodon developers have repeatedly stated that the fediverse is not just a protocol but a distinct culture and values, and federating with their servers means accepting that culture and values. So, even if one’s timeline doesn’t show those posts, the posts are still normative for the overall culture.
Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by anigbrowl on Monday May 18, 2026 @06:19PM (#48186574)
This isn't a good argument. I did move most of my social activity off X on to other platforms, but despite months of effort I had little luck persuading other people to do the same.

It's not because they love Musk, the network effects are just too strong. Media companies mostly set up Bluesky accounts, for example, but they get a fraction of the traffic there. Many elected officials just stayed on X, or if they set up accounts on other platforms they underused or abandoned those which did not get a lot of traffic. World leaders are all still on X. I think it's foolish to blame individual users for 'not leaving hard enough' when all but a very few of them have too little influence to overcome the 'gravity' of the market leader.

Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by spiderfarmer on Monday May 18, 2026 @07:42PM (#48187416)
Nobody I know personally uses X. If you want real network effects, try Whatsapp. X can be ignored without missing anything.
Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by anigbrowl on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:08PM (#48197902)
I just told you why the network effects are so strong and you responded with anecdata about your personal social circle. You're ignoring the fact that X remains the platform where countries and many other official entities post official statements of policy first, and much other news breaks there first.
Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by nitwit005 on Monday May 18, 2026 @10:56PM (#48188661)
If you're actually creating content or running a business of some sort, it's hard to drop a platform, but for your average user it's fairly easy.

It's hard to tell how many people have left, but it's clearly significant.

Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by watwut on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @02:14AM (#48189843)
I left X after it became a wastland. Most of what was in my feed were accounts I did not followed and really really did not wanted to follow.
Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by Imustaskforhelp on Monday May 18, 2026 @05:43PM (#48186120)
Yea, I really want bluesky,mastodon to succeed in the sense of actually having people who are talking about things that I am interested in and more connections in general.

I would also wish to point out lemmy is an interesting project too.

I don't really use twitter anyway but I was frequent on bluesky but didn't really get any responses whatsoever sometimes so I ended up not using it either.

Hackernews and some other forums are honestly just about it for me at a certain point but I do wish to relook at bluesky and mastodon

Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by mnky9800n on Monday May 18, 2026 @10:01PM (#48188387)
LinkedIn is good. It’s not addictive. All your friends have one already. You can post whatever you want but nobody does because they think it’s work related. If you do post whatever you want you will begin to filter who is real and who is ai slop. You can’t spend more than like ten minutes a day looking at it because most of it is too boring to care. Friend me on LinkedIn:

https://www.linkedin.com/in/johnmaiken

Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by operatingthetan on Monday May 18, 2026 @10:03PM (#48188390)
>LinkedIn is good.

No, it's really not. It's full of the most vapid posts imaginable increasingly written by AI.

Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by jerlam on Monday May 18, 2026 @11:58PM (#48189006)
I think that's the joke. Linkedin content is so terrible you'll never get addicted to it.
Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by operatingthetan on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:32AM (#48190371)
Them posting their own profile made me think it was serious, but I'm coming around to your point.
Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by poulpy123 on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @03:51AM (#48190480)
I would say it's the most obvious part of the joke
Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by operatingthetan on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:04AM (#48190546)
Poe's law etc.
Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by Marsymars on Monday May 18, 2026 @10:25PM (#48188508)
Linkedin won't let me log in to my 15-year-old account without sharing government ID to Persona.
Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by umpalumpaaa on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @01:04AM (#48189369)
My main reason for not switching to mastodon:

Direct messages are a UX and privacy nightmare IMHO.

Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by chadgpt3 on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:56AM (#48190932)
Are they more private on X?
Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by chadgpt3 on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @04:59AM (#48190956)
People tend to think there's a demand for a Twitter-like platform, so if they make a new Twitter-like platform they can compete with it.

There isn't. There's demand for Twitter, specifically. Just like you wouldn't "switch" from HN to a hypothetical clone site, people don't switch from Twitter to Blue Sky. Blue Sky and Fediverse are separate platforms with separate identities and cultures and their surface resemblance to Twitter doesn't really mean anything. Twitter could be just as well "replaced" by anything else from Usenet to SMF to a literal megaphone.

Re:X accounts are limited to 50 posts and 200 replies a day ... by kgwxd on Wednesday May 20, 2026 @01:17PM (#48210961)
I've tried the fediverse but beef and coconut aren't there, so there's just no point.