News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Quiet Resurgence of RF Engineering by cactacea on Monday April 27, 2026 @03:17PM (#47926002)
> I've worked in the aerospace industry for the past 8 years, and for most of that time I felt like I could confidently say that RF engineering felt like it was a quiet, non evolving field.

Not an EE myself but honestly baffled how the author got that impression with the huge expansion of RF engineering in the consumer space - particularly with 3/4/5G/LTE networks and 802.1x. Maybe this is just an artifact of working on building weapons (i.e. defense) and being in the US?

Re:The Quiet Resurgence of RF Engineering by amoshebb on Monday April 27, 2026 @03:55PM (#47926509)
Also ignoring the massive new market that has been automotive radars which, as a market, have totally eclipsed weapons
Re:The Quiet Resurgence of RF Engineering by greggsy on Monday April 27, 2026 @05:40PM (#47927715)
It’s a big market but theres only a handful of use cases and R&D requirements, compared to military where the use cases and niche requirements are still continually evolving.

Mil systems have severely constrained supply chain limitations too, while consumer vehicle systems can comfortably be produced in their millions from China.

Re:The Quiet Resurgence of RF Engineering by esseph on Monday April 27, 2026 @06:15PM (#47928111)
Anti-drone is sucking up a lot of time and money from a lot of people right now. Every country is looking for both defensive and offense tools.

Mil is huge

Re:The Quiet Resurgence of RF Engineering by sleepycat801 on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @04:11AM (#47931718)
That is something requiring new antenna design, but was a spin off from FMCW radar already used on ships.
Re:The Quiet Resurgence of RF Engineering by dTal on Monday April 27, 2026 @03:22PM (#47926079)
Bit older than 8 years but even cramming a working GPS reciever into a phone was a huge, nontrivial achievement.
Re:The Quiet Resurgence of RF Engineering by antonvs on Monday April 27, 2026 @06:03PM (#47927993)
Was it? My memory is that there were GPS watches (e.g. Garmin) before GPS became common in phones. Wasn't the miniaturization already there by the time phones started integrating GPS?
Re:The Quiet Resurgence of RF Engineering by angry_octet on Monday April 27, 2026 @09:28PM (#47929475)
It's all about power -- the computation required for processing the signal in the presence of noise, multi path fading etc. The RF part is not the limitation.
Re:The Quiet Resurgence of RF Engineering by bigfatkitten on Monday April 27, 2026 @04:28PM (#47926907)
Even in defense, the advancements being made in fields like radar are incredible.
Re:The Quiet Resurgence of RF Engineering by idkyall on Monday April 27, 2026 @08:28PM (#47929001)
Radar improvements have also propagated to consumer fields. You can buy a mmWave presence sensor for smart home purposes for ~$40 on Amazon, and the raw sensors for $2-4 in bulk from Aliexpress. I remember seeing tech demos of mmWave in college used for imaging humans through tent fabric and dust storms, and now they're cheap enough you could put one in every room of your house.
Re:The Quiet Resurgence of RF Engineering by saltcured on Monday April 27, 2026 @04:38PM (#47927019)
Isn't the issue that this kind of RF is a lot like designing CPUs? There aren't many economically viable products that don't just use a COTS highly integrated circuit, so there aren't that many full on design jobs to go along with all the usage.

The product work is higher level system packaging, such as antennas and application-level manipulation of the whole RF block. But since so much is digital now, that is more software/computer architecture work rather than RF. The COTS RF circuit itself may have standardized serial or even packet interfaces to the rest of the product.

Re:The Quiet Resurgence of RF Engineering by willis936 on Monday April 27, 2026 @07:35PM (#47928706)
I'm not an RF insider, but RFSoCs and deep budgets are a thing. I don't really see this as a constraint.

If you are budget constrained then you just design your signal chain in discretes like everyone else.

Re:The Quiet Resurgence of RF Engineering by saltcured on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @04:07PM (#47939949)
My point was that the examples above like WiFi and 5G are solved with highly integrated COTS modules, not small players designing their own radios.

The fact that there is a large market for end-user products does not translate into lots of design teams in a global sense. Much like there are lots of computer use cases but not that many CPU design teams you can really hire into.

Re:The Quiet Resurgence of RF Engineering by loodish on Monday April 27, 2026 @06:28PM (#47928254)
> Not an EE myself but honestly baffled how the author got that impression with the huge expansion of RF engineering in the consumer space -

Lots of RF devices doesn't actually mean much RF engineering.

If you want 5G connectivity almost everyone buys an integrated module. Chip, antenna, and certifications included. No serious RF engineering required, no RF engineer in the building.

Those modules designers would be purchasing their chip from one of a few companies, like Qualcomm or MediaTek. Even then most of the work isn't RF engineering, it's stitching together a product and grinding through the certifications.

Much of the innovation is done away from the consumer space where certifications are less constraining.

Re:The Quiet Resurgence of RF Engineering by protocolture on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @02:35AM (#47931083)
Theres multiple duelling companies just in the class license antenna space. Like not even emitters, just designing compatible antennas for other peoples telco products.

Theres the whole thing where all the wigig chips that dell binned got upcycled into a companies flagship rf product.

Cambium v Ubiquiti has been an ongoing contest. Add Mikrotik in for good measure.

RF Elements is always trying to sell me something new.

Aviat has bought out NEC's famous flagship RF line, at least in terms of US distribution.

Theres enough happening.

Re:The Quiet Resurgence of RF Engineering by brianpan on Monday April 27, 2026 @10:45PM (#47929957)
3/4/5G/LTE networks and 802.1x predate their 8 years in aerospace. I worked on some of those 25 years ago. If you're not an EE, maybe you also didn't consider the lead time of working on HW to its adoption.
Re:The Quiet Resurgence of RF Engineering by sleepycat801 on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @04:07AM (#47931688)
I agree with the author, certainly 5 years ago most things looked like a "solved problem". Huawei gave the telco equipment makers a run for their money with some interesting applications of SDR, but incumbents preferred trade barriers and export restrictions to competition. Even 5G was more of an optimisation of LTE than a revolution. Baseband over fibre is the only major innovation in that period which I can think of.