News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by chad_oliver on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @03:03AM (#4808162)
This is a great solution, but it seems like it is designed to follow a random path (that is, where the wind blows). How do you prevent this from creating a false sense of security, when in fact there are areas of the desert which have not been tested?

I remember when I was little I built a small platform high up in a tree. My father refused to let me put a rail around it, because the sort of rail I could build would not be enough to stop a fall and would only encourage a sense of complacency.

Of course, I do not mean this as a criticism of the design, but merely as a path for future exploration.

Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by robotresearcher on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @03:44AM (#4808234)
A truly random path would be pretty good, since you approach perfect coverage with repeated runs. Alas, the wind direction is not random, particularly in this kind of environment.

An interesting demining approach is to buy the local villagers lots of sheep and pen them in the areas of concern. Once in a while a sheep goes boom. Meanwhile: wool and baby sheep as a side effect.

Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by bstpierre on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @08:35AM (#4808896)
Sheep like to eat stuff like grass, which does not appear to be plentiful in the areas in question. You could feed hay, but then the sheep will congregate around the area where you dump the hay instead of wandering around getting blown up. Not to mention that hay (as well as fencing, and possibly water in some of those areas) would be expensive.
Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by Cass on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @05:01AM (#4808414)
How are people supposed to shear those sheep, or take care of them during lambing/when they're sick, or to feed or water them, if they can't actually enter the pen? It seems to me that sheep penned in a land mine field would either be useless, because you couldn't go near them, or worse than useless, because they'd be a temptation to enter the dangerous area.
Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by robotresearcher on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @01:14PM (#4810310)
The point is that these people have sheep and goats already for basic subsistence. They already use these dangerous fields. By buying them more animals instead of (or as well as) spending money on expensive technical demining kit, you increase the probability of mine clearance a bit, while making the person wealthier. Sheep reproduce and excess lambs can be sold, making the process sustainable.

Similarly, training locals in demining with donated basic equipment is also good, in the sense that these new experts can sell their services locally. The down side is that these brave people take extra risk.

Both the livestock and local training methods were used in Bosnia, which had a serious landmine problem recently.

Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by nakkiel on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @05:16AM (#4808442)
Turns out sheep's will run toward whoever takes care of them.
Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by nfg on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @05:51AM (#4808495)
I take it you've never worked with sheep on a farm then...?!
Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by nakkiel on Tuesday November 27, 2012 @10:18PM (#4840839)
No, you're right, I never worked on a farm; I simply grew up in a farm.

Sheep are scared stomachs on legs. When they see their daily source of food and nothing suspicious (such as a stranger), they reach. My grandfather could also call them and they would reach even with a stranger present.

Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by bct on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @11:12AM (#4809607)
Ha.
Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by anthonyb on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @03:59AM (#4808281)
Er, that's incredibly cruel, since most landmines are designed to maim, not kill, eg. by spraying shrapnel at knee level.

That might kill sheep outright, but I doubt it.

Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by robotresearcher on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @04:09AM (#4808315)
Better sheep than the children who get blown up in the absence of sheep.
Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by anthonyb on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @04:18AM (#4808330)
Only very slightly.

Also, it suffers from the same problem as the Mine Kafon, in that it's a more-or-less random walk and you won't know whether the whole area is cleared.

Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by humbledrone on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @04:30AM (#4808350)
> Only very slightly.

Just to be clear, are you saying that it is only very slightly better for a sheep, rather than a human child, to be maimed by a land mine? That seems to be what you wrote, but I'm having a very difficult time reconciling your world view with my own, so I'm hoping that I am somehow misunderstanding.

Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by anthonyb on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @07:09AM (#4808636)
Wilfully inflicting a land mine injury on another creature? Sheep might not be as smart as people, but I bet they feel pain every bit as much as you do or a child does.

And given that, what does it say about you as a person that you'd think that it was a good idea?

Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by popopje on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @07:40AM (#4808718)
that he likes shish kebab.
Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by LaGrange on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @09:15AM (#4809063)
Both involve sentient beings. This is not about valuing children less. This is about valuing sheep more.

This might be an uncomfortable world view, taking how much we depend on non-human abuse in our civilization, but it's not the only case where we built it on abuse of others, human or not.

Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by PeterisP on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @02:53PM (#4810965)
If it was neccessary to save my child, I'd eagerly murder every sheep in the world in the most painful way possible with my hands.

Animal lives and welfare do matter, but when it comes to weighing human lives against animal lives, only a ratio of something like a million-to-one may be ethically justified. Definitely not one-to-one sheep to a kid. Definitely not even hundred-to-one. It could be reasonable to sacrifice a few humans to spare a species from extinction, but not to save some individual animals, however sentient they may be.

My fellow humans are important. Leaving a kid to die to spare a hundred sheep is disgraceful.

Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by anthonyb on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @05:27PM (#4811695)
False dichotomy much?

How about we don't murder any sheep or children, and instead spend the money that we would've spent on sheep torture on better fences, signs, education and mine clearance? While you're at it, you can lobby your elected representative to spend more than the currently pitiful amount that they do on mine clearance.

ps. A million-to-one? You have a very interesting idea of "ethics". Also of "definitely".

Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by LaGrange on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @05:16PM (#4811650)
Wow, it must be really scary to be a kid of someone with that kind of violent fantasies.

Now, as a mental exercise, I suggest you replace "animal" with a racial slur of choice. Because, seriously, 100 years ago people said that about all kinds of other people. They actually still do. Having a slightly higher amount of common DNA is not a justification of whatever-the-hell.

And at the point where you say "however sentient they may be", you just go into downright I-don't-want-to-meet-that-person-in-a-dark-alley territory.

Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by PeterisP on Monday November 26, 2012 @04:55PM (#4834256)
The first sentence was an overexagerration, but I have had near-death experience for my kid, and that makes you reconsider various things in life seriously. I am certainly not a violent person whatsoever, but from that incident I understood that I would disregard almost everything if stakes were that high once more.

But, coming back to the original issue - it all comes down to two different theories of ethics, opinions about what is good and just: in essence, if some choice equals to murdering one to save ten others [a simplification for the sake of argument, assume that no alternatives exist] , would doing so be good or evil?

There are valid arguments to say that doing so would be evil by the nature of the act.

There are valid arguments to say that not doing so would be evil, by the result of the act (10 others dying instead of 1).

And I do value a human life of "a racial slur of choice" more than a hundred sheep - archaic laws did value human lives in a couple dozen of domestic animals, and that whas when a peasant's life was considered cheap; we can and should be better than that.

And I do value my kids life more than your life - that is also quite natural, I doubt that you'd find any parents who think otherwise.

It all adds up. I mean, if you start discussing life and death, then most solutions aren't pretty; and discussing only 'pure' solutions means not saving (= murdering) lives - such as the lives of people that could have been saved by some sheep.

Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by mamoswined on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @09:49AM (#4809187)
You do realize these sheep are not pets and are not treated as such in Afghanistan, right? They will be used for milk, wool, and some will be slaughtered for meat.

This makes sense for the people who live there- the dessert is not an easy place to grow crops and a multi-purpose animal is very valuable for survival purposes. Animal rights is a tough sell in a place like this.

It seems like an ineffective non-systematic way to de-mine that damages animals that the Afghans value though.

Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by LaGrange on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @12:12PM (#4809975)
Of course — I said dependance. Just as we depend on abuse of countless people, and we can't stop either overnight. It doesn't change the fact that it's horrible one bit.
Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by jrabone on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @04:51AM (#4808388)
Thinking as a farming peasant, perhaps your child is probably worth less to me than my sheep? Only one is going to feed my family and keep me warm.
Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by natrius on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @05:11AM (#4808433)
You're intending to be counter-intuitively insightful, but there are few scenarios in which a sheep is more valuable than a child. You could sell a child for more than you could sell a sheep. The children who are in the most danger from mines are past infancy, and that is when children begin to be worth more than they cost to maintain if you aren't sending them to school.
Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by bct on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @11:13AM (#4809616)
It's worse than that, because sheep don't walk around randomly; they follow repetitive, collectively-defined paths, like most herd animals.
Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by mamoswined on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @09:53AM (#4809202)
Multiple types of animals have been trained (EG http://www.cnn.com/2010/WORLD/africa/09/07/herorats.detect.l...) to detect land mines. Most animals have much more highly developed senses than ours. It is possible that the flocks of sheep would learn over time to avoid landmines. It's possibly they already do this. It would be better to teach the local people how to train animals than to damage their valuable livestock.
Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by tomrod on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @02:21PM (#4810741)
Instead of sheep (which apparently require a lot of contact)--how many emu farms in the US have gone bankrupt recently?
Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by huhtenberg on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @03:57AM (#4808272)
Truly random paths would give you the 97.8% probability that there are no mines left, over a course of N field traversals. Obviously, that ain't good enough.
Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by robotresearcher on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @04:07AM (#4808309)
That's not true for N=1,2 or 3. If you mean as N approaches infinity, coverage approaches 97.8%, how do you figure that?
Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by _djo_ on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @04:57AM (#4808405)
Only if you assume totally flat terrain and 100% probability of the Mine Kafon detonating each mine it passes over, neither of which are likely.
Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by capsicum on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @04:06AM (#4808302)
but because of the low cost we can create a lot of these and let them run over a long period of time.
Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by lostlogin on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @08:44AM (#4808934)
Surely the trip to collect the thing after it passes out the minefield is an issue, it could take days to retrieve.
Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @10:59PM (#4812691)
Piece of string on a reel?
Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by marcamillion on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @03:50AM (#4808247)
One alternative to this is to just create lanes with rope.

i.e. you drive a stake in the ground on either side of the field (if that's even possible) and just create a lane where each of these rollers roll through.

It won't work in every single landmine, but it can provide a 'grid' within which you know what has been cleared and what has not.

Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by jontas on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @04:25AM (#4808344)
When they're handing out jobs, I sure hope I'm not the one assigned to drive these stakes and run the ropes through the minefields :)
Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by viraptor on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @10:17AM (#4809314)
You don't have to run them through the minefield really. You could potentially start from the side and drag two ends of the lines from the side.

May be harder with heavy / long lines / wind, but come on - we can build hanging bridges over very high canyons without anyone levitating to the other side first ;)

Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines by marcamillion on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @02:38PM (#4810871)
That's exactly what I was referring to.