Re:Hipmunk Raises Money And Is Immediately Threatened By Pat...
by daledavies on Monday November 19, 2012 @11:06AM
(#4804914)
Every time I read an article like this I feel enraged, as I'm sure many other people do too.
I'm a UK resident currently working on a suite of business apps, when I eventually am able to launch the company and (hopefully) make some money what can I do to avoid being a victim of patent trolls?
Seems actively seeking to avoid violating patents could get me into more trouble than doing nothing!
Re:Hipmunk Raises Money And Is Immediately Threatened By Pat...
by joonix on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @12:36AM
(#4807890)
Just keep doing what you're doing, in the UK, try not to open yourself up to US jurisdiction if you don't have to. Keep assets out of there.
If you really are infringing and concerned, I'd see about proactively getting favorable licenses while you're tiny, in case you get big.
If you aren't infringing and it's a bunch of crap, like the Hipmunk case, I'd do what they did. Seek a declaratory judgment and call their bluff. After all, the troll might not even have money to fund a real battle. If their lawyers are working on contingency (they often are), they won't waste their money pursuing something with no real shot.
Re:Hipmunk Raises Money And Is Immediately Threatened By Pat...
by astrodust on Monday November 19, 2012 @12:00PM
(#4805217)
You could always put in your terms and conditions that your application cannot be used inside the United States and then actively reject those users. It's an ugly way to go about doing business, though, kind of the opposite of Hulu.
The best plan is to retain a lawyer you trust who can help you deal with these things if and when they arise.
Re:Hipmunk Raises Money And Is Immediately Threatened By Pat...
by thaumaturgy on Monday November 19, 2012 @02:26PM
(#4805920)
Make contact with a business attorney you think you can trust -- not necessarily to retain them now, but so that you'll be acquainted when your business gets going.
Add a little extra to the margin in your pricing for a legal war chest. Make sure that money stays liquid.
If you receive a patent threat from someone, call up your attorney friend and pay him to respond with a letter.
Re:Hipmunk Raises Money And Is Immediately Threatened By Pat...
by pwg on Monday November 19, 2012 @12:24PM
(#4805320)
And the patent has already expired:
Patent number 5,345,551 was filed on November 9, 1992. That makes it a 17 years from issue date patent.
It issued on September 6, 1994. September 6, 1994 + 17 years is September 6, 2011. The patent expired over one year ago. It is dead, one can no longer by sued for doing anything it claims.
Re:Hipmunk Raises Money And Is Immediately Threatened By Pat...
by jimktrains2 on Monday November 19, 2012 @12:42PM
(#4805430)
According to http://www.uspto.gov/patents/process/status/ it is a patent case, which I interpret to mean it's still in force. (After the captcha, select patent number and enter 5345551, note the lack of commas)(IANAL and could be wrong.) (Sorry, I can't link directly to the page, it's a crappy application).
Re:Hipmunk Raises Money And Is Immediately Threatened By Pat...
by pwg on Monday November 19, 2012 @05:40PM
(#4806685)
That look-up just reports that the application became a patent. That status there does not determine its expiration date. Barring something exceptional it died over a year ago.
I'm a UK resident currently working on a suite of business apps, when I eventually am able to launch the company and (hopefully) make some money what can I do to avoid being a victim of patent trolls?
Seems actively seeking to avoid violating patents could get me into more trouble than doing nothing!
If you really are infringing and concerned, I'd see about proactively getting favorable licenses while you're tiny, in case you get big.
If you aren't infringing and it's a bunch of crap, like the Hipmunk case, I'd do what they did. Seek a declaratory judgment and call their bluff. After all, the troll might not even have money to fund a real battle. If their lawyers are working on contingency (they often are), they won't waste their money pursuing something with no real shot.
The best plan is to retain a lawyer you trust who can help you deal with these things if and when they arise.
Depressingly, nothing.
Add a little extra to the margin in your pricing for a legal war chest. Make sure that money stays liquid.
If you receive a patent threat from someone, call up your attorney friend and pay him to respond with a letter.
Patent number 5,345,551 was filed on November 9, 1992. That makes it a 17 years from issue date patent.
It issued on September 6, 1994. September 6, 1994 + 17 years is September 6, 2011. The patent expired over one year ago. It is dead, one can no longer by sued for doing anything it claims.