News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by kitsune_ on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @08:18AM (#4808830)
What about due dilligence? The fact that this can happen boggles my mind.
Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by chollida1 on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @08:33AM (#4808891)
I once asked this when I started at the hedge fund I currently work at.

The answer I got was that for a large company, hiding things on the balance sheet is like getting a home inspection and finding out later that the house has some big problems with it. The point being is that inspections find somethings but can never find all issues.

What they meant was that if you dig deep enough you can always find out the problems, but when your going through the aquisition, you often don't have the proper access to the records you want, or the time to do the entire audit.

HP has owned autonomy for over a year and just found out this quarter. There is no way they would have had such access to autonomy's books during the due diligence phase nor is there anyway that autonomy would have let them take over a year to do their due diligence

Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by chernevik on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @09:08AM (#4809032)
Here the fundamental problem seems to be a very poor understanding of Autonomy's marketing and margins models.

CNBC is reporting that Autonomy was booking losses on hardware sales as marketing expense, and that its arrangements with resellers amounted to kickbacks. That may reflect improper accounting and practice. But any serious understanding of how the company goes to market and wins business should locate these expenses and arrangements no matter where they reside on the income statement -- and having located them, realized their implications for the value of the business. Clearly HP missed these items, which means they didn't understand the business model. The End.

Maybe Deloitte did a poor job on Autonomy's books. But anyone spending this kind of money at these multiples on the basis of an auditor's opinion is an idiot. And it does not speak well of HP that they are trying to place responsibility for this on someone outside their organization.

Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by objclxt on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @09:20AM (#4809090)
> "And it does not speak well of HP that they are trying to place responsibility for this on someone outside their organization."

If HP are prepared to pass on their information to the SEC and SFO, as well as talk about potential civil action, it would suggest they believe they have a valid case and this isn't just pomp and bluster for the benefit of shareholders.

I'm not saying the acquisition wasn't a stupid idea, or that HP's auditors couldn't have spotted these problems sooner - but if what HP claim is true then you can't hold it entirely against HP and the auditors.

Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by chernevik on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @09:40AM (#4809153)
The point is that a proper understanding of the business model allows you to conduct valuations, capturing all revenues and expenses, away from the financial statements. Those should absolutely reconcile back to statements. But they aren't driven by statement classification of items. Properly done, those models would have shown these problems.

HP is essentially saying "They didn't tell us X was in the marketing costs!" Well, then HP weren't asking the right questions about marketing strategy and drivers, and about relationships with customers and partners.

Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by objclxt on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @09:52AM (#4809196)
I take your point - what I meant to add in my reply but forgot to was that I doubt allocation of marketing spend / revenue was the only problem. Autonomy's revenue in 2010 was $870m - I'm sure the accounting issues are considerably more complex than what's been reported so far.

I don't think HP escape culpability, but for all we know someone at the auditors or HP were asking the right questions, and were being deliberately misled.

Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by macspoofing on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @11:33AM (#4809745)
>it would suggest they believe they have a valid case and this isn't just pomp and bluster for the benefit of shareholders

Or trying to save face.

Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by wpietri on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @10:50AM (#4809463)
If somebody has committed fraud, I think it's entirely reasonable to say so.

The responsibility is, of course, HP's. And they know that, which is why they took the writedown. But the blame for crime falls on the criminals.

Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by cperciva on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @08:40AM (#4808916)
I understand that due diligence is hard and there's always going to be things which get missed... but I have trouble understanding how it's possible to miss 8.8 billion dollars.
Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by chollida1 on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @09:38AM (#4809142)
> but I have trouble understanding how it's possible to miss 8.8 billion dollars.

I think we all are this morning. Unfortunetly the chatter we are hearing is that this type of accounting cover up, if true, would require help from their auditor.

Which means we may be down another accounting firm by the time this is over.

Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by jfb on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @09:41AM (#4809157)
It's also not in anyone's immediate short-term interest to find a reason to scotch an 1.0x10^10$ deal, and whatever we'll kick this stinker of a deal down the road for the next CEO/CFO/&c.
Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by benth on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @03:00PM (#4811018)
I agree. When I heard HP was buying Autonomy for that much, I immediately thought of MS's purchase of aQuantive. And now both end up with huge write-downs.
Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by specialist on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @04:43PM (#4811508)
From what I've read: Audits verify the math, not detect fraud.

Fraud detection is a lot more work aka forensic accounting.

Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by justincormack on Wednesday November 21, 2012 @03:45AM (#4813421)
Of course one of Autonomy's biggest markets was fraud detection software and discovery services for lawsuits...
Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by loceng on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @01:20PM (#4810358)
Wouldn't doing due diligence mean you spend this time, however long it requires, to find out the reality of the company? From another commenter who worked there, said KPMG (and Deloitte) were the auditors, and I can imagine HP would be suing them..
Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by chollida1 on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @02:19PM (#4810720)
> Wouldn't doing due diligence mean you spend this time, however long it requires, to find out the reality of the company?

Possibly, but consider my analogy of buying a house.

When you do a house inspection you get a professional to do it for you. You have to trust his opinion in a lot of cases and in even more cases you understand that he can't vouch for some things.

ie wiring behind walls, mold checks on hidden surfaces, foundation cracks behind finished walls.

if you wanted to do all this on your house inspection you'd have to kick out the tenants for 3-4 weeks and tear the house down to the studs to be 100% sure there were no problems.

Now go back and consider the purchase of a company by another. If they wanted to know every detail it would take 2 years and shut down the company being aquired while they do it.

No sane company would ever agree to that so you have the situation we currently have where you negotiate what the acquiring company can see and what the break fee is if they walk away.

Sadly the diligence phase is often farmed out to an IB who has no interest in seeing the deal break.

Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by loceng on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @02:27PM (#4810794)
Okay, sure. Though it's $8 billion; 80% of the value paid! It seems like the there would have been wiring exposed, pipes burst and water leaking and doing external, visible damage..
Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by josephlord on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @04:51PM (#4811543)
There was a common view at the time that they had significantly overpaid and that was based on the straight books. Also only $5BN of the write down was for Autonomy. If they overpaid by 100% (possible as they paid 64% over the share price which could also have been overvalued) then it could be that accounting irregularity accounts only for a fraction of the write down. 10-20% of the purchase price feels as likely as 80% but we may see when it is investigated.

http://www.hp.com/hpinfo/newsroom/press/2011/110818xc.html

Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by loceng on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @05:55PM (#4811831)
Ah okay, thanks for clarification. Not as dramatic then.
Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by josephlord on Wednesday November 21, 2012 @06:06AM (#4813731)
More like we don't know yet. It could be but I wouldn't jump to the 80% accounting/audit error/failure at this point.
Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by wheaties on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @08:23AM (#4808840)
Large entities can often mask accounting fraud with the helpnof an accounting firm. Think Enron and Auther Anderson. I'm pretty sure HP is going to sue the begeezus out of a number of complicent players. They should start with the former CEO of Autonomy.
Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by kitsune_ on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @08:40AM (#4808919)
Back when the deal was announced I was exteremely skeptical. $10.2 billions for a relatively unknown UK software company that focuses on document management? 10 billions?! Their (Autonomy's) past acquisitions looked rather erratic to me. I also did not understand as to why a hardware company like HP would buy a software company in the first place. Then there were all the glassdoor posts discussed here on HN... the whole deal just looked shady even back then.

edit: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2902749 I just stumbled upon this comment by AlexMuir, it was the most upvoted comment on the HN discussion about HP's acquisition of Autonomy

AlexMuir pretty much called it.

Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by maxerickson on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @08:55AM (#4808974)
One of HPs many personalities wants to be IBM (hence the software services acquisition).
Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by raverbashing on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @08:35AM (#4808899)
In fact, HP should start suing the one that had the brilliant idea of acquiring Autonomy: Leo Apotheker
Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by chollida1 on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @09:41AM (#4809155)
> In fact, HP should start suing the one that had the brilliant idea of acquiring Autonomy: Leo Apotheker

Why? for making a bad business decision?

The board approved it. That's why there is a board. The finance department at HP signed off on it. The tech department at HP looked at the tech and signed off on it.

Everyone signed off on it, it didn't' work out.

Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by raverbashing on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @03:26PM (#4811146)
Apparently, not that clear-cut

http://www.businessinsider.com/meg-whitman-hp-autonomy-blame...

"Why didn't the HP board question the purchase price in the first place? That's what Benjamin Reitzes, an analyst for Barclays Capital, asked on the call. Whitman's answer: The board wasn't responsible. The two people who were responsible, in her view, are now gone: her predecessor, Léo Apotheker and HP's longtime strategy chief, Shane Robison, who retired in November 2011, shortly after the Autonomy deal went through. "

Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by chollida1 on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @03:34PM (#4811197)
I'm not sure that invalidates anything I said.

It's true that the buck stops with the CEO. It was after all, his decision to make the deal.

My point was what are you going to sue him for? He did the right thing. He made up his mind, ran it past the board for approval, ran it past finance for approval, got an outside auditor to do due diligence.

All approved. The deal went through.

It turned out to be a stupendously bad business decision.

Should twitter be able to sue the developer who made the incredibly bad design decision to use ruby on rails and architect their system as a blog rather than than a message queue?

Bad decisions happen, people loose their jobs over them. it's much harder to sue someone when they've done the due diligence and had the decision signed off by many other people.

Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by raverbashing on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @03:54PM (#4811270)
Yes, I believe everything you said is valid, it is a bad business decision, unless evidence to something else is found.

And in the end, it was not something that was done hidden from other people, if it was a bad decision they should have stood their ground.

Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by skrebbel on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @08:41AM (#4808926)
If he got bought, yes. Otherwise, since when is making horrible business decisions a crime?
Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by raverbashing on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @09:06AM (#4809024)
It is naive, given the facts, to consider that it was a mere "horrible business decision" especially in face of the values involved
Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by rbanffy on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @10:41AM (#4809412)
They could start with the board who hired Apotheker.
Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by VonGuard on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @01:35PM (#4810446)
The same board that fired Hurd? The HP board needs to go away. They've been fucking things up for years. It's one of those situations where, after 3 CEO's, the first of which was kicking ass, maybe it's time to consider that the board is the problem, not the CEO.
Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by TheCondor on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @11:29PM (#4812775)
Yeah. The same board that spied on itself and executives to find leaks.

They are clearly part of the problem. HP's vaunted culture isn't what they think it is and that's part of the problem too. They are too big for their britches, literally, need to cut some pieces off and get smaller again before they become smaller.

Re:HP takes a $8.8 billion writeoff, alleging Autonomy accou... by mongol on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @01:11PM (#4810290)
Ah, Arthur Andersen. I had to refresh my memory by reading through its Wikipedia page. What a disaster.