News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Man Arrested At Airport for Unusual Watch by neurotech1 on Sunday November 18, 2012 @01:03PM (#4801073)
BTW Sgt. JD Nelson of the Alameda County Bomb Squad is not some rookie. He is the explosives guy on Mythbusters.

There quite possibly could have been a reason why Sgt Nelson thought this went beyond a piece of art.

Re:Man Arrested At Airport for Unusual Watch by shrikant on Sunday November 18, 2012 @01:26PM (#4801128)
I'm all for civil liberties, but the info in this case is actually quite thin. I'd keep the pitchforks and torches away till a fuller picture emerges.

The facts of the case so far are:

1) Dude is outfitted in camo, watch that looks like an IED timer, and shoes rigged out like the "shoe bomber".

2) Dude gets pulled aside and claims it's all art.

3) Dude gets arrested.

Getting flagged for questioning because of (1) seems straightforward to me.

How it went from (2) to (3) is less clear, and it might be prudent to hold off the hand-wringing for now.

Re:Man Arrested At Airport for Unusual Watch by saalweachter on Sunday November 18, 2012 @04:09PM (#4801680)
You've got to look at four probabilities: X, probability someone wears a geeky watch with exposed toggles and electronics; Y, probability someone wears military-style clothing; Z, probability someone wears oversized shoes; W, probability someone is a terrorist.

I'm betting X * Y * Z is still much larger than W.

Re:Man Arrested At Airport for Unusual Watch by jQueryIsAwesome on Sunday November 18, 2012 @06:13PM (#4802051)
You forgot to add investigation; that would be really easy checking his website and seeing that he has been an artist for many years and that he always dress wierd.

And lets not forget that they could have easily break his shoes and see if he was actually hiding something inside those.

Re:Man Arrested At Airport for Unusual Watch by jQueryIsAwesome on Sunday November 18, 2012 @02:49PM (#4801404)
Who is going to tell you how it went from 2 or 3? The TSA? That would be certainly unbiased.

The fact is that he was arrested for having a wierd outfit. If somebody believes that this guy who has been an artist for many years, flies a lot and registered his domain in 1995 is a actually a terrorist they are delusional and shouldn't be in charge of any kind of law enforcement.

Re:Man Arrested At Airport for Unusual Watch by dkokelley on Sunday November 18, 2012 @05:05PM (#4801856)
> "The fact is that he was arrested for having a wierd [sic] outfit."

It's not possible to know that yet. It may never be possible, if the TSA withholds certain information, or that information never becomes part of the public record.

Re:Man Arrested At Airport for Unusual Watch by jQueryIsAwesome on Sunday November 18, 2012 @06:02PM (#4802017)
Oh yeah, is actually possible that they voluntarily omitted crucial information in their report that would make them look as the heroes they really are. /s
Re:Man Arrested At Airport for Unusual Watch by ScottBurson on Sunday November 18, 2012 @02:09PM (#4801246)
Disagree. The fact that McGann actually has a Web site demonstrating his artistic bona fides is plenty of evidence for me.
Re:Man Arrested At Airport for Unusual Watch by SoftwareMaven on Sunday November 18, 2012 @02:27PM (#4801307)
Because you can believe everything you read online, right? It wouldn't be hard to fake that?

I tend to think there is more to this as well, including plenty of Gestapo ass-hattery from the police and the TSA. I just wonder if part of the art project included being arrested. We may be witnessing a piece of performance art.

Re:Man Arrested At Airport for Unusual Watch by readme on Sunday November 18, 2012 @03:03PM (#4801446)
Honestly I don't think they were in the wrong for stopping the guy. Arrest was probably too much, but when you are wearing a watch that looks like a bomb detonator, you should definitely be stopped and questioned.

Unfortunately every member of the TSA cannot be an expert in this man's artwork to understand what he actually had in his posession. Suspicious watches (and protruding wires!) are one of the things they are trained to look for as all of the 9/11 hijackers had digital casio wrist watches. So yeah, honestly I think confiscating the watch and stopping him was a good move. Maybe even denying him his flight would be sane.

What does it take for you guys to agree that someone shouldn't get on a plane, a backpack full of c4!? The idea is to stop the disaster before it happens, and at this point all we have are vague clues. Not to mention the fact that for economic reasons, each TSA officer is going to be a layman who probably isn't well versed in electronics.

Combine this with the fact that it looked like he "hid" it under his coat... This guy needs to use some discretion when flying, I'm sorry!

As much as I disagree with the erosion of our civil liberties, wearing a watch that looks like a bomb detonator onto a plane is not a smart move. Sure, us HNers would know the difference between art and a real device. The general public does not, and we cannot expect them all to gain our same level of competence with electronics.

Finally, the TSA stopped someone that was actually suspicious.

Re:Man Arrested At Airport for Unusual Watch by ncallaway on Sunday November 18, 2012 @03:17PM (#4801499)
I don't think many people complained that this guy received extra scrutiny. If something looks/seems suspicious it's acceptable to apply a higher level of scrutiny in determining the actual risk. The article acknowledges this, and says it's pretty reasonable that they stopped him, talked to him, and would have been reasonable if they had asked him to mail the device to himself.

What's totally unreasonable in any context is the fact that this guy was CHARGED WITH A CRIME, and is now sitting in jail on $150,000 bail. He will have to go through a lengthy trial process and potentially serve jail-time. Unless the facts are contrary to what the article presents (which is possible), this is totally unreasonable.

Re:Man Arrested At Airport for Unusual Watch by mikeash on Sunday November 18, 2012 @05:09PM (#4801867)
> What does it take for you guys to agree that someone shouldn't get on a plane, a backpack full of c4!?

Are you seriously satirizing the idea that the line should be drawn at items that are actually dangerous?

Re:Man Arrested At Airport for Unusual Watch by readme on Monday November 19, 2012 @09:50AM (#4804553)
Yes!

Mainly, because a terrorist would not walk by the TSA with a gun, bomb, knife, or whatever now. Unless they were just an idiot. Most terrorism is organized. So they would have a plan. They send people in advance to take pictures of the airport and find other entrances. There are ways into the secure areas of airports if you look.

That's why at an airport every employee has the task of challenging people. Every single employee is always watching for suspicious behavior.

So if it is a terrorist attack, the TSA is not going to see a bomb. They might see a tiny hint of something to come, but no one is going to walk by the TSA with a WMD. They are more sophisticated than this and have other ways of getting them in.

Re:Man Arrested At Airport for Unusual Watch by Saavedro on Monday November 19, 2012 @02:09AM (#4803288)
I don't see why not. That's the wrong place to draw the line.

If there is no penalty for trying to board a plane while with lookalike dangerous items, then there is nothing to deter one from "probing" the screening for weaknesses, and the system is worthless.

Re:Man Arrested At Airport for Unusual Watch by KeliNorth on Sunday November 18, 2012 @01:23PM (#4801122)
No, what it means is that Sgt. Nelson knows how to work with bombs. It doesn't make him a subject matter expert on terrorism or art. Just bombs. And as charged, yes, the subject of the article did have materials needed to make bombs minus the explosives.

Everyone who has a timer/watch/cellphone does, which is the point of why this is so ridiculous. If you arrest everyone who has all the materials necessary to make a bomb minus the explosives, everyone would be arrested.

Re:Man Arrested At Airport for Unusual Watch by UnoriginalGuy on Sunday November 18, 2012 @01:37PM (#4801149)
This is what I brought up in the last thread. IEDs are IEDs because they can be made from almost anything.

Now it does take skills which most people don't have; but this isn't about skills it is about physical kit, and purely in terms of the physical stuff needed I'm almost certain you could buy it all at the airport in the "secure" part (e.g. travel clock).

Re:Man Arrested At Airport for Unusual Watch by mikeryan on Sunday November 18, 2012 @01:36PM (#4801147)
There's more to making a detonator then just the timing device.
Re:Man Arrested At Airport for Unusual Watch by incision on Sunday November 18, 2012 @01:35PM (#4801143)
>He is the explosives guy on Mythbusters.

I don't know what's worse...

The idea that knowing how to blow stuff up qualifies you to profile folks as potential terrorists or that being consulted for a TV show qualifies you for anything.

Re:Man Arrested At Airport for Unusual Watch by astrodust on Sunday November 18, 2012 @01:39PM (#4801156)
If you work in the explosives business, maybe everything looks like a bomb to you.
Re:Man Arrested At Airport for Unusual Watch by dlgeek on Sunday November 18, 2012 @01:24PM (#4801124)
The original article I read yesterday (from /.) said the bomb squad cleared him but he was arrested anyway.
Re:Man Arrested At Airport for Unusual Watch by driverdan on Sunday November 18, 2012 @02:25PM (#4801296)
If all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.